On the calculation of normal modes of a coupled ice-shelf/sub-ice-shelf cavity system

Michael H. Meylan, Luke G. Bennetts, R. J. Hosking, Elliot CattJournal of Glaciology 2017 · DOI

Abstract

A corrected solution method is presented for a mathematical model of wave motions in a coupled ice-shelf/sub-iceshelf water-cavity system. The method is used to calculate the periods of the system’s normal modes, and the longest periods are shown to be significantly larger than those calculated using an existing method containing errors. Highly accurate approximations of the normal-mode periods are obtained for a model involving a single non-spectral physical parameter - the shelf/cavity length.

Introduction

Antarctic ice shelves are not static; they behave as massive, flexible elastic plates floating over ocean cavities. When external forces like tsunamis or infragravity (IG) waves interact with these shelves, they can excite "normal modes"—resonant standing waves where the ice and the underlying water vibrate in unison. Accurately predicting these resonant frequencies is essential for understanding the mechanical stresses that lead to iceberg calving. This paper identifies and corrects a fundamental mathematical error in a previously established model (Sergienko, 2013), revealing that the longest-period vibrations are significantly longer than previously estimated.

Methodology

The authors utilize a one-dimensional thin-plate/shallow-water model, treating the ice shelf as an elastic beam and the water as a shallow cavity. The primary technical contribution is the correction of the dispersion relation, which links wave frequency to wavelength.

The previous model assumed that the complex roots of the dispersion equation were simple multiples of the real root. The authors demonstrate that this assumption fails at low frequencies. By using the correct solutions for the "depressed cubic" equation, they reformulate the boundary conditions into a $6 \times 6$ matrix. Normal modes are identified where the determinant of this matrix is zero. To validate the model, they used standard physical parameters: an ice thickness of 300 m, a cavity depth of 100 m, and shelf lengths ($L$) varying from 10 to 100 km.

Key Results and Insights

The most significant finding is the "low-frequency divergence." At low frequencies (long periods), the previous model's complex roots vanished, whereas the corrected roots remain non-zero. This mathematical fix has a profound impact on the calculated fundamental period ($T_1$).

Ratio of corrected fundamental period to the previously calculated period as a function of shelf length $L$.

As shown in the figure above, the discrepancy between the old and new methods grows with the length of the ice shelf. For a 40 km shelf, the corrected fundamental period is 0.677 hours, a ~30% increase over the previous estimate of 0.521 hours.

Comparison of resonant periods ($T_n$) between the original method and the corrected method for various modes.

The table highlights that while the correction is substantial for the longest periods ($n=1, 2$), it becomes negligible for higher-frequency modes ($n \ge 7$). For typical IG waves (100–300 seconds), the correction changes results by less than 1%.

Conclusion

The study concludes that for the longest resonant periods, the system is dominated by the flexural rigidity of the ice shelf rather than its inertia. While the model assumes uniform geometry and one-dimensionality, these corrected periods provide a more accurate benchmark for monitoring ice shelf stability using seismic or GPS data. Future work may incorporate non-linear effects and 2D plate geometry to further refine these predictions.

Summary updated

Abstract

A corrected solution method is presented for a mathematical model of wave motions in a coupled ice-shelf/sub-iceshelf water-cavity system. The method is used to calculate the periods of the system’s normal modes, and the longest periods are shown to be significantly larger than those calculated using an existing method containing errors. Highly accurate approximations of the normal-mode periods are obtained for a model involving a single non-spectral physical parameter - the shelf/cavity length.
BibTeX
@article{meylan2017calculation,
  author = {Michael H. Meylan and Luke G. Bennetts and R. J. Hosking and Elliot Catt},
  title = {{On the calculation of normal modes of a coupled ice-shelf/sub-ice-shelf cavity system}},
  journal = {Journal of Glaciology},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1017/jog.2017.27},
}
Figure