Abstract
Lifetimes of bound states of protein complexes or biomolecule folded states typically decrease when subject to mechanical force. However, a plethora of biological systems exhibit the counter-intuitive phenomenon of catch bonding, where non-covalent bonds become stronger under externally applied forces. The quest to understand the origin of catch-bond behavior has lead to the development of phenomenological and microscopic theories that can quantitatively recapitulate experimental data. Here, we assess the successes and limitations of such theories in explaining experimental data. The most widely applied approach is a phenomenological two-state model, which fits all of the available data on a variety of complexes: actomyosin, kinetochore-microtubule, selectin-ligand, and cadherin-catenin binding to filamentous actin. With a primary focus on the selectin family of cell-adhesion complexes, we discuss the positives and negatives of phenomenological models and the importance of evaluating the physical relevance of fitting parameters. We describe a microscopic theory for selectins, which provides a structural basis for catch bonds and predicts a crucial allosteric role for residues Asn82--Glu88. We emphasize the need for new theories and simulations that can mimic experimental conditions, given the complex response of cell adhesion complexes to force and their potential role in a variety of biological contexts.
Introduction: The Counter-Intuitive Nature of Catch Bonds
In the macroscopic world, tension typically accelerates failure; pulling on a rope makes it more likely to snap. In molecular biology, this standard behavior is termed a "slip bond," where the bond lifetime decreases exponentially with applied force. However, many essential biological processes—such as wound healing, leukocyte trafficking, and chromosome segregation—rely on "catch bonds." These specialized non-covalent interactions strengthen under mechanical stress, with bond lifetimes increasing as force is applied up to a critical threshold.
A classic example is the "rolling" of white blood cells along the vascular endothelium. This process is mediated by selectin-ligand complexes that must withstand the shear forces of blood flow to slow the cell down before it can extravasate into tissue. Understanding how these bonds respond to force requires moving beyond simple observations to robust theoretical models.
Theoretical Frameworks for Modeling Force-Dependent Lifetimes
Researchers have developed several approaches to model catch bond behavior, ranging from abstract mathematical fits to detailed structural simulations.
- Phenomenological Two-State Model: This is the most common approach. It assumes the molecular complex can exist in two distinct states: a weak-binding state and a strong-binding state. Applied force shifts the equilibrium toward the stronger state. While this model uses the Bell Equation to fit experimental data with high precision, its parameters (such as "transition state distances") often lack direct physical counterparts.
- Microscopic Structure-Based Theories: Developed primarily for the selectin family, these models use multi-dimensional energy landscapes derived from atomic-resolution crystal structures. By employing a Fokker-Planck formalism, researchers can calculate dissociation rates based on physical variables like the number of hydrogen bonds and domain orientation.
- Sliding-Rebinding Model: This simulation-based framework suggests that force causes a ligand to "slide" within its binding pocket, facilitating the formation of new, stabilizing contacts that were previously inaccessible.
Key Results and Experimental Validation
The theories are evaluated against diverse datasets, including kinetochore-microtubule attachments and various selectin-ligand pairs (e.g., P-selectin and L-selectin with PSGL-1).
A significant success of the phenomenological two-state model is its ability to describe not only "biphasic" behavior (where the bond strengthens then weakens) but also "triphasic" behavior (slip-catch-slip) observed in complex systems like the von Willebrand factor. However, the microscopic model offers deeper insights into the structural "switches" involved. For selectins, the transition from a "bent" to an "extended" conformation under force acts as a mechanical trigger. Specifically, a loop involving residues Asn82–Glu88 undergoes a structural shift in the extended state, allowing for the formation of six additional hydrogen bonds with the ligand—a feature that is structurally impossible in the bent state.
Discussion: Allostery and the Simulation Gap
Catch bonds are frequently regulated by allostery, where structural changes far from the binding interface dictate the bond's response to force. This highlights a limitation of many current computational approaches. Steered Molecular Dynamics (SMD) simulations often utilize pulling rates that are orders of magnitude faster than physiological conditions, potentially masking the true equilibrium dynamics of the bond.
Furthermore, while phenomenological models are universal, they are often "black boxes." Microscopic models provide a more predictive framework, successfully forecasting how specific mutations to ligands like PSGL-1 alter bond lifetimes. This structural understanding is vital for designing therapeutics that can modulate cell adhesion.
Conclusion and Future Directions
The field is transitioning from merely fitting data to understanding the underlying physics of mechanotransduction. Future work must address the gap between average bond lifetimes and the complex distributions often seen in single-molecule experiments. There is also a pressing need for general microscopic theories that can be applied beyond the selectin family to other important complexes like integrins and cadherins. Developing simulations that operate at realistic physiological loading rates remains a primary challenge for the next generation of mechanobiology research.
Summary updated