Abstract
The frame analysis of Olympics-related news is quite popular, yet few studies do comparative studies of two Olympics hosted by ideologically similar countries. To fill this gap in the literature, this study examined the similarities and differences of an American news agency CNN’s (Cable News Networks) coverages in the 2014 Sochi Winter Olympics and 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics. Under the theoretical framework of framing theory, a content analysis (N = 200) of news stories was conducted. The following four frames were measured: (a) sports frame, (b) human-interest frame, (c) morality frame, and (d) political frame. Findings revealed that the sports frame was mentioned the most frequently in both Olympics. Furthermore, Russia received more coverage in the human-interest and morality frames, while China received more publications in the political frame.
Introduction
Media agencies do more than report facts; they "frame" stories by selecting specific information to shape audience perception. While many studies have analyzed the framing of a single Olympic event, there is a lack of comparative research on how the same news outlet treats different host nations that share similar ideological backgrounds. This study, authored by Xi Yu, addresses this gap by investigating whether CNN’s narrative strategy changed between the 2014 Sochi Games (Russia) and the 2022 Beijing Games (China). The goal is to understand how an American news giant navigates the intersection of sports, human rights, and geopolitics when reporting on "ideologically similar" nations.
Methodology
The researcher employed Framing Theory and a qualitative content analysis approach. Using an inductive approach, frames were allowed to emerge from the news stories, a method well-suited for smaller sample sizes where topics may be unpredictable. The analysis utilized Teun van Dijk’s (1980) theory of semantic macrostructures, applying rules of generalization, deletion, and integration to distill complex news articles into their core meanings.
Articles were categorized into four primary frames:
- Sports: Athletes, facilities, results, and doping.
- Human-interest: Individual rights, health, safety, and LGBTQ+ issues.
- Morality: Ethical prescriptions, "right vs. wrong," and social justice.
- Political: Government actions, international relations, and diplomatic boycotts.
The study analyzed a total of 200 news items (N=200) sourced from CNN’s official website: 80 items from Sochi 2014 (Feb 7–23) and 120 items from Beijing 2022 (Feb 2–20).
Analysis of Framing Strategies
While the "Sports Frame" was the most frequent in both cases (approx. 74%), the specific content within that frame revealed significant biases. For Russia, CNN focused heavily on athletic failures (20.45% of event coverage). In contrast, for China, CNN focused on Chinese triumphs (53%) and ignored Chinese losses entirely (0%). This suggests a framing of China as a "powerful and potentially threatening" rising power rather than an underperforming host.
Furthermore, CNN utilized human-interest and morality frames as tools for criticism. For Sochi, the focus was on anti-gay policies and security threats. For Beijing, the narrative shifted toward the "genocide" of the Uyghurs and COVID-19 isolation protocols. The paper argues that CNN framed Russia as an "ambitious wolf" that failed to enhance its soft power due to internal corruption, whereas China was framed through a political lens, focusing on diplomatic boycotts and its challenge to the global power balance.
Comparative Results
The data shows that while the sports frame remained consistent, the secondary frames shifted significantly between the two events.
- Sports Frame: Consistent at roughly 74% for both.
- Human-Interest Frame: Higher for Russia (17.24%) than for China (15%).
- Morality Frame: Significantly higher for Russia (5.75%) compared to China (1%).
- Political Frame: Nearly three times higher for China (10%) than for Russia (3.45%).
Conclusion
The study highlights how Western media shifts its secondary focus—using human-interest and morality frames to critique Russia’s internal policies, while employing political frames to highlight China’s rising global influence.
Limitations include the reliance on a single news source (CNN), a narrow timeframe limited to the duration of the games, and a relatively small sample size. Future research should expand the timeframe and include multiple news agencies from different countries to provide a more comprehensive view of international media framing.
Summary updated