Abstract
This research project investigated the perceptions of online versus face-to-face (F2F) learning among 177 Bachelor of Science in Rehabilitation Science (BSRS) students in China (Cohorts 2017-2019). Using a cross-sectional descriptive survey, the study found that students significantly preferred F2F learning (47% vs. 14%) and considered it the most effective modality (45%). While online learning offered flexibility and replayability, F2F was superior for engagement and knowledge acquisition in clinical subjects.
Introduction
The COVID-19 pandemic necessitated a rapid transition to digital education globally. For students in clinical and tactile fields like Rehabilitation Science, this shift presented unique challenges. This study examines the perceptions of Chinese students in a U.S.-Sino cooperative BSRS program, exploring whether the convenience of online tools can compensate for the loss of physical classroom interaction in a transnational curriculum.
Methodology
The researchers employed a quantitative, cross-sectional descriptive survey design. To ensure the survey was grounded in actual student experiences, they conducted a pilot study with ten students. The resulting 21-question Qualtrics survey was distributed to 177 students across three cohorts (2017, 2018, and 2019) at Shanghai Normal University Tianhua College. Data analysis utilized descriptive statistics, including mean, mode, and frequency counts, via SPSS and Excel.
Key Insights: The Clinical Necessity of Physical Presence
Rehabilitation Science is inherently hands-on, making the transition to digital platforms particularly complex. The study revealed a "Clinical Catch-22": while students appreciated the flexibility of digital tools, they rated learning effectiveness (67%) and engagement (76%) much higher in person.
As illustrated in Figure 3, practical labs (66%) and discussions (51%) were identified as the most critical components of the F2F experience. For a major like Rehabilitation Science, the absence of physical labs during "emergency" online learning was a major hurdle for students attempting to master clinical competencies.
Comparative Advantages and Cultural Nuances
The research highlighted several key trade-offs between the two modalities:
- The Replayability Factor: The most significant advantage of online learning was the ability to replay recorded lessons (79%). For international students navigating language barriers, this "pause and rewind" capability is a critical accessibility tool.
- The Shyness Barrier: A fascinating cultural insight emerged regarding "shyness." 67% of students cited shyness as a drawback of F2F learning, noting they were often afraid to ask questions in person. However, despite the relative anonymity of online platforms, students still felt they gained more knowledge in the high-engagement F2F environment.
- Motivation Parity: Despite the preference for F2F learning, 45% of respondents reported being equally motivated in both settings, suggesting that student drive may be more internal or curriculum-dependent than medium-dependent.
Results Summary
- Preference: 47% preferred F2F, while only 14% preferred purely online learning.
- Effectiveness: 45% rated F2F as the most effective method, followed by blended learning (39%). Only 16% saw pure online learning as the most effective.
- Top F2F Advantages: Communication with teachers (85%) and student engagement (76%).
- Top Online Advantages: Replaying lessons (79%) and flexibility of time/space (76%).
- Top Online Barriers: Unstable network connections (74%) and visual fatigue (66%).
Conclusion
While online learning provides essential flexibility and accessibility through recorded content, it cannot yet replace the interactive and tactile requirements of Health Science education. Face-to-face learning remains the preferred and most effective method for BSRS students. The authors advocate for the development of "blended learning" models that combine the engagement of the physical classroom with the technological advantages of digital tools to optimize future health science education.
Summary updated