Comparative Study of Air-Gap Field Distribution Characteristics Among Different Pole Array in SPM

Xinghua He, Yan Liang, Xiao-Shan Gao, Pengjie Xiang, Chris GeradaOpenalex Unknown 2022 · DOI · OpenAlex

Abstract

The pole array configuration in surface-mounted permanent magnet (SPM) machines directly influences air-gap field distribution, impacting both average torque and torque ripple. This study utilizes finite element analysis (FEA) to compare radial-magnetized, tangential-magnetized, and Halbach arrays. By analyzing the effects of the pole arc coefficient ($a_p$) and PM thickness coefficient ($a_h$) via fast Fourier transform (FFT), the research identifies critical design trade-offs. Results indicate that while pole arc length significantly affects harmonic components, magnet thickness primarily influences the fundamental flux density. Notably, radial arrays can outperform Halbach arrays at low thicknesses, while tangential arrays emerge as superior when magnet thickness exceeds 0.9 times the pole pitch.

Introduction

In the design of surface-mounted permanent magnet (SPM) machines—essential components in robotics and electric power steering—engineers face a persistent trade-off. The "fundamental wave" of magnetic flux in the air gap determines the average torque (the machine's strength), while "harmonics" (distortions in that wave) cause torque ripple, leading to unwanted vibration and noise. While various magnet arrangements exist, direct head-to-head comparisons across varying physical dimensions have been limited. This paper provides a comprehensive guide for selecting the optimal magnet array and dimensions to balance power and operational smoothness.

Methodology

The researchers employed Finite Element Analysis (FEA) to simulate the magnetic fields of three distinct pole arrays: radial-magnetized, Halbach array, and tangential-magnetized (spoke-type). To ensure universal applicability, the study utilized nondimensionalized coefficients: the pole embrace coefficient ($a_p$), representing the ratio of the magnet's arc length to the total pole pitch, and the pole thickness coefficient ($a_h$), the ratio of magnet thickness to the pole pitch. Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) was then applied to the resulting flux density waveforms to isolate fundamental torque-producing waves from harmonic ripple-producing waves.

The Impact of Geometric Ratios

A key finding of the study is the distinct roles played by $a_p$ and $a_h$. The pole arc length ($a_p$) acts as a "harmonic knob." By tuning this ratio, designers can effectively cancel out specific harmonics (such as the 3rd, 5th, or 7th) that contribute to vibration.

Figure 5: Influence of pole arc ratio ($a_p$) on fundamental and harmonic flux density components.

As shown in Figure 5, varying the pole arc ratio leads to significant fluctuations in harmonic content, allowing for targeted optimization. For radial motors, a ratio between 0.8 and 0.857 is identified as the "sweet spot" for minimizing ripple. Conversely, the magnet thickness ($a_h$) primarily impacts the total torque (fundamental flux) with minimal effect on harmonic distortion.

Figure 3: Relationship between magnet thickness ratio ($a_h$) and flux density components.

Figure 3 illustrates that as the magnet volume increases, the fundamental flux density grows, but the harmonic levels remain relatively flat. This suggests that designers can increase magnet volume to boost power without necessarily increasing the motor's acoustic or vibrational signature.

Comparative Performance and Results

The comparative analysis revealed several surprising insights regarding the three array types:

  • Thin Magnet Performance: When magnets are thin (small $a_h$), the radial-magnetized array performs better than both Halbach and tangential arrays regarding fundamental flux density.
  • The Halbach Advantage: Generally, Halbach arrays provide higher torque density than radial arrays and exhibit perfectly symmetrical harmonic distributions.
  • The Tangential Takeover: Perhaps the most significant result is that when magnet thickness exceeds 0.9 times the pole distance, the tangential-magnetized array produces a higher fundamental magnetic density than the Halbach array.
  • Saturation Effects: Tangential arrays are heavily influenced by iron saturation between magnets, which prevents the fundamental wave from growing linearly with the pole arc, unlike Halbach or radial arrays.

Conclusion

This study clarifies the design space for SPM machines by quantifying how geometric ratios influence magnetic performance across different array types. While radial arrays are effective for thin-magnet designs, Halbach and tangential arrays offer superior performance as magnet volume increases, with tangential arrays becoming particularly advantageous at high thicknesses.

The current analysis relies on a 2D linear geometric model, which is most accurate for high-pole-count motors where rotor curvature is minimal. Future research should incorporate mechanical constraints, such as magnet retention at high speeds, and thermal effects, as the more complex Halbach and tangential arrangements present unique manufacturing and cooling challenges.

Summary updated

Abstract

The pole array directly influences air-gap filed distribution and hence output torque performance especially in surface-mounted PM machine (SPM).The fundamental wave of air-gap magnetic flux density determines the average torque, and harmonic generates torque ripple.In generally, there is a trade-off between them.To simultaneously obtain high torque and low torque ripple, the selection of pole array and corresponding design parameters is essential for PM machine design.Thus, the air-gap field distribution characteristics of three kinds of pole arrays, i.e., radial-magnetized, tangential-magnetized and Halbach array are analysed and compared by finite element analysis (FEA).The effects of the pole arc coefficient and PM thickness coefficient on air-gap field distribution are analysed by fast Fourier transform (FFT).It indicates that the effects of the pole arc length on the harmonic component of air gap magnetic field is obvious and the effects of the pole thickness is very little.The performances of three pole arrays under different pole thicknesses are compared.The results show that radial-magnetized pole array perform better than Halbach array and tangentialmagnetized pole array on fundamental flux density when thickness of magnetic pole is small.Besides, when the thickness of magnetic pole exceeds 0.9 times of pole distance, tangential-magnetized pole array can obtain higher fundamental magnetic density than Halbach array.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{he2022comparative,
  author = {Xinghua He and Yan Liang and Xiao-Shan Gao and Pengjie Xiang and Chris Gerada},
  title = {{Comparative Study of Air-Gap Field Distribution Characteristics Among Different Pole Array in SPM}},
  booktitle = {Openalex Unknown},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.2991/978-94-6463-022-0\_18},
}
Figure