On the 3-D Placement of Airborne Base Stations Using Tethered UAVs

Mustafa A. Kishk, Ahmed Bader, Mohamed-Slim Alouini

TL;DR

This paper provides the first mathematical framework for the optimal 3-D placement of tethered UAVs (TUAVs) acting as airborne base stations. By accounting for physical constraints like tether length and safety angles to avoid building tangling, the authors derive a suboptimal closed-form solution that achieves performance within 0–3 dB of the theoretical optimum.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

While Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are promising as "flying base stations" for 5G and beyond, they face a major hurdle: battery life. Most untethered drones can only hover for about an hour before needing a recharge, creating coverage gaps.

Tethered UAVs (TUAVs) solve this by connecting to a ground station via a cable that provides continuous power and high-speed data. however, the tether introduces new physical constraints. You can't just fly anywhere; you are limited by the cable's length and the risk of the tether snagging on surrounding buildings. This paper tackles the challenge of finding the "sweet spot" in 3-D space to minimize signal path-loss while respecting these tether-specific boundaries.

Methods

The authors approach the problem through three main lenses:

  1. Geometric Modeling: They define a "hovering region"—essentially a slice of a hemisphere centered on a rooftop—where the TUAV can safely operate. This region is constrained by the maximum tether length ($T_{max}$) and a minimum inclination angle ($\theta_{min}$) required to clear nearby obstacles.
  2. Optimization Theory: They formulate an optimization problem to minimize average path-loss (PL) at a ground receiver. Since the exact solution is complex, they derive upper and lower bounds for the optimal tether length and inclination angle.
  3. Stochastic Geometry: To make the model realistic, they use a Poisson Point Process (PPP) to model building locations and Rayleigh distributions for building heights. This allows them to calculate the probability distribution of the minimum safe inclination angle ($\theta_{min}$) across different environments (suburban vs. high-rise urban).

Datasets

The paper does not use a specific external dataset but relies on standardized environmental parameters for building density ($\beta$) and mean height ($\gamma$) established in previous landmark studies (e.g., Al-Hourani et al.). They simulate four distinct scenarios:

  • Suburban
  • Urban
  • Dense Urban
  • High-Rise Urban

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Boundary is Key: The authors prove that the optimal location for a TUAV almost always lies on the boundary of its allowed hovering region.
  • LoS vs. Distance Trade-off: Minimizing path-loss is a tug-of-war between getting closer to the user (shorter distance) and going higher to ensure a clear Line-of-Sight (LoS).
  • The "Safety Angle" varies wildly: Using stochastic geometry, they found that the average minimum inclination angle needed to avoid tangling is only 10.6° in suburban areas but jumps to 30.8° in high-rise urban environments.
  • Suboptimal can be "Good Enough": They proposed a closed-form suboptimal solution based purely on maximizing LoS probability. This is much easier to calculate than the full path-loss optimization but yields nearly identical results.

Key Results

  • Tight Bounds: The derived upper and lower bounds for optimal placement lead to path-loss values that are very close to the absolute minimum.
  • Performance Gap: The proposed suboptimal closed-form solution is remarkably efficient, staying within 0–3 dB of the optimal average path-loss.
  • Tether Length Gains: Increasing the maximum tether length can reduce path-loss by up to 10 dB when users are close to the building, though these gains diminish as the user moves further away.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several areas for expansion:

  • Single Receiver Focus: The current model optimizes placement for one specific receiver. Real-world applications would need to consider a distribution of many users (hotspots).
  • Static Placement: The study focuses on a fixed hovering location. Future work could explore optimal 3-D trajectories for TUAVs to follow moving users while tethered.
  • Environment Assumptions: The building height model assumes a Rayleigh distribution; different architectural styles might require more complex modeling.
  • Tether Mechanics: The paper treats the tether as a straight line, but real-world factors like tether weight, wind, and tension control could affect the actual reachable hovering region.

Summary updated

Abstract

One of the main challenges slowing the deployment of airborne base stations (BSs) using unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) is the limited on-board energy and flight time. One potential solution to such problem, is to provide the UAV with power supply through a tether that connects the UAV to the ground. In this paper, we study the optimal placement of tethered UAVs (TUAVs) to minimize the average path-loss between the TUAV and a receiver located on the ground. Given that the tether has a maximum length, and the launching point of the TUAV (the starting point of the tether) is placed on a rooftop, the TUAV is only allowed to hover within a specific hovering region. Beside the maximum tether length, this hovering region also depends on the heights of the buildings surrounding the rooftop, which requires the inclination angle of the tether not to be below a given minimum value, in order to avoid tangling and ensure safety. We first formulate the optimization problem for such setup and provide some useful insights on its solution. Next, we derive upper and lower bounds for the optimal values of the tether length and inclination angle. We also propose a suboptimal closed-form solution for the tether length and its inclination angle that is based on maximizing the line-of-sight probability. Finally, we derive the probability distribution of the minimum inclination angle of the tether length. We show that its mean value varies depending on the environment from 10° in suburban environments to 31° in high rise urban environments. Our numerical results show that the derived upper and lower bounds on the optimal values of the tether length and inclination angle lead to tight suboptimal values of the average path-loss that are only 0 - 3 dBs above the minimum value.
BibTeX
@article{kishk2020d,
  author = {Mustafa A. Kishk and Ahmed Bader and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the 3-D Placement of Airborne Base Stations Using Tethered UAVs}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Communications},
  year = {2020},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ryljaOUv78Z},
}

Loading related content...

Figure