Performance Analysis of Ambient RF Energy Harvesting with Repulsive Point Process Modeling

Ian Flint, Xiao Lu, Nicolas Privault, Dusit Niyato, Ping Wang

Abstract

Ambient RF (Radio Frequency) energy harvesting technique has recently been proposed as a potential solution to provide proactive energy replenishment for wireless devices. This paper aims to analyze the performance of a battery-free wireless sensor powered by ambient RF energy harvesting using a stochastic geometry approach. Specifically, we consider the point-to-point uplink transmission of a wireless sensor in a stochastic geometry network, where ambient RF sources, such as mobile transmit devices, access points and base stations, are distributed as a Ginibre alpha-determinantal point process (DPP). The DPP is able to capture repulsion among points, and hence, it is more general than the Poisson point process (PPP). We analyze two common receiver architectures: separated receiver and time-switching architectures. For each architecture, we consider the scenarios with and without co-channel interference for information transmission. We derive the expectation of the RF energy harvesting rate in closed form and also compute its variance. Moreover, we perform a worst-case study which derives the upper bound of both power and transmission outage probabilities. Additionally, we provide guidelines on the setting of optimal time-switching coefficient in the case of the time-switching architecture. Numerical results verify the correctness of the analysis and show various tradeoffs between parameter setting. Lastly, we prove that the sensor is more efficient when the distribution of the ambient sources exhibits stronger repulsion.

Introduction

As the Internet of Things (IoT) expands toward billions of connected devices, traditional battery-based power solutions face significant logistical and environmental challenges. Ambient RF energy harvesting offers a promising alternative, enabling battery-free, perpetual operation by scavenging energy from existing signals like cellular transmissions and Wi-Fi.

A critical challenge in designing these systems is accurately modeling the spatial distribution of RF sources. Most prior research relies on the Poisson Point Process (PPP), which assumes sources are placed independently. However, real-world infrastructure is typically planned to minimize interference and maximize coverage, resulting in a "repulsive" distribution where sources are spread out more uniformly. This paper addresses this gap by employing a Ginibre $\alpha$-determinantal point process (DPP) to model this repulsion and its impact on energy harvesting performance.

System model of ambient RF energy harvesting from multiple sources.

Methodology and System Model

The study utilizes stochastic geometry to analyze a wireless sensor node harvesting energy from ambient sources and transmitting data to a central sink. The key innovation is the use of the Ginibre $\alpha$-DPP, where the parameter $\alpha$ controls the degree of repulsion (ranging from $\alpha \to 0$ for PPP to $\alpha = -1$ for maximum repulsion).

The authors evaluate two primary hardware architectures for the sensor node:

  1. Separated Receiver Architecture: Utilizes two dedicated antennas to allow simultaneous energy harvesting and information transmission.
  2. Time-Switching Architecture: Uses a single antenna that alternates between harvesting and transmitting modes based on a switching coefficient $\tau$.
Receiver architectures: (a) Separated and (b) Time-switching.

Mathematical derivations provide closed-form expressions for the expected harvesting rate and its variance. To handle the computational complexity of outage probabilities in DPPs, the authors also derive "worst-case" upper bounds for power and transmission outages.

Key Insights

The Role of Repulsion

A major finding is that while the average harvested energy remains consistent across different spatial models, the variance is significantly lower in repulsive (DPP) networks. This increased stability leads to more predictable power supplies and fewer power outages compared to purely random (PPP) distributions. Essentially, the sensor is more efficient when ambient sources exhibit stronger repulsion ($\alpha$ closer to -1).

Optimization and Bounds

For time-switching architectures, the research identifies an optimal switching coefficient ($\tau$). This represents a "Goldilocks" zone: harvesting for too short a duration leads to power depletion, while harvesting for too long reduces the time available for data transmission. Furthermore, the "worst-case" analysis—which considers only the nearest neighbor for energy—provides a tight and practical upper bound for engineering design, especially in high-density environments.

Results and Conclusion

Numerical simulations, parameterized for LTE networks (1800 MHz, 1W transmit power), validate the analytical models. The results confirm that repulsive source distributions significantly improve sensor reliability. While the separated architecture offers higher efficiency, the time-switching architecture can be optimized to achieve acceptable performance with a smaller physical footprint.

While this study focuses on a point-to-point scenario, it establishes a rigorous foundation for future work on multi-antenna (MIMO) systems and large-scale network-level IoT deployments.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ambient RF (Radio Frequency) energy harvesting technique has recently been proposed as a potential solution to provide proactive energy replenishment for wireless devices. This paper aims to analyze the performance of a battery-free wireless sensor powered by ambient RF energy harvesting using a stochastic geometry approach. Specifically, we consider the point-to-point uplink transmission of a wireless sensor in a stochastic geometry network, where ambient RF sources, such as mobile transmit devices, access points and base stations, are distributed as a Ginibre alpha-determinantal point process (DPP). The DPP is able to capture repulsion among points, and hence, it is more general than the Poisson point process (PPP). We analyze two common receiver architectures: separated receiver and time-switching architectures. For each architecture, we consider the scenarios with and without co-channel interference for information transmission. We derive the expectation of the RF energy harvesting rate in closed form and also compute its variance. Moreover, we perform a worst-case study which derives the upper bound of both power and transmission outage probabilities. Additionally, we provide guidelines on the setting of optimal time-switching coefficient in the case of the time-switching architecture. Numerical results verify the correctness of the analysis and show various tradeoffs between parameter setting. Lastly, we prove that the sensor is more efficient when the distribution of the ambient sources exhibits stronger repulsion.
BibTeX
@article{flint2015performance,
  author = {Ian Flint and Xiao Lu and Nicolas Privault and Dusit Niyato and Ping Wang},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of Ambient RF Energy Harvesting with Repulsive Point Process Modeling}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=fZNSFbAGdm},
}
Figure