Optimal Cruise Airspeed for Hybrid-Electric and Electric Aircraft: Applications to Air Mobility

Steven Li, Luis Rodrigues

Abstract

As the aviation industry transitions toward hybrid-electric and electric propulsion to meet decarbonization goals, the optimization of flight trajectories becomes increasingly complex. This paper presents a systematic, continuous-time solution—derived as a quintic polynomial—to determine the optimal cruise airspeed that minimizes Direct Operating Cost (DOC). By integrating this solution into a modified RRT* path-planning algorithm, the research demonstrates a robust framework for optimizing both time and energy costs in urban and international air mobility scenarios.

Introduction

The shift toward hybrid-electric propulsion introduces a dual-energy challenge: operators must manage both fuel and electricity, each characterized by distinct costs and weight dynamics. Traditional optimization models often rely on discrete-time simulations or specific numerical solvers that lack a generalized framework for finding the "sweet spot" airspeed. This study addresses this gap by providing a mathematical derivation for optimal airspeed ($v^*$) and applying it to modern path-planning challenges in Urban Air Mobility (UAM).

Methodology

1. Optimal Control and the Quintic Polynomial

The researchers utilized Pontryagin’s Minimum Principle to derive a quintic (5th-degree) polynomial. The positive real root of this equation represents the airspeed that minimizes the DOC. The DOC function is designed to balance two primary factors:

  • Time-related costs ($C_I$): Fixed costs associated with the duration of the flight.
  • Energy costs ($C_E$): The combined cost of fuel and electricity.

To ensure the model's versatility, a hybridization factor ($\beta$) was introduced. This parameter describes the proportion of thrust generated by electric motors, allowing the framework to accommodate pure combustion ($\beta=0$), pure electric ($\beta=1$), and hybrid configurations.

2. RRT* Integration

The study integrates the optimal airspeed solution into the Rapidly-exploring Random Trees Star (RRT) algorithm. While standard RRT typically seeks the shortest geometric path, this modified version uses the minimum DOC as the cost metric for each edge. This allows the algorithm to find a global minimum cost by balancing the extra distance required to avoid obstacles against the optimal cruise speed for that specific segment.

Experimental Setup

The framework was validated using simulated scenarios based on real-world aircraft specifications:

  • Hybrid-Electric International Scenario: An Airbus E-Fan X was modeled for a 450km flight from Montreal to New York.
  • All-Electric Urban Scenario: A Yuneec International E430 was modeled for a 10km mission within a simulated city environment containing 500 randomly generated cylindrical obstacles representing buildings and restricted airspace.

Key Insights

The Weight-Speed Relationship

A critical finding of the research is the link between aircraft mass and optimal speed. In hybrid-electric aircraft, the mass decreases as fuel is consumed. The derived polynomial indicates that the optimal airspeed should decrease proportionally as the aircraft becomes lighter to maintain peak efficiency. Conversely, for all-electric aircraft, the mass remains constant because batteries do not lose mass during discharge. In these cases, the quintic polynomial simplifies to a quartic (4th-degree) equation, and the optimal airspeed remains constant throughout the cruise.

Economic Viability of Electrification

The model highlights the significant cost-saving potential of electric propulsion. In the urban mission scenario, the energy cost for the electric flight was calculated at $0.23 USD. If the same mission were flown using traditional kerosene, the cost would rise to $1.48 USD— a six-fold increase. This underscores the economic incentive for adopting electric aircraft in short-range UAM operations.

Results

  • Hybrid Performance: For the Montreal to NYC route, the E-Fan X began its cruise at approximately 991 km/h, with the optimal speed gradually decreasing as fuel was burned.
  • Electric Performance: The Yuneec E430 maintained a steady optimal speed of 130 km/h throughout its 10km urban mission, successfully navigating the obstacle-dense environment with minimal energy expenditure.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the current model provides a robust foundation for cruise optimization, several areas remain for future exploration:

  • Vertical Profiles: The study assumes a constant altitude; future iterations could include optimal climb and descent profiles for full 3D trajectory optimization.
  • Atmospheric Variables: The impact of wind (headwinds and tailwinds) on ground speed and energy consumption was not included in this phase.
  • Battery Dynamics: Future models could integrate real-world battery discharge curves and thermal effects, moving beyond the assumption of constant voltage to achieve higher fidelity.

Conclusion

By providing a closed-form mathematical solution for optimal airspeed, this research offers a scalable tool for the next generation of flight management systems. The integration of economic cost factors with path-planning algorithms ensures that hybrid and electric aircraft can operate at maximum efficiency, paving the way for sustainable and cost-effective urban air mobility.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{li2023optimal,
  author = {Steven Li and Luis Rodrigues},
  title = {{Optimal Cruise Airspeed for Hybrid-Electric and Electric Aircraft: Applications to Air Mobility}},
  booktitle = {CCTA},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1109/ccta54093.2023.10252879},
}
Figure