On the 3-D Placement of Airborne Base Stations Using Tethered UAVs

Mustafa A. Kishk, Ahmed Bader, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

Abstract

One of the main challenges slowing the deployment of airborne base stations (BSs) using unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) is the limited on-board energy and flight time. One potential solution to such problem, is to provide the UAV with power supply through a tether that connects the UAV to the ground. In this paper, we study the optimal placement of tethered UAVs (TUAVs) to minimize the average path-loss between the TUAV and a receiver located on the ground. Given that the tether has a maximum length, and the launching point of the TUAV (the starting point of the tether) is placed on a rooftop, the TUAV is only allowed to hover within a specific hovering region. Beside the maximum tether length, this hovering region also depends on the heights of the buildings surrounding the rooftop, which requires the inclination angle of the tether not to be below a given minimum value, in order to avoid tangling and ensure safety. We first formulate the optimization problem for such setup and provide some useful insights on its solution. Next, we derive upper and lower bounds for the optimal values of the tether length and inclination angle. We also propose a suboptimal closed-form solution for the tether length and its inclination angle that is based on maximizing the line-of-sight probability. Finally, we derive the probability distribution of the minimum inclination angle of the tether length. We show that its mean value varies depending on the environment from 10 degrees in suburban environments to 31 degrees in high rise urban environments. Our numerical results show that the derived upper and lower bounds on the optimal values of the tether length and inclination angle lead to tight suboptimal values of the average path-loss that are only 0-3 dBs above the minimum value.

Introduction

Unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) are promising candidates for "flying base stations," offering flexible and on-demand cellular coverage. However, they face a significant hurdle: the "battery problem." Most commercial drones can only hover for less than an hour before needing a recharge, leading to service gaps and operational complexity.

Tethered UAVs (TUAVs) solve this by connecting the drone to a ground station via a cable that provides continuous power and a high-speed wired backhaul. This allows for persistent operation, as shown by various commercial systems currently on the market.

Comparison of commercial TUAV systems showing tether lengths and extended flight times.

While the tether solves the energy problem, it introduces new spatial constraints. A TUAV cannot fly anywhere; it is restricted by the tether's maximum length and the physical environment. This paper addresses the 3D placement problem: determining the optimal hovering position to minimize signal path-loss while staying within physical and safety boundaries.

Modeling the Hovering Region

The authors define a 3D "hovering region" based on two critical constraints:

  1. Maximum Tether Length ($T_{max}$): The physical limit of the cable.
  2. Minimum Inclination Angle ($\theta_{min}$): A safety constraint ensuring the tether does not hit the edges of the launch building or neighboring structures.

To make the model realistic, the study uses stochastic geometry. Specifically, a Poisson Point Process (PPP) models the locations of surrounding buildings, while a Rayleigh distribution models their heights. This framework allows the derivation of the probability distribution of the minimum safe inclination angle across different environments, ranging from suburban to high-rise urban settings.

Optimization Framework

The core objective is to minimize the average path-loss between the TUAV and a ground receiver. This involves a trade-off between the distance to the user and the probability of maintaining a clear Line-of-Sight (LoS).

Because the global optimum can be complex to compute, the paper provides several analytical tools:

  • Bounds: Upper and lower bounds for the optimal tether length and inclination angle are derived, providing a tight search area for deployment.
  • Suboptimal Closed-Form Solution: The authors propose a simplified solution based on maximizing the LoS probability. This proxy is highly effective, with numerical results showing it performs within 0–3 dB of the absolute mathematical optimum.

Environmental Insights and Results

The research highlights how urban density significantly impacts the available airspace for TUAVs. The mean minimum inclination angle required for safety varies from 10.6° in suburban environments to 30.8° in high-rise urban environments. In dense cities, the risk of tangling is so high that the drone is forced to maintain a much steeper tether angle, significantly shrinking its usable hovering region.

Furthermore, the benefits of tether length are found to be non-linear. Increasing the tether length is highly beneficial when users are close to the launch building (providing up to 10 dB improvement), but the advantage diminishes as users move further away horizontally.

Conclusion and Future Work

This study provides a mathematical foundation for deploying persistent airborne base stations using tethered drones. By accounting for environmental safety and path-loss optimization, the proposed framework enables more reliable aerial network planning. Future work will expand this model to include mobile users, multi-TUAV coordination to avoid tether crossing, and the mechanical realities of tether behavior, such as catenary curves caused by wind and weight.

Summary updated

Abstract

One of the main challenges slowing the deployment of airborne base stations (BSs) using unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) is the limited on-board energy and flight time. One potential solution to such problem, is to provide the UAV with power supply through a tether that connects the UAV to the ground. In this paper, we study the optimal placement of tethered UAVs (TUAVs) to minimize the average path-loss between the TUAV and a receiver located on the ground. Given that the tether has a maximum length, and the launching point of the TUAV (the starting point of the tether) is placed on a rooftop, the TUAV is only allowed to hover within a specific hovering region. Beside the maximum tether length, this hovering region also depends on the heights of the buildings surrounding the rooftop, which requires the inclination angle of the tether not to be below a given minimum value, in order to avoid tangling and ensure safety. We first formulate the optimization problem for such setup and provide some useful insights on its solution. Next, we derive upper and lower bounds for the optimal values of the tether length and inclination angle. We also propose a suboptimal closed-form solution for the tether length and its inclination angle that is based on maximizing the line-of-sight probability. Finally, we derive the probability distribution of the minimum inclination angle of the tether length. We show that its mean value varies depending on the environment from 10 degrees in suburban environments to 31 degrees in high rise urban environments. Our numerical results show that the derived upper and lower bounds on the optimal values of the tether length and inclination angle lead to tight suboptimal values of the average path-loss that are only 0-3 dBs above the minimum value.
BibTeX
@article{kishk2020d,
  author = {Mustafa A. Kishk and Ahmed Bader and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the 3-D Placement of Airborne Base Stations Using Tethered UAVs}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ryljaOUv78Z},
}
Figure