Abstract: This paper studies the performance of hybrid radio-frequency (RF) and free-space optical (FSO) links assuming perfect channel state information (CSI) at the receiver. Considering the cases with and without hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ), we derive closed-form expressions for the message decoding probabilities as well as the throughput and the outage probability of the RF-FSO setups. We also evaluate the effect of adaptive power allocation and different channel conditions on the throughput and the outage probability. The results show the efficiency of the RF-FSO links in different conditions.
Introduction
As the demand for high-bandwidth wireless communication grows, researchers are looking toward the synergy between Radio Frequency (RF) and Free-Space Optical (FSO) technologies. While FSO offers fiber-like speeds, it is highly susceptible to atmospheric conditions like fog. Conversely, millimeter-wave RF links are robust against fog but struggle during heavy rain. This paper explores a joint transmission strategy where data is sent over both links simultaneously, augmented by Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) to ensure ultra-reliable, high-rate performance.
System Architecture
The core of the proposed system is a joint transmission model. Unlike previous research that treated the RF link as a simple backup, this model utilizes both channels in parallel.
As shown in the system diagram, an encoder splits the data into parallel streams for the RF and FSO links. The receiver (decoder) processes these signals and provides feedback via an HARQ mechanism. If a message is not correctly decoded, the transmitter sends additional parity bits in subsequent rounds—a process known as Incremental Redundancy (INR) HARQ—to help the receiver reconstruct the original data.
Transmission Protocol and Channel Dynamics
A critical challenge in analyzing these hybrid systems is the differing coherence times of the two media. FSO channels typically fluctuate much faster than RF channels.
The timing diagram illustrates how multiple fading blocks of the FSO channel can occur within a single retransmission round, while the RF channel might remain relatively static over the same period. To handle this complexity, the authors employed the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to model the rapidly changing FSO link and used Minkowski and Jensen’s inequalities to find performance bounds for the combined system.
Key Insights and Analytical Results
The paper provides several closed-form mathematical expressions that allow engineers to predict system behavior without relying solely on time-consuming simulations. Key findings include:
- The Diversity Advantage: By quantifying diversity gain, the authors show that the joint system maintains connectivity even when one link is completely obstructed, as RF and FSO rarely fail simultaneously.
- The 50/50 Power Rule: A significant result (Lemma 6) demonstrates that at high signal-to-noise ratios (SNR), the optimal strategy is to split power equally between the RF and FSO links. This simplifies hardware design by removing the need for complex, real-time power-balancing algorithms in high-performance regimes.
- Power and Throughput Efficiency: For a target outage probability of $10^{-2}$, the joint system reduces required power by 16 dB compared to RF alone and 4 dB compared to FSO alone. Furthermore, implementing HARQ with just two rounds ($M=2$) leads to a massive reduction in outage probability compared to systems without retransmissions.
Limitations and Future Work
While the results are promising, the study assumes several ideal conditions that provide avenues for future research:
- Perfect CSI: The model assumes the receiver has perfect Channel State Information, which is difficult to maintain in volatile atmospheric conditions.
- Ideal Feedback: The HARQ mechanism assumes instantaneous and error-free "ACK/NACK" feedback.
- Synchronization: Perfect synchronization between the light-based FSO and radio-based RF links is assumed, which remains a significant real-world engineering challenge.
In conclusion, the integration of joint transmission and HARQ in hybrid RF-FSO systems offers a robust solution for next-generation wireless networks, providing a clear path toward balancing high throughput with extreme reliability.
Summary updated