To charge in-flight or not: an inquiry into parallel-hybrid electric aircraft configurations via optimal control

Mengyuan Wang, Mehran MesbahiarXiv 2022 · OpenReview

Abstract

We examine two configurations for parallel hybrid electric aircraft, one with, and one without, a mechanical connection between the engines and the electric motors. For this two designs, we then review the power allocation problem in the context of aircraft energy management for a 19-seat conceptual Hybrid Electric Aircraft. We then represent the original optimal control problem as a finite-dimensional optimization and validate the second-order sufficient conditions for global optimality of the obtained solution. This is then followed by a sensitivity analysis of the fuel consumption on the initial aircraft weight and flight endurance. Our simulation and theoretical results clarify the limited benefit of charging the battery in-flight for this class of hybrid electric aircraft to reduce $CO_2$ emissions.

Introduction

As the aviation industry scrambles to meet aggressive CO2 reduction targets, Hybrid-Electric Aircraft (HEA) have emerged as a vital mid-term solution while battery technology catches up. Most HEA designs borrow a page from the automotive playbook, mechanically linking the gas turbine and electric motor so the engine can charge the battery during the cruise phase.

Parallel-hybrid architecture with a mechanical connection between the engine and motor, enabling in-flight battery charging.

However, this mechanical connection adds significant weight, complexity, and maintenance requirements. A newer "independent" approach keeps the engine and electric paths separate. The core question this paper tackles is: Is the fuel efficiency gained by allowing the engine to charge the battery in-flight worth the added complexity of a mechanical connection?

Independent propulsion architecture where the engine and electric motor paths remain separate, simplifying the design but precluding in-flight charging.

Methodology

The authors approach this as a rigorous trajectory optimization problem. They modeled a conceptual 19-seat commuter aircraft equipped with a Pratt & Whitney PT6A-135A turboprop and a Magni250 electric motor. To solve the power allocation strategy, they formulated an Optimal Control Problem (OCP) to minimize total fuel consumption over a fixed flight profile.

To solve the OCP, they converted it into a finite-dimensional optimization problem using arc-parametrization. They identified that the optimal control follows a "max-boundary-min" structure, where the system switches between maximum power, a specific charging rate, and minimum power. Crucially, they used the ipopt solver and validated the second-order sufficient conditions to prove their solution was a global optimum.

Key Results and Discussion

The study's findings challenge the assumption that in-flight charging is a necessary feature for hybrid aviation.

  • The "Efficiency Sweet Spot" is a Mirage: While charging the battery in-flight allows the engine to run at a more efficient operating point (lower Specific Fuel Consumption), the extra energy required to perform the charging almost perfectly cancels out those gains.
  • Negligible Savings: For a standard 400km mission, allowing the battery to charge in-flight saved only 0.33kg of fuel out of a total 310.8kg consumed—a marginal gain of roughly 0.1%.
  • Weight is the Enemy: In aviation, weight is critical. The study found that if a specific battery charge level is needed for landing, it is more fuel-efficient to carry a larger, pre-charged battery from the ground than to carry a smaller one and charge it mid-air.
  • Simplicity Wins: Because the fuel savings from in-flight charging are so small, the "independent" architecture—which is lighter and easier to transition to a fully electric system—appears to be the superior engineering choice.

Conclusion

This research settles a high-stakes design debate by demonstrating that the fuel savings from in-flight charging are negligible for 19-seat commuter planes. The results suggest that simpler, lighter "independent" propulsion designs are the more effective path forward. Future work could expand this framework to include more complex flight maneuvers or explore how different battery chemistries might change the trade-offs for larger narrow-body jets or smaller VTOL craft.

Summary updated

Abstract

We examine two configurations for parallel hybrid electric aircraft, one with, and one without, a mechanical connection between the engines and the electric motors. For this two designs, we then review the power allocation problem in the context of aircraft energy management for a 19-seat conceptual Hybrid Electric Aircraft. We then represent the original optimal control problem as a finite-dimensional optimization and validate the second-order sufficient conditions for global optimality of the obtained solution. This is then followed by a sensitivity analysis of the fuel consumption on the initial aircraft weight and flight endurance. Our simulation and theoretical results clarify the limited benefit of charging the battery in-flight for this class of hybrid electric aircraft to reduce $CO_2$ emissions.
BibTeX
@misc{wang2022charge,
  author = {Mengyuan Wang and Mehran Mesbahi},
  title = {{To charge in-flight or not: an inquiry into parallel-hybrid electric aircraft configurations via optimal control}},
  year = {2022},
  eprint = {2208.08969},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2208.08969},
}
Figure