On radial migration of dense regions and objects and local unstability of accreting systems

Tobias HartungarXiv 2009 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

I have used a newtonian infinite body problem to model a protoplanitary-like hot accretion disk and added terms of laminar and Stokes friction. Then I used qualitative methods to show the unstability of local regions leading to a lemma of radial migration and local unstability in hot, proto-planetary-like accretion disks. Then I considered a general infinite body problem with a position dependent, gravitation-like force and a general perturbating term.

Introduction

In the study of astrophysical accretion disks—ranging from the protoplanitary environments where planets form to the massive disks of stars within galaxies—a persistent observation is that celestial bodies rarely remain at their birth radii. This phenomenon, known as radial migration, is well-documented in numerical simulations and observational data. For instance, Roškar et al. (2008) highlighted significant stellar mixing in galactic disks, suggesting that a star's current position is a poor proxy for its chemical or gravitational origin.

While the "what" of radial migration is clear, the mathematical "why" often remains obscured by the complexity of large-scale numerical simulations. This research provides a rigorous qualitative framework to explain this phenomenon, demonstrating that local regions within "hot" accretion disks are inherently unstable. By applying Lyapunov stability theory to a Newtonian model, we show that radial migration is not merely a possibility but an inevitable physical consequence of the system's dynamics.

Mathematical Framework

The study models the accretion disk as a Newtonian infinite body problem. This approach treats the disk as a continuous background of particles, providing a medium through which a single dense "object" or region moves.

Lagrangian Mechanics and Equations of Motion

The analysis begins with a Lagrangian ($\mathcal{L}$) describing the energy state of a dense region relative to the disk's barycenter. To reflect the physical realities of these disks, the model incorporates two distinct types of dissipative forces:

  1. Laminar Friction: A force linear with respect to velocity.
  2. Stokes Friction: A force quadratic with respect to velocity.

These terms are critical as they define the boundaries of the system's stability. While friction is typically viewed as a stabilizing or dampening force, in this context, it helps define the highly restrictive regions ($\Omega$) where stability might theoretically exist. The research shows these regions are often too small to contain the natural motion of dense objects.

Qualitative Stability Analysis

The core of the proof rests on Lyapunov stability theory. To determine the stability of a local region, we construct piecewise exponential Lyapunov functions ($V$). In the context of dynamical systems, a system is considered stable if a function $V$ can be found such that its time derivative ($\dot{V}$) remains non-positive ($\leq 0$) within a specific neighborhood.

The research demonstrates that for "hot" accretion disks, it is mathematically impossible to maintain $\dot{V} \leq 0$ across the entire local region. The interplay between the central gravitational force, the collective gravity of the disk, and the dissipative friction terms creates a scenario where any local equilibrium is transient.

Scale-Dependent Instability

The analysis introduces a resolution scale ($R$). It is proven that for any local region, there exists a critical radius beyond which the system cannot maintain stability. This suggests that instability is not just a global feature but is baked into the local geometry of the disk.

Results: Migration and Mixing

The mathematical findings are summarized in two primary results:

Lemma 1 (Radial Migration): This lemma establishes the formal conditions under which a dense object will undergo radial migration. It relates the effective gravitational constants ($\alpha_1, \alpha_2$) and the dissipative parameter ($\kappa$) to show that trajectories are mathematically forced out of their local neighborhoods.

Theorem 1 (The Mixing Result): Building on the lemma, this theorem states that dense regions in accreting systems are inherently unstable. Because these objects are forced to leave their local neighborhoods in finite time, they must travel across the disk. This leads to "high mixture" environments where objects found in close proximity today likely originated from vastly different radial distances.

Generalization to 3D Systems

To ensure the findings were not an artifact of simplified 2D geometry, the model was extended to a 3D generalized system. This generalization considers arbitrary "gravitation-like" forces and general perturbing terms. The results remained consistent: the structural instability of the system persists, confirming that radial migration is a fundamental property of accreting Newtonian systems regardless of the specific dimensionality or force-law nuances.

Conclusion and Implications

This research provides a structural mathematical proof for the radial migration observed in astrophysics. By showing that local stability is impossible to maintain in the presence of standard gravitational and frictional forces, the study validates the "mixing" observed in galactic and protoplanitary disks.

While the model is qualitative—proving that migration occurs rather than predicting specific timescales for individual planets—it offers a robust theoretical foundation. Future work may integrate these findings with magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) turbulence models to further refine our understanding of the chemical evolution of galaxies, where the position of a star is often used as a proxy for its age and composition.

Summary updated

Abstract

I have used a newtonian infinite body problem to model a protoplanitary-like hot accretion disk and added terms of laminar and Stokes friction. Then I used qualitative methods to show the unstability of local regions leading to a lemma of radial migration and local unstability in hot, proto-planetary-like accretion disks. Then I considered a general infinite body problem with a position dependent, gravitation-like force and a general perturbating term.
BibTeX
@misc{hartung2009radial,
  author = {Tobias Hartung},
  title = {{On radial migration of dense regions and objects and local unstability of accreting systems}},
  year = {2009},
  eprint = {0906.3859},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/0906.3859},
  howpublished = {arXiv},
}
Figure