On the Performance of Dual-Hop Systems Over Mixed FSO/mmWave Fading Channels

Yan Zhang, Jiayi Zhang, Liang Yang, Bo Ai, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Abstract

Free-space optical (FSO) links are considered as a cost-efficient way to fill the backhaul/fronthaul connectivity gap between millimeter wave (mmWave) access networks and optical fiber based central networks. In this paper, we investigate the end-to-end performance of dual-hop mixed FSO/mmWave systems to address this combined use. The FSO link is modeled as a Gamma-Gamma fading channel using both heterodyne detection and indirect modulation/direct detection with pointing error impairments, while the mmWave link experiences the fluctuating two-ray fading. Under the assumption of both amplify-and-forward and decode-and-forward relaying, we derive novel closed-form expressions for the outage probability, average bit error probability (BER), ergodic capacity, and effective capacity in terms of bivariate Fox's H-functions. Additionally, we discuss the diversity gain and provide other important engineering insights based on the high signal-to-noise-ratio analysis of the outage probability and the average BER. Finally, all our analytical results are verified using Monte Carlo simulations.

Introduction

As 5G and future 6G networks deploy ultra-dense "small cells" to provide unprecedented data rates, the logistical challenge of connecting these cells to the core network—the backhaul/fronthaul—becomes critical. While fiber-optic cables are the gold standard for high-capacity links, their deployment is often prohibitively expensive or physically impossible in dense urban environments.

Free-space optical (FSO) communication offers a high-bandwidth, cost-effective alternative by transmitting data via lasers through the air. However, FSO performance is significantly degraded by atmospheric turbulence and pointing errors caused by building sway. Conversely, Millimeter Wave (mmWave) technology is ideal for high-speed wireless access but faces complex fading challenges. This paper addresses the need for a unified mathematical framework to evaluate a "dual-hop" system that bridges these two technologies, providing a robust solution for the "backhaul gap."

System Model and Relaying Strategies

The studied system consists of a source (S) transmitting to a destination (D) via an intermediate relay (R). The first hop utilizes an FSO link, while the second hop employs a mmWave RF link.

System model of a dual-hop mixed FSO/mmWave communication system.

The researchers analyzed two primary relaying protocols to manage the signal transition at the relay node:

  1. Amplify-and-Forward (AF): The relay simply amplifies the received signal and retransmits it. This is a low-complexity, low-latency approach.
  2. Decode-and-Forward (DF): The relay decodes the incoming data and re-encodes it before transmission, which can significantly improve reliability by preventing noise propagation.

To ensure realistic modeling, the FSO link incorporates Gamma-Gamma fading with pointing error impairments, supporting both Heterodyne detection and Intensity Modulation/Direct Detection (IM/DD). The mmWave link is modeled using Fluctuating Two-Ray (FTR) fading, a sophisticated model that accurately represents experimental data for 28 GHz channels better than traditional Rayleigh or Rician models.

Performance Analysis and Engineering Insights

The core contribution of this work is the derivation of novel closed-form expressions for key performance metrics using bivariate Fox’s H-functions. This mathematical approach allows for precise performance prediction without the need for exhaustive simulations.

Key Insights

  • The "Weakest Link" Principle: The overall system diversity gain is primarily limited by the FSO link parameters, specifically atmospheric turbulence (defined by parameters $\alpha, \beta$) and pointing errors ($\xi$). If the laser alignment is poor, increasing mmWave power cannot fully compensate for the loss.
  • Detection Robustness: Heterodyne detection consistently outperforms IM/DD. While IM/DD is simpler and cheaper, Heterodyne is significantly more resilient against the signal "flickering" caused by atmospheric turbulence.
  • Model Versatility: The use of the FTR model for the mmWave hop provides a generalized framework. By adjusting FTR parameters, the results can be simplified to older models like Nakagami-m, making the study broadly applicable to various wireless environments.

Results and Validation

The derived analytical expressions for Outage Probability, Average Bit Error Rate (BER), and Capacity were validated using extensive Monte Carlo simulations. In all test cases—ranging from strong to moderate turbulence and varying pointing error intensities—the analytical curves perfectly matched the simulation results, confirming the accuracy of the complex H-function derivations.

The study also quantified the diversity order ($G_d$). For AF relaying, $G_d = \min(2, \xi^2/r, \alpha/r, \beta/r)$, while for DF relaying, $G_d = \min(1, \xi^2/r, \alpha/r, \beta/r)$, where $r$ denotes the detection mode. Furthermore, the analysis of "Effective Capacity" demonstrated how delay constraints, vital for real-time applications like AR/VR, degrade the total throughput of the mixed link.

Conclusion and Future Directions

This research provides a rigorous foundation for designing hybrid FSO/mmWave backhaul solutions for next-generation networks. While the current model focuses on a single-relay setup, future work could extend this to multi-hop mesh networks or relay selection schemes. Additionally, incorporating the specific impacts of weather extremes like heavy fog or rain, and accounting for co-channel interference in dense deployments, would further enhance the model's practical utility for 6G network planning.

Summary updated

Abstract

Free-space optical (FSO) links are considered as a cost-efficient way to fill the backhaul/fronthaul connectivity gap between millimeter wave (mmWave) access networks and optical fiber based central networks. In this paper, we investigate the end-to-end performance of dual-hop mixed FSO/mmWave systems to address this combined use. The FSO link is modeled as a Gamma-Gamma fading channel using both heterodyne detection and indirect modulation/direct detection with pointing error impairments, while the mmWave link experiences the fluctuating two-ray fading. Under the assumption of both amplify-and-forward and decode-and-forward relaying, we derive novel closed-form expressions for the outage probability, average bit error probability (BER), ergodic capacity, effective capacity in terms of bivariate Fox's H-functions. Additionally, we discuss the diversity gain and provide other important engineering insights based on the high signal-to-noise-ratio analysis of the outage probability and the average BER. Finally, all our analytical results are verified using Monte Carlo simulations.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2020performance,
  author = {Yan Zhang and Jiayi Zhang and Liang Yang and Bo Ai and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Performance of Dual-Hop Systems Over Mixed FSO/mmWave Fading Channels}},
  journal = {IEEE Open J. Commun. Soc.},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=glc7RL6F6a},
}
Figure