On Reusing Pilots Among Interfering Cells in Massive MIMO

Jy-yong Sohn, Sung Whan Yoon, Jaekyun Moon

Abstract

Pilot contamination, caused by the reuse of pilots among interfering cells, remains as a significant obstacle that limits the performance of massive multi-input multi-output antenna systems. To handle this problem, less aggressive reuse of pilots involving allocation of additional pilots for interfering users is closely examined in this paper. Hierarchical pilot reuse methods are proposed, which effectively mitigate pilot contamination and increase the net throughput of the system. Among the suggested hierarchical pilot reuse schemes, the optimal way of assigning pilots to different users is obtained in a closed-form solution which maximizes the net sum-rate in a given coherence time. Simulation results confirm that when the ratio of the channel coherence time to the number of users in each cell is sufficiently large, less aggressive reuse of pilots yields significant performance advantage relative to the case where all cells reuse the same pilot set.

Introduction

In Massive MIMO systems, base stations (BSs) utilize large antenna arrays to serve multiple users simultaneously. Accurate channel state information (CSI) is crucial for this operation, typically obtained via training signals known as pilots. However, the limited coherence interval—the time during which the channel remains stable—restricts the number of available orthogonal pilots.

Standard practice often involves "full pilot reuse," where every cell utilizes the same set of pilots. This leads to pilot contamination: when a BS estimates its user's channel, it inadvertently captures interference from users in neighboring cells using identical pilots. This interference creates a performance ceiling that persists even as the number of antennas increases. This paper explores hierarchical pilot reuse strategies to break this ceiling.

Hierarchical Pilot Reuse Methodology

The authors propose a Hierarchical Pilot Reuse scheme to balance pilot overhead and interference mitigation. The approach involves:

  1. Cell Partitioning: Cells are grouped using a 3-way hierarchical partitioning method, similar to traditional frequency reuse patterns.
  2. Pilot Assignment Vector (p): A vector defines the distribution of users across different hierarchy depths. Users at greater depths are more geographically separated from others sharing the same pilot, thereby reducing contamination.
  3. Optimization: The researchers derived a closed-form solution for the optimal pilot assignment vector to maximize the net sum-rate, accounting for the tradeoff between training duration and data transmission time.
Hierarchical set partitioning and the corresponding tree structure.

Results and Performance Analysis

The proposed optimal assignment strategy was evaluated using Monte Carlo simulations in a hexagonal grid environment. Key findings include:

  • Significant Throughput Gains: In urban outdoor scenarios, the optimal assignment provides a 121% to 300% increase in net sum-rate compared to conventional full pilot reuse. Even with a practical number of antennas (e.g., 128), the strategy yields a 40% improvement.
  • Breaking the Asymptotic Ceiling: While pilot contamination remains a factor as the number of antennas goes to infinity, the hierarchical strategy significantly raises the performance ceiling.
  • Optimal Training Fraction: The study reveals that as the coherence interval grows, the optimal strategy maintains a non-vanishing fraction of time for training to ensure a high Signal-to-Interference Ratio (SIR).
Comparison of net sum rate for optimal assignment vs. full pilot reuse.

Conclusion

This research demonstrates that moving away from aggressive full pilot reuse in favor of a hierarchical approach can significantly enhance Massive MIMO performance. By optimizing the pilot assignment vector, network throughput is substantially increased, particularly for cell-edge users who suffer most from contamination. Future work may incorporate power control and irregular cell deployments to further refine these strategies for real-world ultra-dense networks.

Reference: Sohn, J., Yoon, S. W., & Moon, J. (2017). On Reusing Pilots Among Interfering Cells in Massive MIMO. IEEE Transactions on Wireless Communications.

Summary updated

Abstract

Pilot contamination, caused by the reuse of pilots among interfering cells, remains as a significant obstacle that limits the performance of massive multi-input multi-output antenna systems. To handle this problem, less aggressive reuse of pilots involving allocation of additional pilots for interfering users is closely examined in this paper. Hierarchical pilot reuse methods are proposed, which effectively mitigate pilot contamination and increase the net throughput of the system. Among the suggested hierarchical pilot reuse schemes, the optimal way of assigning pilots to different users is obtained in a closed-form solution which maximizes the net sum-rate in a given coherence time. Simulation results confirm that when the ratio of the channel coherence time to the number of users in each cell is sufficiently large, less aggressive reuse of pilots yields significant performance advantage relative to the case where all cells reuse the same pilot set.
BibTeX
@article{sohn2017reusing,
  author = {Jy-yong Sohn and Sung Whan Yoon and Jaekyun Moon},
  title = {{On Reusing Pilots Among Interfering Cells in Massive MIMO}},
  journal = {IEEE Trans. Wireless Communications},
  year = {2017},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=7UAsQV3IyvB},
}
Figure