On secrecy rates and outage in multi-user multi-eavesdroppers MISO systems

Joseph Kampeas, Asaf Cohen, Omer Gurewitz

Wireless communication is inherently vulnerable to interception because signals propagate in all directions. Physical-Layer Security (PLS) leverages the random nature of wireless channels to ensure that an eavesdropper’s channel is mathematically inferior to that of a legitimate user. In a Multiple-Input-Single-Output (MISO) system, a transmitter can beamform its signal toward a specific user to boost signal strength. However, without exact knowledge of eavesdropper locations, a secrecy outage can occur if an eavesdropper unexpectedly has a better channel than the intended recipient.

This research provides a rigorous asymptotic analysis of secrecy in networks where a multi-antenna transmitter serves many legitimate users ($K$) while being monitored by multiple eavesdroppers ($M$). The study addresses how opportunistic scheduling—choosing the "best" user—can counter the threat posed by the "best" eavesdropper.

Methodology: Extreme Value Theory and Tractable Bounds

The researchers modeled the system as a Gaussian wiretap channel, assuming full Channel State Information (CSI) for legitimate users but only statistical knowledge for eavesdroppers. Their mathematical approach relies on Extreme Value Theory (EVT), using the Gumbel distribution to characterize maximum channel gains.

Because the ratio of two Gumbel-distributed variables lacks a simple closed-form expression, the authors derived an exact expression using an infinite sum of Gamma functions. To provide practical tools for engineers, they developed tight upper and lower bounds for the secrecy outage probability.

Figure 1: Comparison of the exact secrecy outage probability approximation with the derived upper and lower bounds, demonstrating the tightness of the analytical framework.

Key Insights and Scaling Laws

The analysis reveals that secrecy in this model is essentially a race between the best legitimate channel (scaling with $\log K$) and the best eavesdropper channel (scaling with $\log M$). The number of transmit antennas ($t$) provides a significant advantage to legitimate users through beamforming gains.

A primary contribution of this work is the derivation of a specific scaling law: to maintain a low risk of secrecy outage as the number of eavesdroppers ($M$) grows, the number of legitimate users ($K$) must grow at a rate of:

$$K = \Omega(M (\log M)^{t-1})$$

This result suggests that user diversity alone can be a powerful security asset, potentially removing the need for techniques like "Artificial Noise" (jamming) in large-scale networks.

Figure 3: Secrecy outage probability $P(R_s \leq 1 \text{ bit})$ as a function of the number of eavesdroppers $M$, illustrating how the outage risk increases as the eavesdropper population grows.

Numerical simulations (as seen in Figures 1 and 3) validate that the proposed theoretical bounds are remarkably accurate, especially as the number of users and eavesdroppers increases beyond 30.

Limitations and Future Outlook

While providing a strong theoretical foundation, the study assumes independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) fading and non-colluding eavesdroppers. In real-world urban environments, channel correlation or eavesdropper cooperation could significantly impact these scaling laws. Future work is needed to explore these complexities, as well as the effects of user mobility in time-varying channels.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, we study the secrecy rate and outage probability in Multiple-Input-Single-Output (MISO) Gaussian wiretap channels at the limit of a large number of legitimate users and eavesdroppers. In particular, we analyze the asymptotic achievable secrecy rates and outage, when only statistical knowledge on the wiretap channels is available to the transmitter. The analysis provides exact expressions for the reduction in the secrecy rate as the number of eavesdroppers grows, compared to the boost in the secrecy rate as the number of legitimate users grows.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{kampeas2016secrecy,
  author = {Joseph Kampeas and Asaf Cohen and Omer Gurewitz},
  title = {{On secrecy rates and outage in multi-user multi-eavesdroppers MISO systems}},
  booktitle = {ISIT},
  year = {2016},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Ct0tBnHjYsI},
}
Figure