Phenomenological and microscopic theories for catch bonds

Shaon Chakrabarti, Michael Hinczewski, D. Thirumalai

TL;DR

This paper reviews the current state of understanding catch bonds – molecular interactions that strengthen under force, defying intuition. It critically examines phenomenological and microscopic theories, highlighting their successes and limitations, and argues for the development of more structurally informed models to explain this crucial biological phenomenon.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Many biological interactions, like those between cells or between viruses and their hosts, rely on protein complexes that bind to each other. Typically, applying force to these bonds weakens them, leading to rupture. However, a fascinating counter-phenomenon, termed "catch bonding," has been observed where these bonds strengthen under applied force, up to a certain point. Understanding the origin and mechanisms of catch bonds is crucial because they play vital roles in processes like cell adhesion, immune responses, and tissue repair. The challenge lies in developing theoretical frameworks that can accurately describe and predict this counter-intuitive behavior, bridging the gap between experimental observations and fundamental molecular principles.

Methods

The paper primarily focuses on reviewing and critically analyzing existing theoretical approaches to catch bonds.

  • Phenomenological Theories: The most prominent is the two-state model. This model posits that a protein-ligand complex can exist in two distinct bound states (S₁ and S₂). Transitions between these states and dissociation to an unbound state are governed by rates that depend on applied force, often described by the Zhurkov-Bell equation. This model is flexible and can fit a wide range of experimental data. Another approach discussed is the effective 1-D models, such as the "one-state, two-pathway" model, which simplifies the energy landscape but may lack experimental validation.
  • Microscopic Theories: The paper highlights a structure-based microscopic theory developed for selectin-ligand complexes. This approach aims to derive the energy landscape directly from known protein structures, incorporating specific structural features like loops and hydrogen bonds. It uses a three-dimensional energy landscape (effectively two-dimensional due to symmetry) and calculates mean first passage times to estimate dissociation rates. This theory attempts to link observable structural changes to catch bond behavior without assuming a priori force dependence.
  • Steered Molecular Dynamics (SMD): While not a primary theoretical framework discussed in detail, SMD simulations are mentioned as a computational tool used to investigate these interactions, though their limitations at high loading rates and with current force fields are noted.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on analyzing and synthesizing existing experimental data and theoretical models rather than introducing new datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Two-State Model's Success and Limitations: The phenomenological two-state model is remarkably successful at fitting diverse experimental data for catch bonds across various biological systems. However, it lacks a direct structural basis, treating the underlying molecular mechanisms as abstract states and rates.
  • Structural Basis for Catch Bonds: The paper strongly advocates for the need for structure-based theories. For selectins, it points to specific structural changes, particularly in the Asn82-Glu88 loop, as the likely origin of catch bond behavior. This loop forms new hydrogen bonds with the ligand in an "extended" receptor conformation, stabilizing the bond.
  • Allostery is Key: The mechanism in selectins appears to be allosteric, meaning a change in one part of the molecule (the receptor's conformation) influences the binding affinity at a distant site (the ligand binding interface).
  • Force-Dependent Dynamics: The core of catch bond behavior lies in how applied force alters the energy landscape and the rates of transitions between bound states, leading to non-monotonic lifetime dependencies.
  • Limitations of 1D Models and SMD: Effective 1-D models often yield unphysical parameters, and SMD simulations, while powerful, can be limited by current force fields and non-equilibrium effects at high loading rates, making their results questionable for understanding catch bond origins.

Key Results

  • The two-state model can quantitatively recapitulate experimental catch and slip bond data from systems like P-selectin, kinetochore-microtubule attachments, and cadherin-catenin interactions.
  • A microscopic, structure-based model for P-selectin predicts that remodeling of the Asn82-Glu88 loop is responsible for catch-like behavior and provides testable predictions for mutations.
  • The paper emphasizes that while phenomenological models are good for fitting data, microscopic, structure-based models are needed for true mechanistic understanding.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations of Phenomenological Theories: They do not provide structural explanations for catch bonds and can yield parameters that are difficult to interpret physically.
  • Limitations of Microscopic Models: The current structure-based model for selectins is specific to that system and does not explain catch bonds in systems with different mechanisms or those exhibiting multi-exponential lifetime distributions (e.g., cadherin-catenin) or triphasic slip-catch-slip behavior (e.g., E-selectin).
  • Limitations of SMD: Current force fields and high loading rates in SMD simulations limit their ability to accurately reproduce experimental catch bond dynamics and structural changes.
  • Future Directions: The authors call for the development of more general theories that can explain the full distribution of lifetimes, not just averages. They emphasize the need for detailed simulations under conditions that mimic experimental forces and loading rates. Future work should focus on creating theories that capture crucial structural features and are critically evaluated on solid physical grounds to achieve predictive power.

Summary updated

Abstract

Lifetimes of bound states of protein complexes or biomolecule folded states typically decrease when subject to mechanical force. However, a plethora of biological systems exhibit the counter-intuitive phenomenon of catch bonding, where non-covalent bonds become stronger under externally applied forces. The quest to understand the origin of catch-bond behavior has lead to the development of phenomenological and microscopic theories that can quantitatively recapitulate experimental data. Here, we assess the successes and limitations of such theories in explaining experimental data. The most widely applied approach is a phenomenological two-state model, which fits all of the available data on a variety of complexes: actomyosin, kinetochore-microtubule, selectin-ligand, and cadherin-catenin binding to filamentous actin. With a primary focus on the selectin family of cell-adhesion complexes, we discuss the positives and negatives of phenomenological models and the importance of evaluating the physical relevance of fitting parameters. We describe a microscopic theory for selectins, which provides a structural basis for catch bonds and predicts a crucial allosteric role for residues Asn82--Glu88. We emphasize the need for new theories and simulations that can mimic experimental conditions, given the complex response of cell adhesion complexes to force and their potential role in a variety of biological contexts.
BibTeX
@article{chakrabarti2018phenomenological,
  author = {Shaon Chakrabarti and Michael Hinczewski and D. Thirumalai},
  title = {{Phenomenological and microscopic theories for catch bonds}},
  journal = {Journal of Structural Biology},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=P21kHMDx0i},
}
Figure