Performance Analysis for Correlated AoI and Energy Efficiency in Heterogeneous CR-IoT System

Xiaoyu Hao, Tao Yang, Yulin Hu, Bo Hu

Abstract

We consider a cognitive radio based Internet of Things (CR-IoT) system where the secondary IoT device (SD) accesses the licensed channel during the transmission vacancies of the primary IoT device (PD). We focus on the impact of the IoT devices' heterogeneous traffic pattern on the energy efficiency and on the age of information (AoI) performance of the SD. We first derive closed-form expressions of the energy efficiency and the average AoI, and subsequently explore their convexity and monotonicity to the transmit power. Following these characterizations, an optimal transmit power optimization algorithm (TPOA) is proposed for the SD to maximize the energy efficiency while maintaining the average AoI under a predefined threshold. Numerical results verify the different preferences of the SD toward different PD traffic patterns, and provides insights into the tradeoff between the energy efficiency and the average AoI.

Introduction

In the massive IoT landscape, spectrum scarcity is a major hurdle. Cognitive Radio (CR) allows "Secondary Devices" (SDs) to opportunistically use the licensed spectrum of "Primary Devices" (PDs) when the channel is idle. However, most existing research assumes uniform traffic. In reality, traffic is heterogeneous: a primary user might have frequent, short bursts of data, while a secondary sensor might have large, infrequent packets. This creates two conflicting challenges for the secondary device: maximizing Energy Efficiency (EE) to preserve battery life and minimizing the Age of Information (AoI) to ensure data freshness.

System Model and AoI Characterization

The authors model the CR-IoT system using a two-state Continuous-Time Markov Chain (CTMC) to represent the primary user's "IDLE" and "BUSY" periods. The secondary device's packet generation is modeled as a Poisson process.

Evolution of Age of Information (AoI) over time, illustrating the sawtooth pattern and the impact of packet delivery.

As shown in Figure 1, AoI measures the time elapsed since the generation of the last successfully received update. The analysis is complicated by "interrupted" transmissions—where the secondary device starts sending data but must stop and restart because the primary user reclaimed the channel. The authors successfully derived closed-form mathematical expressions for average AoI and EE that account for these interruptions.

Optimization and the "Double Infinity" Trap

A key insight from the analytical model is the "Double Infinity" trap: average AoI tends toward infinity in two extreme cases. If the primary user switches states too quickly, the secondary device is constantly interrupted; if it switches too slowly, the secondary device waits too long for an opening. Information freshness requires a "Goldilocks" traffic pattern.

To navigate these challenges, the authors introduced the Transmit Power Optimization Algorithm (TPOA). This algorithm uses binary search and gradient descent to find the optimal transmit power that maximizes energy efficiency while ensuring the average AoI stays below a user-defined threshold.

Numerical Results and Tradeoffs

The mathematical models were validated using Monte Carlo simulations consistent with NB-IoT standards. The results confirmed that the derived closed-form expressions for EE and AoI matched simulation results almost perfectly.

Energy efficiency and average AoI versus transmit power, demonstrating the fundamental tradeoff between battery life and data freshness.

As illustrated in Figure 2, increasing transmit power reduces the time needed to send a packet (lowering AoI), but it does not always improve energy efficiency. There is a specific transmit power that maximizes bits-per-joule. When AoI constraints are strict, the SD must often sacrifice energy efficiency by using higher power to ensure packets are delivered before they become obsolete. Furthermore, the research provides a clear lower bound for AoI, determined by the sum of the average packet generation interval and the minimum possible transmission time.

Conclusion

This work provides a robust analytical framework for understanding the interplay between energy efficiency and data freshness in CR-IoT systems. By accounting for heterogeneous traffic patterns and providing an optimization algorithm, it offers a practical path for IoT devices to balance battery longevity with the requirements of time-critical monitoring applications.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider a cognitive radio based Internet of Things (CR-IoT) system where the secondary IoT device (SD) accesses the licensed channel during the transmission vacancies of the primary IoT device (PD). We focus on the impact of the IoT devices' heterogeneous traffic pattern on the energy efficiency and on the age of information (AoI) performance of the SD. We first derive closed-form expressions of the energy efficiency and the average AoI, and subsequently explore their convexity and monotonicity to the transmit power. Following these characterizations, an optimal transmit power optimization algorithm (TPOA) is proposed for the SD to maximize the energy efficiency while maintaining the average AoI under a predefined threshold. Numerical results verify the different preferences of the SD toward different PD traffic patterns, and provides insights into the tradeoff between the energy efficiency and the average AoI.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{hao2021performance,
  author = {Xiaoyu Hao and Tao Yang and Yulin Hu and Bo Hu},
  title = {{Performance Analysis for Correlated AoI and Energy Efficiency in Heterogeneous CR-IoT System}},
  booktitle = {Workshops @ INFOCOM},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=OVHjgxgxvE},
}
Figure