On the Performance of Millimeter Wave-Based RF-FSO Multi-Hop and Mesh Networks

Behrooz Makki, Tommy Svensson, Maïté Brandt-Pearce, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Introduction

As 5G and future wireless generations strive for fiber-like data rates, the integration of Millimeter Wave (MMW) and Free-Space Optical (FSO) technologies becomes essential. FSO offers massive bandwidth but is vulnerable to atmospheric conditions like fog, while MMW-based RF links provide high speeds with better resilience to weather. While point-to-point hybrid links are well-studied, real-world deployments often involve complex multi-hop "daisy chains" or mesh networks. This paper provides a comprehensive analytical framework for evaluating these sophisticated topologies, specifically accounting for non-ideal hardware and advanced error-correction protocols like Hybrid Automatic Repeat Request (HARQ).

Methodology

The researchers developed a mathematical framework to predict outage probability and data rates across mixed-media networks. They employed a Rician fading model for MMW-RF links and Exponential or Gamma-Gamma distributions for FSO links to account for atmospheric turbulence. A key differentiator of this work is the integration of a state-of-the-art model for Power Amplifier (PA) efficiency, acknowledging real-world hardware impairments.

To handle the mathematical complexity of multi-hop mesh networks, the authors developed several approximation paths based on codeword length:

  • Central Limit Theorem (CLT): Applied to "long codewords" where many channel realizations occur during a single transmission.
  • Minkowski Inequality/Bounding: Applied to "short codewords" where the channel remains relatively static.
Summary of the analytical framework including Lemmas and Corollaries for RF and FSO metrics.

The framework's validity was confirmed through extensive Monte Carlo simulations, ensuring that the "near-closed-form" expressions accurately reflect performance across various Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR) regimes.

Key Insights

The "Mapping" Phenomenon

A significant finding is the existence of mathematical mappings between RF and FSO hops. By scaling specific channel parameters, an RF hop can be modeled to "look" like an FSO hop in terms of outage probability. This simplifies the analysis of heterogeneous networks by allowing them to be treated under a unified mathematical umbrella.

HARQ as a Hardware Compensator

The study demonstrates that HARQ is not merely an error-correction tool but a powerful mechanism to mitigate hardware impairments. In networks with inefficient PAs, HARQ effectively "hides" these shortcomings, bringing performance levels close to those of ideal hardware.

Antenna Sensitivity and Mesh Benefits

While network outage probability becomes insensitive to the number of RF antennas beyond a small threshold (e.g., $N \ge 3$), the ergodic rate (average data rate) continues to scale significantly with additional antennas. Furthermore, mesh networks provide a massive boost through path diversity; for a target outage of $10^{-6}$, moving from a single route to a mesh with multiple parallel paths can reduce the required SNR at each hop by approximately 1.2 dB.

Results

The analytical approximations (Lemmas 1-6) match numerical simulations almost perfectly, providing a reliable shortcut for network design. Key performance metrics include:

  • Energy Efficiency: For a standard dual-hop setup with a target outage of $10^{-4}$, implementing HARQ with three retransmissions reduces the required transmit power by 17 dB compared to open-loop systems.
  • Rate Matching: The paper introduces a specific formula (Corollary 2) to calculate the minimum number of RF antennas required to prevent the RF segment from becoming a bottleneck for high-speed FSO links.

Conclusion and Future Work

While this framework offers robust tools for designing hybrid MMW-FSO networks, some limitations remain. The current mesh analysis assumes non-overlapping routes, potentially underestimating inter-link interference in dense deployments. Future research could expand this to include Amplify-and-Forward relaying strategies and account for weather correlation across multiple hops, where a single atmospheric event might simultaneously degrade several FSO links.

Summary updated

Abstract

This paper studies the performance of multi-hop and mesh networks composed of millimeter wave-based radio frequency (RF) and free-space optical (FSO) links. The results are obtained in cases with and without hybrid automatic repeat request (HARQ). Using the central limit theorem as well as other state-of-the-art approximation schemes, we derive closed-form expressions for the networks' outage probability and ergodic achievable rates. We also evaluate the effect of various parameters such as power amplifiers efficiency, number of antennas as well as different coherence times of the RF and the FSO links on the system performance. Finally, we determine the minimum number of the transmit antennas in the RF link such that the same rate is supported in the RF- and the FSO-based hops. The results show the efficiency of the RF-FSO setups in different conditions. Moreover, HARQ can effectively improve the outage probability/energy efficiency, and compensate for the effect of hardware impairments in RF-FSO networks. For common parameter settings of the RF-FSO dual-hop networks, outage probability of 10 <sup xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">-4</sup> and code rate of 3 nats-per-channel-use, the implementation of HARQ with a maximum of 2 and 3 retransmissions reduces the required power, compared to cases with open-loop communication, by 13 and 17 dB, respectively.
BibTeX
@article{makki2017performance,
  author = {Behrooz Makki and Tommy Svensson and Maïté Brandt-Pearce and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Performance of Millimeter Wave-Based RF-FSO Multi-Hop and Mesh Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=8BMvCeh0VL},
}
Figure