On the Performance of RF-FSO Links With and Without Hybrid ARQ

Behrooz Makki, Tommy Svensson, Thomas Eriksson, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

This paper, published in 2016, explores the synergy between two high-bandwidth wireless technologies: Radio Frequency (RF) and Free-Space Optical (FSO) communication. By combining these links and adding a layer of intelligent retransmission (Hybrid ARQ), the authors demonstrate a path toward ultra-reliable, high-rate wireless networks.

TL;DR

The paper provides a comprehensive analytical framework for hybrid RF-FSO systems, proving that joint transmission combined with Incremental Redundancy HARQ dramatically improves reliability and throughput. A key finding is that while adaptive power allocation helps at low signal levels, a simple 50/50 power split becomes optimal at high signal-to-noise ratios (SNR), regardless of atmospheric conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

As we push for higher data rates, FSO (using lasers through the air) offers fiber-like speeds but is notoriously unreliable; a bit of fog or a passing cloud can kill the link. Conversely, millimeter-wave RF links are robust against fog but suffer during heavy rain.

While these two technologies are perfectly complementary (rain hurts RF; fog hurts FSO), most previous research treated the RF link merely as a "backup" that sits idle until the FSO link fails. This paper tackles the challenge of joint transmission—sending data over both links simultaneously—and analyzes how Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ) can further boost performance. The authors aim to move beyond simple simulations by deriving closed-form mathematical expressions that engineers can use to predict system behavior under various weather conditions.

Methods

The authors model a system where an encoder splits data into parallel streams for RF and FSO links. They focus on Incremental Redundancy (INR) HARQ, where if a message isn't decoded correctly, the transmitter sends additional parity bits in subsequent rounds to help the receiver "piece together" the original data.

The paper’s technical heavy lifting involves:

  • Analytical Derivations: They derive new closed-form expressions for message decoding probabilities, throughput, and outage probability.
  • Approximation Techniques: Because the math for these combined channels is complex, they use the Central Limit Theorem (CLT) to model the FSO link when it changes much faster than the RF link. For cases where both links change at similar speeds, they employ Minkowski and Jensen’s inequalities to find performance bounds.
  • Channel Modeling: They test their models against three common FSO turbulence distributions: Exponential, Log-normal, and Gamma-Gamma.

Datasets

This is a theoretical and analytical paper, so it does not use external real-world datasets. Instead, the authors validate their mathematical "Lemmas" using extensive Monte Carlo simulations. They simulate various atmospheric conditions by adjusting parameters like the Rytov variance (to model turbulence) and normalized log-normal distributions for fading.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Diversity" Advantage: The biggest "aha" moment is the quantification of the diversity gain. Because RF and FSO rarely fail at the same time, the joint system can maintain a connection even when one link is completely blocked.
  • The 50/50 Rule: The authors prove (in Lemma 6) that at high SNR, the optimal power allocation strategy is to simply split power equally between the RF and FSO links. This is a powerful result for hardware designers because it means complex, real-time power-balancing algorithms aren't necessary in high-performance regimes.
  • HARQ Efficiency: HARQ is most effective at low-to-moderate SNRs. At very high SNRs, the "open-loop" (single transmission) performance is already so good that the overhead of HARQ provides diminishing returns.
  • Coherence Time Sensitivity: The paper highlights that the relative "speed" of the channel (coherence time) dictates which mathematical tools are best for analysis. If the FSO channel fluctuates rapidly, the system effectively "averages out" the noise, behaving like an AWGN channel with a fixed boost.

Key Results

  • Power Savings: For a target outage probability of $10^{-2}$, the joint RF-FSO system reduces the required power by 16 dB compared to using RF alone, and by 4 dB compared to using FSO alone.
  • Throughput Gains: Implementing HARQ with just two rounds ($M=2$) leads to a massive reduction in outage probability compared to a system without retransmissions.
  • Model Accuracy: The derived analytical approximations (Lemmas 1-5) were shown to be extremely tight, meaning they "mimic" the actual simulation results with high precision across different power levels.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge a few simplifying assumptions that provide opportunities for future research:

  • Perfect CSI: The study assumes the receiver has perfect Channel State Information (CSI), which is difficult to achieve in rapidly changing atmospheric conditions.
  • Ideal Feedback: The HARQ mechanism assumes the "ACK/NACK" feedback from the receiver is error-free and instantaneous.
  • Infinite Code Length: The math assumes "asymptotically long codes." Real-world systems use finite-length packets, which introduces additional latency and error floor issues.
  • Synchronization: The paper assumes perfect synchronization between the RF and FSO links, a non-trivial engineering challenge given the different propagation characteristics of light and radio waves.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper studies the performance of hybrid radio-frequency (RF) and free-space optical (FSO) links assuming perfect channel state information (CSI) at the receiver. Considering the cases with and without hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ), we derive closed-form expressions for the message decoding probabilities as well as the throughput and the outage probability of the RF-FSO setups. We also evaluate the effect of adaptive power allocation and different channel conditions on the throughput and the outage probability. The results show the efficiency of the RF-FSO links in different conditions.
BibTeX
@article{makki2016performance,
  author = {Behrooz Makki and Tommy Svensson and Thomas Eriksson and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Performance of RF-FSO Links With and Without Hybrid ARQ}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Jy3oVF8Vie},
}

Loading related content...

Figure