Online Power Control Optimization for Wireless Transmission With Energy Harvesting and Storage

Fatemeh Amirnavaei, Min Dong

This paper presents a robust framework for managing power in wireless transmitters that rely on energy harvesting (like solar or wind) and finite battery storage. The authors develop an "online" algorithm—meaning it makes decisions in real-time without needing to know future energy arrivals or channel conditions—to maximize the long-term data transmission rate while respecting the physical limits of the battery.

TL;DR

The authors propose a Lyapunov-based online power control strategy that maximizes wireless transmission rates under realistic battery constraints without requiring any prior knowledge of energy or channel statistics. Their solution features a simple, three-stage closed-form power allocation that effectively handles unbounded channel fading and achieves near-optimal performance even with small battery capacities.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In the push for "green" communications, energy harvesting (EH) is a promising way to power remote sensors or base stations. However, EH introduces two major layers of randomness: the energy source itself (which is intermittent) and the wireless channel (which fades over time).

Most existing solutions fall into two traps:

  1. Offline optimization: They assume we know exactly when energy will arrive and how the channel will behave in the future, which is impossible in practice.
  2. Complex Statistics: They require knowing the exact probability distributions of energy and fading, which are difficult to model accurately for dynamic environments like solar or wind.

Furthermore, many models ignore realistic battery constraints, such as finite capacity and maximum charging/discharging rates. This paper bridges the gap by designing a practical, statistical-knowledge-free controller that handles these "messy" real-world constraints.

Methods

The researchers leverage the Lyapunov optimization framework, a tool typically used to stabilize queues in networks. They transform the long-term rate maximization problem into a "drift-plus-cost" minimization problem.

Key technical steps include:

  • Virtual Queues: They define a virtual queue that tracks the battery's state of charge relative to a target level. Keeping this virtual queue "stable" ensures the battery never overcharges or depletes.
  • Problem Relaxation: They relax strict per-slot battery constraints into long-term averages to make the math tractable, then prove that their final solution still satisfies the strict per-slot limits.
  • Handling Unbounded Fading: Standard Lyapunov techniques often struggle with "unbounded" variables (like Rayleigh fading, where the channel gain can theoretically be infinitely high). The authors introduce a novel "outage" mechanism and a time-averaged battery tracking method to maintain stability even during extreme channel events.
  • Closed-Form Solution: The resulting algorithm is computationally "cheap." It’s a three-stage logic: if the battery is low, stop transmitting; if it's high, transmit at max power; if it's in the middle, use a "water-filling" style power level based on the current channel gain.

Datasets

The paper evaluates the algorithm using numerical simulations rather than a static dataset.

  • Energy Arrivals: Modeled as a compound Poisson process (random bursts of energy).
  • Channel Fading: Modeled using i.i.d. complex Gaussian variables (Rayleigh fading), representing a typical wireless environment.
  • Benchmarks: The authors compare their work against a Greedy algorithm (spend all available energy), Power Halving (save half for later), and Energy Adaptive Water-Filling (EAWF).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Strategic Conservation: The algorithm doesn't just spend energy because it's there. It "learns" to save energy during poor channel conditions to spend it more effectively when the channel improves, effectively performing "water-filling" over time.
  • Battery Size Efficiency: A major "aha" moment is that you don't need a massive battery to reach near-optimal transmission rates. The algorithm is so efficient at managing energy that performance saturates quickly as battery size increases.
  • Zero-Knowledge Requirement: The most powerful aspect is that the transmitter doesn't need to know the average solar intensity or the average fading level; it only needs to see what is happening right now.

Key Results

  • Performance Gain: The proposed algorithm achieved a 70% higher average rate than the greedy approach and outperformed other heuristic methods (EAWF and power halving) by 30% to 50%.
  • Convergence: The system stabilizes and reaches its optimal average rate very quickly, making it suitable for real-time deployment.
  • Scalability: The authors demonstrated that the logic extends easily to MISO (Multiple-Input Single-Output) beamforming, where multiple antennas are used to focus the signal.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Perfect CSI: The paper assumes the transmitter has perfect "Channel State Information" (it knows exactly how strong the signal is at any moment). In reality, measuring this consumes energy and time.
  • Circuit Power: The model assumes power is only consumed by the transmission itself. Future work could incorporate "static" power costs (the energy needed just to keep the electronics turned on).
  • Multi-user Scenarios: This study focuses on a single point-to-point link. Extending this to a network where multiple users compete for the same energy or frequency bands would be a significant next step.

Summary updated

Abstract

We consider wireless transmission over fading channel powered by energy harvesting and storage devices. Assuming a finite battery storage capacity, we design an online power control strategy aiming at maximizing the long-term time-averaged transmission rate under battery operational constraints for energy harvesting. We first formulate the stochastic optimization problem, and then develop techniques to transform this problem and employ techniques from Lyapunov optimization to design the online power control solution. In particular, we propose an approach to handle unbounded channel fade which cannot by directly dealt with by Lyapunov framework. Our proposed algorithm determines the transmission power based only on the current energy state of the battery and channel fade conditions, without requiring any knowledge of the statistics of energy arrivals or fading channels. Our online power control solution is a three-stage closed-form solution depending on the battery energy level. It not only provides strategic energy conservation through the battery energy control, but also reveals an opportunistic transmission style based on fading condition, both of which improve the long-term time-averaged transmission rate. We further characterize the performance bound of our proposed algorithm to the optimal solution with a general fading distribution. Simulation results demonstrate a significant performance gain of our proposed online algorithm over alternative online approaches.
BibTeX
@article{amirnavaei2016online,
  author = {Fatemeh Amirnavaei and Min Dong},
  title = {{Online Power Control Optimization for Wireless Transmission With Energy Harvesting and Storage}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=vDFv73L6im},
}

Loading related content...

Figure