On the Secrecy Performance of Generalized User Selection for Interference-Limited Multiuser Wireless Networks

Yazan H. Al-Badarneh, Costas N. Georghiades, Redha M. Radaydeh, Mohamed-Slim AlouiniIEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology 2018 · DOI · OpenReview

Abstract

We investigate the secrecy performance of a multiuser diversity scheme for an interference-limited wireless network with a base station (BS), N legitimate users, and an eavesdropper in the presence of a single dominant interferer. Assuming interference dominates noise power at the eavesdropper and at each legitimate user's receiver, the BS transmits information to the legitimate user with the kth best (highest) signal-to-interference ratio. We derive a closed-form expression for the secrecy outage probability for an arbitrary N and an asymptotic expression for a fixed k and large N. Furthermore, we derive a closed-form asymptotic expression for the ergodic secrecy capacity of the kth best user and show that it scales like O(log(N)) for a fixed k and large N.

Introduction

In modern wireless communications, multiuser diversity is a powerful technique to enhance system performance by scheduling transmissions to users with the most favorable channel conditions. However, practical constraints such as scheduling delays or user availability often necessitate selecting a sub-optimal user—the "k-th best" rather than the absolute best. Simultaneously, the proliferation of wireless devices has shifted the bottleneck from thermal noise to co-channel interference. This paper explores the physical layer (PHY) security implications of such generalized user selection in interference-limited environments.

System Model and Methodology

The study considers a wireless network consisting of a single-antenna base station (Alice), $N$ single-antenna legitimate users (Bobs), and an eavesdropper (Eve) equipped with $L$ antennas. A critical feature of this model is the presence of a dominant interfering base station that affects both the legitimate users and the eavesdropper.

System model of an interference-limited multiuser network with a multi-antenna eavesdropper.

The researchers employed a rigorous analytical approach:

  • Channel Modeling: All links are assumed to undergo independent and identically distributed (i.i.d.) Rayleigh fading.
  • User Selection: The system selects the $k$-th best user based on the Signal-to-Interference Ratio (SIR).
  • Performance Metrics: The primary metrics are the Secrecy Outage Probability (SOP) and the Ergodic Secrecy Capacity (ESC).
  • Mathematical Derivation: Using order statistics and complex functions like the Gauss hypergeometric function, the authors derived exact closed-form expressions for these metrics, which were subsequently validated through Monte Carlo simulations.

Key Insights and Results

The analysis reveals several fundamental properties of secure multiuser networks:

1. The Logarithmic Scaling Law A pivotal finding is that the Ergodic Secrecy Capacity (ESC) scales as $O(\log(N))$ for a fixed $k$ as the number of users $N$ grows large. This indicates that increasing the user pool consistently improves secrecy performance, even when the optimal user is not selected.

Ergodic Secrecy Capacity (ESC) as a function of the number of users (N) for different user selection indices (k).

2. Interference as a Performance Limiter In interference-limited regimes, the transmit power of the base station eventually cancels out in the SIR equations. Consequently, secrecy performance is determined by the relative fading statistics of the legitimate and interfering channels rather than absolute power levels.

3. Impact of Eavesdropper Capabilities The study quantifies the trade-off between multiuser diversity and eavesdropper diversity. If the eavesdropper increases her antenna count ($L$) at the same rate the network adds users ($N$), the security gains from multiuser diversity are effectively neutralized.

4. Generalized Selection Accuracy The derived asymptotic formulas for large $N$ provide highly accurate approximations of the exact SOP and ESC. The "gap" in secrecy performance between the best user ($k=1$) and the $k$-th best user is shown to converge to a constant value related to the harmonic number $H_{k-1}$.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a robust framework for evaluating secrecy in realistic, interference-heavy multiuser environments. It demonstrates that multiuser diversity remains a viable strategy for enhancing physical layer security even under sub-optimal scheduling.

Future research directions include extending this model to Multiple-Input Multiple-Output (MIMO) systems where both the BS and users possess multiple antennas, and exploring more complex interference scenarios typical of ultra-dense 5G/6G networks using stochastic geometry. Additionally, addressing scenarios with imperfect or unavailable channel state information (CSI) for the eavesdropper remains a significant practical challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

We investigate the secrecy performance of a multiuser diversity scheme for an interference-limited wireless network with a base-station (BS), $N$ legitimate users and an eavesdropper, in the presence of a single dominant interferer. Assuming interference dominates noise power at the eavesdropper and at each legitimate user's receiver, the BS transmits information to the legitimate user with the $k$-th best (highest) signal-to-interference ratio. We derive a closed-form expression for the secrecy outage probability for an arbitrary $N$ and an asymptotic expression for a fixed $k$ and large $N$. Furthermore, we derive a closed form asymptotic expression for the ergodic secrecy capacity of the $k$-th best user and show that it scales like $O\left(\log(N)\right)$ for a fixed $k$ and large $N$.
BibTeX
@article{albadarneh2018secrecy,
  author = {Yazan H. Al-Badarneh and Costas N. Georghiades and Redha M. Radaydeh and Mohamed-Slim Alouini},
  title = {{On the Secrecy Performance of Generalized User Selection for Interference-Limited Multiuser Wireless Networks}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Vehicular Technology},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.1109/tvt.2018.2878050},
}
Figure