Abstract
In this letter, the secrecy performance of a decode-and-forward (DF) principle based mixed free space optics (FSO) and radio frequency (RF) system is analyzed. The analysis is done from physical layer (PHY) security perspective. Herein, two different eavesdroppers are considered while signal is transmitting from source (S) to destination (D) through a relay (R) point. The FSO based and RF based eavesdroppers are trying to intercept the confidential signal from S-R link and R-D links respectively. The faded FSO links are modeled by Málaga (M) distribution and RF links are characterized by Nakagami-m distribution. Exact closed form expression for secrecy performance metric such as secrecy outage probability is derived and analyzed for the aforementioned system in terms of Meijer's G-function and bivariate Fox's H-function. Furthermore, the asymptotic expressions for these performance metrics are derived by employing high signal to noise ratio (SNR) approximation. Afterwards the results are verified by Monte-Carlo simulations. Finally, the secrecy threshold for the system is derived to get insight of the system reliability and secrecy.
Introduction
Wireless communication is inherently vulnerable to eavesdropping because signals are broadcast through open space. While traditional security measures operate at higher software layers through encryption, Physical Layer Security (PHY) leverages the physical characteristics of the communication channel itself to ensure data privacy. This approach is increasingly vital for hybrid systems that combine Free Space Optics (FSO) for high-speed backhaul with Radio Frequency (RF) for end-user connectivity. This paper addresses a realistic "worst-case" scenario: simultaneous eavesdropping on both the FSO link (where a spy might intercept a reflected laser beam) and the RF link.
System Model and Methodology
The authors analyze a three-node cooperative system consisting of a Source, a Relay, and a Destination. The Source-to-Relay link utilizes FSO, modeled by the Málaga ($M$) distribution to account for atmospheric turbulence and pointing errors. The Relay-to-Destination link uses RF, modeled by the Nakagami-$m$ distribution.
To quantify security, the authors derive exact closed-form expressions for the Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP)—the probability that the secrecy capacity falls below a target rate—and the Strictly Positive Secrecy Capacity (SPSC). Due to the complexity of these channels, the solutions involve advanced mathematical tools like Meijer’s G-functions and bivariate Fox’s H-functions. The analytical models are validated using Monte-Carlo simulations, which generate thousands of random channel realizations to ensure the formulas' accuracy.
Impact of Channel Conditions and Detection
A key insight of the study is the significant impact of FSO detection methods on security. The paper compares Heterodyne Detection (HD) and Intensity Modulation with Direct Detection (IM/DD), demonstrating that HD consistently provides superior secrecy performance across various conditions.
Atmospheric conditions and alignment are also critical. As atmospheric turbulence becomes less severe (higher $\alpha$ and $\beta$ parameters), secrecy performance improves. Furthermore, pointing accuracy (how well the laser is aimed) is vital; high accuracy not only improves signal strength but also significantly widens the "secrecy gap" between the legitimate receiver and an eavesdropper.
Key Results
The derived analytical expressions perfectly match the Monte-Carlo simulation results, confirming the model's reliability. The SOP improves (decreases) as the average SNR of the legitimate link increases. Additionally, the authors provide simplified "asymptotic" formulas for high SNR scenarios, which tightly approximate the exact results and offer a practical tool for system designers to estimate security without complex computations.
Conclusion and Future Work
This research provides a rigorous framework for evaluating the security of mixed FSO/RF systems under multi-hop eavesdropping threats. While the study focuses on Decode and Forward (DF) relays and independent eavesdroppers, future work could explore Amplify and Forward (AF) protocols or scenarios where multiple eavesdroppers collaborate to combine intercepted signals. Additionally, maintaining security with zero knowledge of the eavesdropper's channel remains a promising direction for future investigation.
Summary updated