Intrinsic processes drive variability in basal melting of the Totten Glacier Ice Shelf

David E. Gwyther, T. Okane, Benjamin K. Galton‐Fenzi, Didier P. Monselesan, Jamin S. GreenbaumNature Communications 2018 · DOI

Abstract

Over the period 2003-2008, the Totten Ice Shelf (TIS) was shown to be rapidly thinning, likely due to basal melting. However, a recent study using a longer time series found high interannual variability present in TIS surface elevation without any apparent trend. Here we show that low-frequency intrinsic ocean variability potentially accounts for a large fraction of the variability in the basal melting of TIS. Specifically, numerical ocean model simulations show that up to 44% of the modelled variability in basal melting in the 1-5 year timescale (and up to 21% in the 5-10 year timescale) is intrinsic, with a similar response to the full climate forcing. We identify the important role of intrinsic ocean variability in setting the observed interannual variation in TIS surface thickness and velocity. Our results further demonstrate the need to account for intrinsic ocean processes in the detection and attribution of change.

The Challenge of Attribution at Totten Glacier

The Totten Glacier Ice Shelf (TIS) is a critical gateway for the East Antarctic Ice Sheet, and its thinning is a major concern for global sea-level rise. However, observational data has been difficult to interpret: while short-term records (2003–2008) showed rapid thinning, longer satellite records (1994–2012) revealed massive fluctuations in thickness with no clear long-term trend.

The central question is how much of this variability is a direct response to external climate "forcing" (such as ENSO or global warming) versus "intrinsic" variability generated by the ocean itself. If the ocean has its own internal "weather" that causes melting to swing wildly, this "noise" must be accounted for before changes can be accurately attributed to human-induced climate change.

Modeling Intrinsic vs. Forced Variability

To isolate intrinsic variability, researchers used the Regional Ocean Modelling System (ROMS) to simulate the ocean environment around the TIS over a 150-year period. They conducted two distinct experiments:

  1. COREv1 (Intrinsic-only): The model was forced with a "normal year" atmospheric cycle repeated annually. Because the atmosphere remains constant year-to-year, any interannual variability in the results is internally generated by non-linear ocean physics.
  2. COREv2 (Full forcing): The model used historical climate data from 1949 to 2007, incorporating both interannual and decadal climate modes.
Figure 1: Comparison of area-averaged melt rates under intrinsic-only (COREv1, blue) and full climate (COREv2, red) forcing. The similarity in magnitude suggests that intrinsic processes are a major driver of variability.

The Driver: Modified Circumpolar Deep Water

Basal melting is tightly coupled to the thickness of the Modified Circumpolar Deep Water (MCDW) layer—a pool of relatively warm water near the seabed. The study found that the melt rate tracks the MCDW thickness with a high correlation (r = 0.87). This relationship demonstrates that the "internal weather" of the ocean manifests as fluctuations in the volume of warm water reaching the ice shelf base.

Figure 2: Physical drivers of melt rate variability. Panel (b) shows ocean temperature with the -1.5°C contour (white line) indicating the MCDW layer thickness. Panel (c) shows the corresponding melt rate, demonstrating the strong coupling between the two.

Key Results

  • Variance Attribution: Intrinsic variability accounts for up to 44% of the modeled melt rate variability on 1–5 year timescales and up to 21% on 5–10 year timescales.
  • Signal-to-Noise Ratio: The ratio of total melt rate variance (COREv2) to intrinsic variance (COREv1) is only 1.7. This low ratio indicates that the "noise" of internal ocean physics is a primary component of what is observed in the field.
  • Timescale Sensitivity: Intrinsic variability is most dominant on shorter (1–5 year) timescales but remains significant even on multidecadal scales (10–30 years), where it explains approximately 24% of the variance.

Implications for Future Research

The findings emphasize that short-term "snapshots" of ice shelf thinning are likely dominated by intrinsic noise, making them poor indicators of long-term climate trends. The researchers conclude that future observational missions must be long-term to distinguish between internal ocean fluctuations and anthropogenic climate change. Furthermore, the steady-state ice shelf assumption used in this model suggests that future work incorporating dynamic ice shelf geometry could reveal even more complex feedback loops.

Summary updated

Abstract

Over the period 2003-2008, the Totten Ice Shelf (TIS) was shown to be rapidly thinning, likely due to basal melting. However, a recent study using a longer time series found high interannual variability present in TIS surface elevation without any apparent trend. Here we show that low-frequency intrinsic ocean variability potentially accounts for a large fraction of the variability in the basal melting of TIS. Specifically, numerical ocean model simulations show that up to 44% of the modelled variability in basal melting in the 1-5 year timescale (and up to 21% in the 5-10 year timescale) is intrinsic, with a similar response to the full climate forcing. We identify the important role of intrinsic ocean variability in setting the observed interannual variation in TIS surface thickness and velocity. Our results further demonstrate the need to account for intrinsic ocean processes in the detection and attribution of change.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gwyther2018intrinsic,
  author = {David E. Gwyther and T. Okane and Benjamin K. Galton‐Fenzi and Didier P. Monselesan and Jamin S. Greenbaum},
  title = {{Intrinsic processes drive variability in basal melting of the Totten Glacier Ice Shelf}},
  booktitle = {Nature Communications},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1038/s41467-018-05618-2},
}
Figure