Hydrodynamic-driven morphogenesis of karst draperies: spatio-temporal analysis of the two-dimensional impulse response – CORRIGENDUM

Pier Giuseppe Ledda, Gioele Balestra, Gaétan Lerisson, Benoît Scheid, Matthieu Wyart, François GallaireJournal of Fluid Mechanics 2021 · DOI · OpenAlex

Karst draperies, colloquially known as "cave bacon," are striking, thin, undulating mineral formations that hang from the ceilings and walls of limestone caves. The morphogenesis of these structures is a complex phenomenon driven by the hydrodynamic behavior of thin water films flowing over mineral surfaces, coupled with the chemical processes of mineral precipitation. A previous study provided a detailed spatio-temporal analysis of how these patterns respond to two-dimensional impulses. This corrigendum addresses a technical error in the mathematical formulation of the free surface curvature used in that model.

The Mathematical Correction

The original publication contained a typographical error in equation (2.4), which defines the non-dimensional curvature ($\kappa$) of the fluid's free surface. In the context of thin-film flows, the curvature term is essential for accurately modeling the Laplace pressure and surface tension effects that influence fluid velocity and, consequently, the rate of mineral deposition. The corrected non-dimensional expression for curvature is:

$$\kappa = \nabla \cdot \left( \frac{\nabla(h + h^0)}{\sqrt{1 + \left(\frac{h_N}{l_c^*}\right)^2 |\nabla(h + h^0)|^2}} \right)$$

In this formulation, $h$ represents the thickness of the flowing water film, while $h^0$ describes the geometry of the underlying rock substrate. The correction specifically addresses the scaling of the gradient terms. It introduces the ratio of the characteristic film thickness ($h_N$) to the capillary length ($l_c^*$), ensuring that the geometric description of the free surface is physically consistent with the non-dimensionalization scheme of the overall model.

Impact on Original Findings

A critical question following such a correction is whether the original scientific conclusions remain valid. The authors have confirmed that the error was "benign" with respect to the paper's primary results. The core of the original research relied on linear stability analysis. In a linear framework, higher-order non-linear terms—such as those found in the full curvature expression—are simplified, meaning the typo did not propagate into the fundamental stability criteria or the predicted growth rates of the draperies.

However, the correction is significant for the reproducibility of the non-linear numerical simulations. To ensure that the results presented in Figures 15, 16, 17, and 21 of the original paper remain accurate, the authors specify that the parameter ratio $h_N/l_c^*$ must be set to 1. This specific value represents a physical regime where the characteristic thickness of the water layer is equal to the length scale at which surface tension effects become dominant, a common assumption in such hydrodynamic models.

Conclusion

This corrigendum serves as an important act of scientific transparency, providing the correct mathematical foundation for future researchers. While the original discussion and conclusions regarding the two-dimensional impulse response of karst draperies remain robust, this correction ensures that subsequent non-linear modeling efforts can proceed from an accurate geometric framework.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{ledda2021hydrodynamic,
  author = {Pier Giuseppe Ledda and Gioele Balestra and Gaétan Lerisson and Benoît Scheid and Matthieu Wyart and François Gallaire},
  title = {{Hydrodynamic-driven morphogenesis of karst draperies: spatio-temporal analysis of the two-dimensional impulse response – CORRIGENDUM}},
  journal = {Journal of Fluid Mechanics},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1017/jfm.2021.700},
}
Figure