On the Physical Layer Security of a Decode and Forward Based Mixed FSO/RF Co-Operative System

Dipti R. Pattanayak, Vivek Kumar Dwivedi, Vikram Karwal, Imran Shafique Ansari, Hongjiang Lei, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper provides a rigorous mathematical analysis of the physical layer security (PHY) for hybrid communication systems that combine laser-based (Free Space Optics) and radio-based (RF) links. By deriving exact closed-form expressions for secrecy metrics, the authors demonstrate how atmospheric turbulence, pointing errors, and detection methods impact a system's ability to keep data private from multiple eavesdroppers.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wireless communication is inherently "leaky" because signals are broadcast through open space, making them vulnerable to eavesdropping. While traditional security happens at higher software layers (like encryption), Physical Layer Security (PHY) exploits the physical characteristics of the communication channel itself to ensure that an eavesdropper cannot decode the message, regardless of their computing power.

Mixed systems—using Free Space Optics (FSO) for high-speed backhaul and Radio Frequency (RF) for the final user connection—are becoming popular for 5G and beyond. However, most previous research only considered eavesdroppers on the RF side. This paper addresses a more realistic "worst-case" scenario: simultaneous eavesdropping on both the FSO link (where a spy might catch a reflected laser beam) and the RF link.

Methods

The authors model a three-node system: a Source, a Relay, and a Destination.

  • The Links: The Source-to-Relay link uses FSO, modeled by the Málaga ($M$) distribution (which accounts for atmospheric turbulence). The Relay-to-Destination link uses RF, modeled by the Nakagami-$m$ distribution (a standard model for fading).
  • The Threat: Two independent eavesdroppers are present—one attempting to intercept the FSO signal at the relay and another intercepting the RF signal at the destination.
  • Mathematical Framework: To quantify security, the authors derive exact expressions for Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP)—the chance that the secrecy capacity falls below a target rate—and Strictly Positive Secrecy Capacity (SPSC).
  • Special Functions: Because the physics of these channels is complex, the solutions involve advanced mathematical tools like Meijer’s G-functions and bivariate Fox’s H-functions. They also provide simplified "asymptotic" formulas for high Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) scenarios to make the results easier for engineers to use.

Datasets

The paper does not use external real-world datasets. Instead, it relies on Monte-Carlo simulations to generate thousands of random channel realizations. These simulations are used to verify that the complex analytical formulas derived by the authors are accurate.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Worst-Case" Perspective: By assuming eavesdroppers are present at every hop of the mixed system, the paper provides a lower bound on security that is highly relevant for military or high-security commercial applications.
  • Detection Strategy Matters: The paper compares two FSO detection methods: Heterodyne Detection (HD) and Intensity Modulation with Direct Detection (IM/DD). A key insight is that Heterodyne Detection consistently provides better secrecy performance across various conditions.
  • Pointing Accuracy is Vital: In FSO, "pointing error" (how well the laser is aimed) is a major factor. High pointing accuracy doesn't just improve signal strength; it significantly widens the "secrecy gap" between the legitimate receiver and a nearby eavesdropper.
  • Turbulence Impact: As atmospheric turbulence becomes less severe (higher $\alpha$ and $\beta$ parameters), the secrecy performance improves. This suggests that these systems are naturally more secure in clear, stable weather conditions.

Key Results

  • Analytical Validation: The derived closed-form expressions perfectly match the Monte-Carlo simulation results, proving the mathematical model's reliability.
  • SOP Trends: The Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP) decreases (improves) as the average SNR of the legitimate link increases, as expected.
  • Asymptotic Accuracy: The simplified high-SNR formulas "tightly approximate" the exact results, providing a practical tool for system designers to estimate security without needing to compute the full, complex functions.
  • Comparative Performance: The results quantify exactly how much better HD is than IM/DD, showing a clear advantage in secrecy capacity for the former.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Relay Protocol: The study focuses on "Decode and Forward" (DF) relays. Future work could explore "Amplify and Forward" (AF) relays, which are simpler but handle noise differently.
  • Eavesdropper Cooperation: The model assumes eavesdroppers act independently. In reality, multiple eavesdroppers might collaborate (colluding eavesdroppers) to combine their intercepted signals, which would further challenge the system's security.
  • Channel Knowledge: The analysis assumes certain statistical knowledge of the eavesdropper's channel, which is often difficult to obtain in real-world "blind" scenarios. Exploring how to maintain security with zero knowledge of the eavesdropper is a promising future direction.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this letter, the secrecy performance of a decode-and-forward (DF) principle based mixed free space optics (FSO) and radio frequency (RF) system is analyzed. The analysis is done from physical layer (PHY) security perspective. Herein, two different eavesdroppers are considered while signal is transmitting from source (S) to destination (D) through a relay (R) point. The FSO based and RF based eavesdroppers are trying to intercept the confidential signal from S-R link and R-D links respectively. The faded FSO links are modeled by Málaga (M) distribution and RF links are characterized by Nakagami-m distribution. Exact closed form expression for secrecy performance metric such as secrecy outage probability is derived and analyzed for the aforementioned system in terms of Meijer's G-function and bivariate Fox's H-function. Furthermore, the asymptotic expressions for these performance metrics are derived by employing high signal to noise ratio (SNR) approximation. Afterwards the results are verified by Monte-Carlo simulations. Finally, the secrecy threshold for the system is derived to get insight of the system reliability and secrecy.
BibTeX
@article{pattanayak2020physical,
  author = {Dipti R. Pattanayak and Vivek Kumar Dwivedi and Vikram Karwal and Imran Shafique Ansari and Hongjiang Lei and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Physical Layer Security of a Decode and Forward Based Mixed FSO/RF Co-Operative System}},
  journal = {IEEE Wireless Communications Letters},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=77UXt6gtOe},
}

Loading related content...

Figure