One Coin has Two Sides: A Comparative Appraisal of New York Times and China Daily's News Coverage of Alleged Internet Hacking

Wenyu Liu, Wen ZhangJournal of Arts and Humanities 2015 · DOI

Abstract

This study investigates the linguistic strategies employed by the New York Times and China Daily in their reporting on international hacking incidents in 2013. Utilizing the Engagement system within Appraisal Theory, the research explores how these outlets frame ideological stances while maintaining a facade of journalistic objectivity. The findings reveal that while both publications favor dialogic expansion to appear balanced, the New York Times adopts a more contractive, assertive stance against China. Conversely, China Daily demonstrated a significant rhetorical shift following the Edward Snowden revelations, transitioning from a defensive posture to an offensive critique of U.S. surveillance.

Introduction

The ideal of objective journalism—reporting facts without bias or emotion—is a cornerstone of media ethics. However, linguistic analysis often reveals that news reports are deeply embedded with the ideologies of their respective institutions. This paper examines this "myth of objectivity" by comparing the coverage of alleged internet hacking in the New York Times (NYT) and China Daily (CD) during 2013. This year was marked by two major events: the Mandiant report accusing China of state-sponsored cyberattacks and the Edward Snowden leaks exposing the U.S. PRISM program. By analyzing these reports, the study uncovers the hidden linguistic mechanisms used to shape public opinion during geopolitical conflicts.

Methods and Theoretical Framework

The research is grounded in Systemic Functional Linguistics (SFL), specifically the Appraisal Theory developed by Martin and White. SFL views language as a resource for making meaning within a social context, categorized into three metafunctions: interpersonal, textual, and ideational.

The three metafunctions of Systemic-Functional Grammar

Within this framework, Appraisal Theory focuses on the interpersonal metafunction—how writers evaluate phenomena and position themselves in relation to other voices. The study specifically analyzes the Engagement System, which manages the introduction of external perspectives into a text.

The Appraisal Theory framework, highlighting the Engagement system

The Engagement system distinguishes between Monogloss (where the authorial voice is the sole authority) and Heterogloss (where the author acknowledges alternative viewpoints). Heterogloss is further divided into:

  • Dialogic Contraction: Resources that "close down" space for alternative views (e.g., Disclaim or Proclaim).
  • Dialogic Expansion: Resources that "open up" space for other voices (e.g., Entertain or Attribute).

The authors analyzed 32 news reports using the UAM Corpus Tool 3.0, categorizing them into four corpora based on their timing relative to the Mandiant and Snowden events.

Key Findings

The Illusion of Balance

In all analyzed corpora, "Dialogic Expansion" (52%–63%) outweighed "Contraction." This suggests that both outlets prefer to appear balanced and interactive with their audience, even when pushing a specific ideological line. By opening up space for other voices, they maintain a veneer of objectivity.

NYT’s Determinative Stance

The New York Times consistently used more "Contractive" resources (specifically the Counter sub-type) than China Daily. By using words like "but," "yet," and "although" to introduce and then immediately dismiss opposing views, the NYT took a more "determinative" and assertive stance in accusing China of hacking.

China Daily’s "Objective" Shield

China Daily relied heavily on "Attribute" resources—quoting external experts or reports. This allows the outlet to maintain a neutral standpoint while using those external voices to clarify its innocence or refute accusations.

The Snowden Pivot

The most striking finding was the shift in China Daily’s tone. Before Snowden, they focused on defending against accusations. After Snowden, they significantly increased their use of "Entertain" resources (e.g., "it seems," "perhaps") to introduce alternative positions that criticized the US PRISM project, effectively moving from a defensive to an offensive rhetorical posture.

Conclusion

The study demonstrates that news reporting on sensitive geopolitical issues like cyber-hacking is rarely neutral. While both the New York Times and China Daily utilize similar linguistic tools to appear balanced, their underlying ideological goals dictate the specific distribution of engagement resources. The New York Times maintains a consistent, assertive stance, while China Daily adapts its rhetorical strategy to the evolving political landscape. Future research could expand this analysis by incorporating the "Attitude" and "Graduation" systems of Appraisal Theory to provide a more comprehensive view of media bias.

Summary updated

Abstract

There is always some debate as to whether news reporting is objective and emotionless. Under the guidance of engagement system, a sub-system of Appraisal Theory, concerning the conveyance of ideology, the present study attempts to make a comparative study of different ideological attitudes by news coverage in New York Times and China Daily’s (English version) on alleged internet hacking. The findings suggest that similar distributions of engagement resources in the news reports are adopted when engaged in an ideological attitude. Additionally, China Daily and New York Times hold different attitudes to Internet hacking. The attitude by China Daily changes before and after Snowden Event, while New York Times remains the same.
BibTeX
@article{liu2015one,
  author = {Wenyu Liu and Wen Zhang},
  title = {{One Coin has Two Sides: A Comparative Appraisal of New York Times and China Daily's News Coverage of Alleged Internet Hacking}},
  journal = {Journal of Arts and Humanities},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.18533/journal.v4i4.681},
}
Figure