An assessment of online and offline blended teaching of Stomatology for non-stomatology medical students

Jingyan Huang, Bo Yang, Guihong Yang, H. H. Zhang, Youyu Gan, Yan WangResearch Square 2025 · DOI

Abstract

Introduction and aims: The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the adoption of blended teaching models in medical education, highlighting their potential to address challenges in traditional pedagogy. This study evaluates the effectiveness of online and offline blended teaching for non-stomatology medical students in Stomatology, a critical yet often underrepresented discipline in medical curricula. Methods: A blended teaching approach was implemented, combining pre-recorded online lectures with interactive offline sessions. Pre-class surveys assessed students’ perceptions and readiness, while post-class evaluations, including theory tests and satisfaction questionnaires, measured learning outcomes and engagement. Results: The blended teaching model significantly enhanced classroom engagement, stimulated learning enthusiasm, and improved knowledge retention. Students receiving blended teaching demonstrated higher satisfaction and performance compared to those taught through traditional methods. Conclusions: The findings underscore the value of blended teaching in fostering interdisciplinary understanding and clinical competence in Stomatology. This study advocates for the broader application of blended teaching model in interdisciplinary Stomatology teaching to bridge gaps in oral-systemic health training and improve patient outcomes.

Introduction

In medical education, Stomatology (oral medicine) is frequently treated as a peripheral discipline. However, its clinical relevance is profound, as over 90% of systemic diseases, including diabetes and cardiovascular conditions, manifest oral symptoms. Despite this, general medical curricula often struggle to integrate oral health effectively.

Traditional lecture-based teaching frequently results in passive learning and poor knowledge retention. While the COVID-19 pandemic forced a shift to purely online learning, that model lacked the hands-on interaction necessary for clinical competence. This study investigates whether a "blended" model—combining asynchronous online lectures with interactive offline sessions—could provide a sustainable and effective framework for interdisciplinary medical education.

Methods

The researchers conducted a comparative study involving three cohorts of second-year Clinical Medicine students at Sun Yat-sen University, totaling 414 participants:

  • Control Group (n=172): Traditional face-to-face lectures (2020).
  • Online Teaching Group (OT, n=120): Purely online instruction (2021).
  • Blended Teaching Group (BT, n=122): Hybrid model (2022–2023).

The blended workflow involved an initial learning phase using digital platforms like Rain Classroom and WeChat for pre-recorded lectures and self-evaluation. This was followed by interactive face-to-face sessions reserved for case studies and small-group collaborations. Finally, post-class engagement included additional readings and a theoretical review paper.

To assess student perceptions and the effectiveness of these models, the researchers utilized a structured questionnaire to gauge preferences and perceived challenges.

Questionnaire used to assess student perceptions of different teaching modes.

Effectiveness was measured through these anonymous surveys and standardized theoretical test scores (20-point scale), with data analyzed using SPSS 26.0.

Results and Discussion

Academic Performance and Knowledge Retention

Both the purely online (OT) and blended (BT) groups significantly outperformed the traditional control group in theoretical tests ($P < 0.001$). This suggests that digital resources, particularly the ability to "playback" lectures, help cement complex interdisciplinary knowledge. Interestingly, there was no significant difference between BT and OT scores, indicating both digital-heavy models are effective for rote knowledge acquisition.

Engagement and Satisfaction

The Blended Teaching group reported significantly higher satisfaction regarding "teaching methods" and "teaching effects" compared to the Online-only group ($P < 0.0001$). Students noted that the hybrid model allowed teachers to explain difficult concepts more thoroughly while maintaining an active classroom atmosphere. 74.29% of students cited the "breakthrough of spatiotemporal limitations" as a primary advantage of the blended approach.

The "Comfort Zone" Paradox and Challenges

Despite the benefits, 51.43% of students initially preferred traditional teaching. This highlights a "comfort zone" issue where students acknowledge the flaws of traditional methods (like spatiotemporal constraints) but find the self-discipline required for blended learning burdensome. Indeed, 77.14% of students identified "self-restraint" as a major challenge in the online component. Furthermore, the use of common social apps like WeChat was deemed essential by most students for lowering communication barriers between teachers and students.

Conclusion

The blended teaching model effectively bridges the gap between digital convenience and the irreplaceable human element of face-to-face discussion. While it increases the workload for educators and requires higher student self-regulation, the improvements in engagement and satisfaction are significant. Future iterations should focus on better time-management strategies for students and the integration of AI-driven tools to further facilitate asynchronous learning.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Introduction and aims: The COVID-19 pandemic accelerated the adoption of blended teaching models in medical education, highlighting their potential to address challenges in traditional pedagogy. This study evaluates the effectiveness of online and offline blended teaching for non-stomatology medical students in Stomatology, a critical yet often underrepresented discipline in medical curricula. Methods: A blended teaching approach was implemented, combining pre-recorded online lectures with interactive offline sessions. Pre-class surveys assessed students’ perceptions and readiness, while post-class evaluations, including theory tests and satisfaction questionnaires, measured learning outcomes and engagement. Results: The blended teaching model significantly enhanced classroom engagement, stimulated learning enthusiasm, and improved knowledge retention. Students receiving blended teaching demonstrated higher satisfaction and performance compared to those taught through traditional methods. Conclusions: The findings underscore the value of blended teaching in fostering interdisciplinary understanding and clinical competence in Stomatology. This study advocates for the broader application of blended teaching model in interdisciplinary Stomatology teaching to bridge gaps in oral-systemic health training and improve patient outcomes.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{huang2025assessment,
  author = {Jingyan Huang and Bo Yang and Guihong Yang and H. H. Zhang and Youyu Gan and Yan Wang},
  title = {{An assessment of online and offline blended teaching of Stomatology for non-stomatology medical students}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-6140068/v1},
}
Figure