Performance Analysis of Ambient RF Energy Harvesting with Repulsive Point Process Modeling

Ian Flint, Xiao Lu, Nicolas Privault, Dusit Niyato, Ping Wang

TL;DR

This paper provides a rigorous performance analysis of battery-free wireless sensors that "scavenge" energy from ambient radio frequency (RF) signals. By using a sophisticated mathematical model called a Ginibre $\alpha$-determinantal point process (DPP), the authors demonstrate that when RF sources (like cell towers or Wi-Fi APs) are spread out due to mutual "repulsion," sensors actually harvest energy more reliably and experience fewer outages compared to purely random distributions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As the Internet of Things (IoT) grows, powering billions of small sensors becomes a massive logistical headache. Ambient RF energy harvesting—pulling power from the invisible sea of signals around us—is a promising solution for battery-free, perpetual operation.

However, predicting how well these sensors will perform is tricky. Most existing research uses the Poisson Point Process (PPP) to model the locations of RF sources. While mathematically convenient, the PPP assumes sources are placed completely independently. In reality, network infrastructure like base stations and access points are carefully planned and usually "repel" each other to avoid interference and maximize coverage. This paper fills the gap by modeling this "repulsion" and analyzing how it affects energy harvesting rates and outage probabilities.

Methods

The authors employ stochastic geometry to model the network. The key innovation is the use of the Ginibre $\alpha$-determinantal point process (DPP).

  • The $\alpha$ Parameter: This allows the model to vary from a standard Poisson process ($\alpha \to 0$) to a highly repulsive "Ginibre" model ($\alpha = -1$).
  • Receiver Architectures: They analyze two setups:
  • Separated: Two antennas allow the sensor to harvest energy and transmit data simultaneously.
  • Time-switching: A single antenna alternates between harvesting and transmitting.
  • Analytical Derivations: The authors derive closed-form expressions for the expected energy harvesting rate and its variance. Because exact outage probabilities for DPPs are computationally expensive to simulate, they also derive "worst-case" upper bounds for power and transmission outages.

Datasets

The paper does not use a physical dataset. Instead, it relies on Monte Carlo simulations to validate its mathematical models. To ensure the simulations are realistic, the authors use parameters consistent with an LTE network:

  • Operating Frequency: 1800 MHz.
  • Transmit Power: 1W for ambient sources.
  • Circuit Consumption: 15.8 $\mu$W (a typical low-power sensor requirement).
  • Noise Floor: -90 dBm.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Repulsion is a Stabilizer: While the average amount of energy harvested is the same regardless of whether sources are repulsive or purely random, the variance is much lower in repulsive (DPP) networks. In engineering terms, this means the power supply is more stable and predictable.
  • The "Aha" Moment on Outages: Because the energy supply is more stable in a repulsive network, the sensor is significantly less likely to suffer a "power outage" (where it doesn't have enough juice to run its circuits).
  • Worst-Case Utility: The authors show that a "worst-case" analysis—assuming the sensor only gets energy from its single closest neighbor—provides a very tight and useful upper bound for real-world performance. This simplifies the math for engineers designing these systems.
  • Optimal Timing: For time-switching sensors, there is a "Goldilocks" zone for the switching coefficient ($\tau$). If you harvest for too little time, you run out of power; if you harvest for too long, you don't have enough time left to send your data.

Key Results

  • Mathematical Accuracy: Numerical simulations perfectly match the derived closed-form expressions for harvesting rates.
  • Efficiency Gain: The paper proves that sensors are more efficient (lower outage probability) when the distribution of ambient sources exhibits stronger repulsion ($\alpha$ closer to -1).
  • Tight Bounds: The derived upper bounds for outage probabilities were shown to be very accurate, especially in high-density environments.
  • Architecture Comparison: While the separated architecture is more efficient because it performs two tasks at once, the time-switching architecture can be optimized via the $\tau$ parameter to achieve acceptable performance with a smaller physical footprint.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Point-to-Point Focus: The study focuses on a single sensor node transmitting to a single data sink. In a real-world IoT deployment, thousands of sensors might be competing for the same ambient energy and channel space.
  • Simple Propagation: The model uses a standard free-space path loss model. Real-world environments with heavy shadowing or multi-path fading (like dense cities or factories) might introduce more volatility.
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest extending this analysis to multi-antenna (MIMO) systems and moving from a single-node analysis to a full network-level performance study.

Summary updated

Abstract

Ambient radio frequency (RF) energy harvesting technique has recently been proposed as a potential solution for providing proactive energy replenishment for wireless devices. This paper aims to analyze the performance of a battery-free wireless sensor powered by ambient RF energy harvesting using a stochastic geometry approach. Specifically, we consider the point-to-point uplink transmission of a wireless sensor in a stochastic geometry network, where ambient RF sources, such as mobile transmit devices, access points and base stations, are distributed as a Ginibre α-determinantal point process (DPP). The DPP is able to capture repulsion among points, and hence, it is more general than the Poisson point process (PPP). We analyze two common receiver architectures: separated receiver and time-switching architectures. For each architecture, we consider the scenarios with and without co-channel interference for information transmission. We derive the expectation of the RF energy harvesting rate in closed form and also compute its variance. Moreover, we perform a worst-case study which derives the upper bound of both power and transmission outage probabilities. Additionally, we provide guidelines on the setting of optimal time-switching coefficient in the case of the time-switching architecture. Numerical results verify the correctness of the analysis and show various tradeoffs between parameter setting. Lastly, we prove that the RF-powered sensor performs better when the distribution of the ambient sources exhibits stronger repulsion.
BibTeX
@article{flint2015performance,
  author = {Ian Flint and Xiao Lu and Nicolas Privault and Dusit Niyato and Ping Wang},
  title = {{Performance Analysis of Ambient RF Energy Harvesting with Repulsive Point Process Modeling}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2015},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=fZNSFbAGdm},
}

Loading related content...

Figure