Optimal Claiming of Social Security Benefits

Steven Diamond, Stephen Boyd, David Greenberg, Mykel J. Kochenderfer, Andrew Ang

Deciding when to claim Social Security benefits is one of the most significant financial choices for the average American. While the window for claiming spans from age 62 to 70, the financial implications of this choice are profound: waiting until age 70 can increase monthly benefits by up to 77% compared to claiming at 62. Despite this, many individuals claim early, often relying on simple "break-even" actuarial calculations that fail to account for broader financial health.

In this research, a team including optimization experts Stephen Boyd and Mykel Kochenderfer applies rigorous mathematical optimization to this decision. By moving beyond total expected dollars and into a lifecycle framework, the authors provide a new decision-making metric: the ratio of an individual's wealth to their Primary Insurance Amount (PIA).

The Problem: Consumption Smoothing vs. Delayed Gratification

Social Security claiming is a classic problem of delayed gratification. Claiming at 62 provides immediate liquidity but locks in a lower permanent benefit. Conversely, waiting requires the individual to fund their lifestyle from personal savings for several years in exchange for a significantly higher, inflation-indexed government annuity later in life.

Traditional advice often focuses on the "break-even" age—the point at which the total cumulative benefits of waiting exceed the total benefits of claiming early. However, this ignores consumption smoothing, the human preference for a stable standard of living. For an individual with no savings, waiting until 70 is mathematically "optimal" in terms of total dollars but practically impossible, as they would have no income in the interim. The authors address this by integrating investment returns, mortality risk, and utility preferences into a unified optimization problem.

Methodology: The Lifecycle Model

The researchers employ a lifecycle model utilizing Epstein-Zin (1989) utility. This framework is particularly effective in financial economics because it separates two critical concepts:

  1. Risk Aversion: The degree to which an individual dislikes market volatility.
  2. Intertemporal Elasticity of Substitution (IES): The willingness to consume less today to ensure higher consumption in the future.

To solve the claiming problem, the authors use mixed-integer optimization, representing the decision to claim at each age (62 through 70) as a series of binary variables. A key mathematical insight of the paper is that the problem is homogeneous with respect to the ratio of wealth to PIA. This allows the complex decision-making process to be distilled into a single, elegant threshold rule: if your wealth-to-PIA ratio ($W/PIA$) is above a specific threshold, you should defer; if it falls below, you should claim.

Key Insights: The Wealth-to-PIA Ratio

The most significant contribution of the paper is the identification of the $W/PIA$ ratio as a "sufficient statistic." An individual does not need to consider their absolute wealth or their benefit amount in isolation; only the relationship between the two matters.

The Ratchet Effect and Gender Differences

The optimal threshold for claiming does not increase linearly with age. Instead, it "ratchets" up discontinuously. This occurs because Social Security benefit increases are lumpy—for instance, the percentage jump in benefits between certain years is higher than others. When the "raise" for waiting is particularly high, the model suggests individuals should be willing to endure lower current consumption to secure that increase.

Furthermore, gender plays a critical role due to differences in life expectancy. Because women generally live longer, the lifetime value of the Social Security annuity is higher for them. Consequently, the model finds that women should generally be willing to defer claiming at lower wealth levels than men.

Market Insensitivity

Surprisingly, the optimal decision is relatively insensitive to stock market performance. Unless real market returns are unrealistically high (exceeding 7%), the "guaranteed," inflation-indexed return provided by delaying Social Security outclasses the risk-adjusted returns of a typical 60/40 investment portfolio. For most retirees, delaying Social Security is the most efficient way to "buy" a high-quality annuity.

Results and Economic Value

The authors define specific critical $W/PIA$ ratios for deferring benefits for at least one more year:

  • At Age 62: A man should defer if his $W/PIA$ ratio is greater than 5.5; a woman should defer if it is greater than 5.2.
  • At Age 69: The thresholds rise significantly to 11.1 for men and 10.4 for women.

The economic value of waiting is substantial. The authors calculate that deferring for one year at age 62 is equivalent to spending $8,400 today to secure a $50/month inflation-indexed annuity. In the current market, the fair value of such an annuity is approximately $15,000—nearly double the "cost" of waiting.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the model provides a robust framework for individuals, it has limitations that invite future research:

  • Household Dynamics: The current model focuses on single individuals. Spousal and survivor benefits add significant complexity to the claiming decision for couples.
  • Endogenous Asset Allocation: The model assumes a fixed 60/40 investment glide path. Future iterations could optimize the asset allocation itself in conjunction with the claiming decision.
  • Behavioral Factors: The model assumes rational agents. It does not account for the psychological "bird in the hand" bias that often drives early claiming despite the mathematical advantages of waiting.

By providing a clear, ratio-based threshold, this research offers a practical tool for financial planners and individuals to navigate one of the most important milestones in retirement planning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Using a life-cycle framework, we compute the optimal age to claim Social Security benefits. If the ratio of a worker’s wealth to their primary insurance amount (PIA)—the monthly benefit payable at their full retirement age—exceeds a certain threshold, they should defer Social Security for at least a year or claim immediately. The optimal threshold depends on mortality assumptions and individual preferences, but is less sensitive to capital market assumptions. The threshold wealth to PIA ratio increases from 5.5 for men and 5.2 for women at age 62, to 11.1 for men and 10.4 for women at age 69. For example, a man with a PIA of $2,000 should delay past age 69 unless his wealth is less than $22,200, illustrating that all except those with low levels of wealth should delay claiming. Those with wealth below these levels should claim, because maintaining their consumption requires immediate Social Security payments.
BibTeX
@article{diamond2022optimal,
  author = {Steven Diamond and Stephen Boyd and David Greenberg and Mykel J. Kochenderfer and Andrew Ang},
  title = {{Optimal Claiming of Social Security Benefits}},
  journal = {The Journal of Retirement},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3905/jor.2022.1.117},
}

Loading related content...

Figure