Photoconductive Effects in Single Crystals of BaZrS$_3$

Boyang Zhao, Huandong Chen, Ragib Ahsan, Fei Hou, Eric R. Hoglund, Shantanu Singh, Huan Zhao, Han Htoon, Andrey Krayev, Maruda Shanmugasundaram, Patrick E. Hopkins, Jan Seidel, Rehan Kapadia, Jayakanth Ravichandran

TL;DR

Researchers have confirmed that the emerging solar material $\text{BaZrS}_3$ is a p-type semiconductor and discovered that standard surface preparation—specifically mechanical polishing—severely degrades its performance. By switching to crystal cleaving, they reduced response times from nearly 30 seconds to just 2 seconds, highlighting that managing processing-induced defects is the next major hurdle for chalcogenide perovskite electronics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Chalcogenide perovskites like $\text{BaZrS}_3$ are the "sturdier cousins" of the famous halide perovskites used in next-gen solar cells. They offer excellent light absorption and thermal stability without using toxic lead. However, while we have seen progress in thin films, we haven't fully understood the intrinsic limits of the material or how defects influence charge carrier behavior.

A major practical challenge is that $\text{BaZrS}_3$ crystals naturally form an insulating oxide/sulfate layer on their surface when exposed to air. To make electrical contact, researchers usually polish this layer off. This paper investigates whether that "cleaning" process actually does more harm than good by introducing sub-surface damage that traps electrons and holes.

Methods

The team grew high-quality $\text{BaZrS}_3$ single crystals using a $\text{BaCl}_2$ flux method. To study the impact of surface processing, they compared two methods of removing the surface oxide:

  1. Mechanical Polishing: Using a fine 12,000-mesh cloth.
  2. Cleaving: Physically breaking the crystal to expose a fresh, internal surface.

They characterized these surfaces using a suite of advanced microscopy techniques:

  • Kelvin Probe Force Microscopy (KPFM): To measure the work function and determine the semiconductor type (n-type vs. p-type).
  • Scanning Transmission Electron Microscopy (STEM): To visualize atomic-scale defects beneath the surface.
  • Scanning Photocurrent Microscopy (SPCM): To map how current flows across the device under laser excitation.
  • Time-Resolved Photoluminescence (TRPL): To measure how long photo-excited carriers survive before recombining.

Datasets

As an experimental materials science paper, this work does not use large-scale public datasets. Instead, it generates and analyzes original experimental data, including:

  • Photocurrent response curves under various light intensities and wavelengths.
  • STEM cross-sectional images of polished vs. cleaved interfaces.
  • Work function measurements for $\text{BaZrS}_3$ compared to a Highly Oriented Pyrolytic Graphite (HOPG) reference.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The P-Type Confirmation: Using KPFM under illumination, the researchers observed a positive surface photovoltage (a decrease in work function). This provides strong experimental evidence that $\text{BaZrS}_3$ behaves as a p-type semiconductor, resolving a key question for device architecture.
  • Polishing is a "Defect Factory": STEM imaging revealed that even "gentle" mechanical polishing creates a 300 nm thick "damage zone" filled with dislocations, stacking faults, and grain boundaries.
  • Trap-Dominated Transport: In polished crystals, the photocurrent response was sluggish. The carriers get "stuck" in the defects created by polishing, leading to a response dominated by traps rather than the intrinsic properties of the crystal.
  • Cleaving Restores Performance: Cleaved crystals showed significantly better linearity and much faster response times, behaving similarly to high-quality epitaxial thin films. This suggests that the "intrinsic" performance of $\text{BaZrS}_3$ is much higher than previously thought, but it is easily masked by poor processing.

Key Results

  • Work Function: Measured at 4.44 ± 0.02 eV.
  • Response Times: The rise/decay times for photocurrent improved dramatically from 18s/26s (polished) to 2s/2s (cleaved).
  • Power Law Scaling ($\theta$): The relationship between light intensity ($P$) and photocurrent follows $I \propto P^\theta$. Cleaved crystals achieved a $\theta$ of 0.67 (close to the 0.71 seen in high-end films), while polished crystals lagged at 0.29, indicating heavy trap interference.
  • Responsivity: The devices achieved a responsivity of ~0.3 A/W under 532 nm excitation, equivalent to an external quantum efficiency (EQE) of ~0.18.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that while cleaving is better than polishing, it isn't perfect. $\text{BaZrS}_3$ has an orthorhombic structure with no easy-to-cleave plane, resulting in uneven, jagged surfaces that make it difficult to deposit precise metal electrodes.

Future work will need to focus on:

  1. Surface Passivation: Finding chemical ways to remove the oxide layer without mechanical force.
  2. Contact Optimization: Developing better methods to create ohmic contacts on uneven cleaved surfaces.
  3. Heterojunctions: Moving from simple two-terminal "resistor" style devices to actual p-n junctions to push toward high-efficiency solar cells.

Summary updated

Abstract

Chalcogenide perovskites, such as BaZrS$_3$, are emerging semiconductors with potential for high photovoltaic power conversion efficiency. The role of defects in the efficiency of the generation and collection of photo-excited carriers has not been experimentally investigated extensively. We study the effect of processing-induced defects on the photoconductive properties of single crystals of BaZrS$_3$. We achieved ohmic contacts to single crystals of BaZrS$_3$ and observed positive surface photovoltage, which is typically observed in p-type semiconductors. However, mechanical polishing of BaZrS$_3$ to remove the surface oxide leads to dense deformation grain boundaries and leads to trap-dominated photoconductive response. In comparison, ohmic contacts achieved in cleaved crystals leave fewer deformation defects and greatly improve optoelectronic properties. Defect-controlled crystal growth and contact fabrication are potentially limiting factors for achieving high photon-to-excited electron conversion efficiency in BaZrS$_3$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2024photoconductive,
  author = {Boyang Zhao and Huandong Chen and Ragib Ahsan and Fei Hou and Eric R. Hoglund and Shantanu Singh and Huan Zhao and Han Htoon and Andrey Krayev and Maruda Shanmugasundaram and Patrick E. Hopkins and Jan Seidel and Rehan Kapadia and Jayakanth Ravichandran},
  title = {{Photoconductive Effects in Single Crystals of BaZrS$\_3$}},
  booktitle = {ACS},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1021/acsphotonics.3c01563},
}

Loading related content...

Figure