Abstract: In industrial applications that require low-cost positioning and high torque, stator permanent magnet hybrid stepper motors (SPMHSMs) possess significant application potential. The torque of the SPMHSM is related to the number of teeth per stator pole. However, few studies have analyzed the effect of the number of stator teeth on motor performance. To this end, in this study, we designed SPMHSMs with four, five and six-tooth configurations. First, the topology of the SPMHSM is introduced and its operating principle is analyzed. Next, the three motors are designed with the same PM and electrical load. Lastly, we analyzed the electromagnetic performance of these three motors in terms of several factors including magnetic flux distribution, back electromotive force, detent torque, and output torque. The obtained results show that the output torque of the SPMHSMs with five and six-tooth configurations is 2.61% and 3.26% higher than that of the SPMHSM with four-tooth configuration, whereas that with a four-tooth configuration has a wilder torque-current range.
Introduction
Stepper motors are essential for precision positioning in various industrial sectors, ranging from 3D printing to CNC machining. The Hybrid Stepper Motor (HSM) is particularly favored for its high torque and small step sizes. However, traditional HSM designs typically place the permanent magnet (PM) in the rotor, which can result in non-linear magnetic flux and inefficient material utilization.
The Stator Permanent Magnet Hybrid Stepper Motor (SPMHSM) addresses these issues by relocating the magnets to the stator yoke. This design choice simplifies the rotor construction and improves the magnetic density distribution. While it is known that the number of teeth on stator poles influences torque, a detailed comparative analysis of different tooth configurations has been lacking. This study benchmarks three specific designs to fill this gap.
Methods and Design Topology
The research team designed three motor variants featuring four, five, and six teeth per stator pole. To ensure a fair comparison, several key parameters were kept constant across all models: physical dimensions (stator/rotor diameters and stack length), core materials, PM volume, and electrical load (turns per phase and a rated current of 2.5 A).
Finite Element Analysis (FEA) was utilized to simulate electromagnetic performance. The study specifically examined magnetic flux distribution, no-load magnetic density, back electromotive force (back-EMF), detent torque, and active output torque.
Key Insights: The Saturation Trade-off
A critical finding of the study is the relationship between tooth count and magnetic saturation. While increasing the number of teeth enhances the magnetic flux in the stator poles—thereby boosting torque—it also causes the stator core to reach magnetic saturation more quickly.
Conversely, the 4-tooth configuration offers a "wider" torque-current range. Because it has fewer teeth, it can accommodate higher currents before the iron core reaches its magnetic limit. This makes the 4-tooth version more versatile for applications that may require pushing the motor beyond its rated current without losing performance linearity.
Results and Performance Comparison
The simulation results revealed distinct performance advantages for higher tooth counts at rated current:
- Output Torque: The 6-tooth motor achieved the highest average torque of 1.58 Nm, a 3.26% increase over the 4-tooth version. The 5-tooth motor followed with 1.57 Nm (2.61% higher).
- Back-EMF: The RMS values for the 5 and 6-tooth configurations were 3.08% and 5.01% higher, respectively, than the 4-tooth design.
- Detent Torque: The 5-tooth configuration exhibited the highest fundamental detent torque (18.70 mNm), approximately 6.37% higher than the 4-tooth version.
- Holding Torque: Interestingly, the maximum holding torque for both the 5 and 6-tooth versions was identical at 1.76 Nm, both outperforming the 4-tooth version's 1.71 Nm.
Conclusion
The choice between tooth configurations depends on the specific application requirements. If maximum torque in a compact size at rated current is the priority, the 6-tooth configuration is superior. However, if the application requires a broader operating range and better linearity at high currents, the 4-tooth configuration is the more robust choice. Future work will expand on these findings by including thermal analysis, acoustic studies, and experimental validation with physical prototypes.
Summary updated