Online, face to face and hybrid meetings. What is the new normal in the COVID-19 era? A global collaborative survey by iTRUE group and UroSoMe working group

Daniele Castellani, B. M. Zeeshan Hameed, Yılören Tanıdır, Nithesh Naik, Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh, Milap Shah, Marcelo Langer Wroclawski, Afrah Budnar Kunjibettu, Sufyan Ibrahim, Rodrigo Donalisio da Silva, Bhavan Prasad, Jean de la Rosette, Rajeev Tp, Vineet Gauhar, Bhaskar SomaniResearch 2020 · DOI

The COVID-19 pandemic fundamentally disrupted Continuous Medical Education (CME), the essential process by which physicians stay current with surgical techniques and clinical advancements. Traditionally centered around large-scale international congresses, the sudden cancellation of major events like the American Urological Association (AUA) annual meeting created a significant educational gap. While digital webinars emerged as a rapid solution, their long-term role remained uncertain. A global survey conducted by the iTRUE and UroSoMe working groups sought to evaluate the utility of online versus face-to-face (F2F) meetings and define the "new normal" for professional medical gatherings.

Methodology

The researchers deployed an online global survey between June and July 2020, utilizing a modified Delphi method to ensure the relevance and robustness of the questionnaire. A panel of experts iteratively refined questions across five domains: demographics, F2F conference experience, webinar experience, perceptions of hybrid models, and the characteristics of an optimal virtual meeting.

The study analyzed responses from 526 urology professionals across 56 countries, with 386 completing the full survey. The cohort was predominantly composed of consultants (73.3%) and residents (24.6%), primarily from Asia and Europe.

The Rise of the Hybrid Model

A central finding of the study is the strong preference for a "hybrid" conference model in the post-pandemic era. Over half of the respondents (51%) favored a blend of in-person and digital access, compared to only 25% who preferred purely virtual webinars. This consensus suggests that while the reach of digital platforms is invaluable, it cannot entirely replace the physical conference environment.

Networking: The Face-to-Face Advantage

The survey revealed a clear distinction in the strengths of each format. Face-to-face meetings remain the gold standard for social networking and personal professional development. While webinars were rated highly for cost-effectiveness and accessibility, they scored significantly lower in areas of "personal pleasure" and relationship building.

Interestingly, urology residents perceived F2F meetings as more cost-effective than consultants did. This likely reflects the high career value trainees place on hands-on learning and the networking opportunities essential for career advancement, which they feel justify the associated travel costs.

Addressing "Webinar Fatigue"

Despite the high adoption rate—96% of respondents attended an average of 10 webinars during the early pandemic—the data suggests a growing "digital burnout." Only 21% of participants rated their overall webinar experience as "very good," compared to 64% for F2F meetings.

To combat this, the study identified the "recipe" for a successful virtual event. According to the respondents, the ideal webinar should be:

  • Duration: Approximately 1 hour.
  • Timing: Held in the evening.
  • Composition: Featuring 3–5 speakers.
  • Format: Delivered live rather than pre-recorded.
  • Platform: Accessed via laptop or desktop (69%) rather than mobile devices, with Zoom being the preferred platform (73%).

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The findings indicate that while webinars are a powerful tool for disseminating scientific information cost-effectively, they serve as a supplement to, rather than a replacement for, traditional conferences. The "new normal" is likely to be a hybrid ecosystem that leverages the global reach of digital platforms while preserving the high-value networking of in-person events. Future research should investigate the long-term knowledge retention of these different formats and the economic sustainability of the hybrid model for medical societies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Background : During the COVID-19 pandemic there was a significant increase in online webinars, which were universally available and advertised via Social Media, eliminating geographic restrictions thereby achieving a broader audience. Objective : The primary outcome of our survey was to see how virtual meetings would fare vis a vis face-to-face meeting, and if there would any future role of a “hybrid" meeting concept. The secondary outcome was to find out the best webinar/ virtual meeting settings. Design, setting, and participants : An online global survey was done between 6 th June, 2020 to 5 th July 2020 via https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/K26B5RQ. Using Delphi method, the survey questions were designed regarding webinars, face to face meetings and hybrid meetings, and circulated. Outcome measurements and statistical analysis : Categorical data were presented with counts and percentages, and comparison was done using Chi-square test and answers to Likert-like scale questions using the Mann-Whitney U test. Results and limitations : A total of N=526 urologists from 56 countries responded to the survey, of which N=386(73.38%) completed the questionnaire. The overall experience of participants was better in the face-to-face meeting followed by a hybrid meeting and webinar. After the COVID-19 pandemic, the preference for the type of conference was that of a hybrid meeting N=199(51%) than the webinar N=95(25%), using Zoom platform N= 283(73%) on laptop/desktop as the device of choice N=267(69%) and believed that a 1-hour webinar N=196(51%) was ideal at evening time N=277(72%) with 3-5 speakers N=242(62%) for each meeting. Although urology residents rated face-to-face meetings to have better cost-effectiveness when compared to consultants. Conclusions : The current pandemic has shown a trend towards online webinars; however, they are not a substitution to face-to-face meetings. Our survey shows an increased preference towards a hybrid meeting in the coming future which would be ideal for global participation, adding value to money and time.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{castellani2020online,
  author = {Daniele Castellani and B. M. Zeeshan Hameed and Yılören Tanıdır and Nithesh Naik and Jeremy Yuen‐Chun Teoh and Milap Shah and Marcelo Langer Wroclawski and Afrah Budnar Kunjibettu and Sufyan Ibrahim and Rodrigo Donalisio da Silva and Bhavan Prasad and Jean de la Rosette and Rajeev TP and Vineet Gauhar and Bhaskar Somani},
  title = {{Online, face to face and hybrid meetings. What is the new normal in the COVID-19 era? A global collaborative survey by iTRUE group and UroSoMe working group}},
  booktitle = {Research},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-89959/v1},
}
Figure