Is the Spiral Galaxy a Cosmic Hurricane?

Zexin Cao, Ling Liu, Tingting ZhengarXiv 2018 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract: It is discussed that the formation of the spiral galaxies is driven by the cosmic background rotation, not a result of an isolated evolution proposed by the density wave theory. To analyze the motions of the galaxies, a simple double particle galaxy model is considered and the Coriolis force formed by the rotational background is introduced. The numerical analysis shows that not only the trajectory of the particle is the spiral shape, but also the relationship between the velocity and the radius reveals both the existence of spiral arm and the change of the arm number. In addition, the results of the three-dimensional simulation also give the warped structure of the spiral galaxies, and shows that the disc surface of the warped galaxy, like a spinning coins on the table, exists a whole overturning movement. Through the analysis, it can be concluded that the background environment of the spiral galaxies have a large-scale rotation, and both the formation and evolution of hurricane-like spiral galaxies are driven by this background rotation.

Introduction: Challenging the Density Wave Theory

For decades, the "Density Wave Theory" has been the standard explanation for the beautiful spiral structures we see in the cosmos. It suggests that stars move in elliptical orbits and "crowd together" in certain areas to form arms, much like a traffic jam. However, this theory struggles to explain "flocculent" galaxies (which have patchy, indistinct arms), galaxies with many arms, or the ubiquitous "warped" S-shape seen in many galactic discs.

The spiral galaxy NGC 6814, a prime example of the complex structures standard theories struggle to fully explain.

Furthermore, standard models require massive amounts of dark matter to explain why the outer edges of galaxies rotate so quickly. The authors of this paper ask: What if we are looking at the problem from the wrong frame of reference? By treating the galaxy as a system embedded in a rotating cosmic background, they attempt to solve these structural mysteries using classical mechanics.

Methods: The Viscous Two-Body Model

The researchers moved away from complex N-body simulations to focus on a "viscous two-body problem" in a non-inertial system. They modeled a galaxy using two particles and subjected them to three primary forces:

  1. Gravitational Force ($F_g$): The standard mutual attraction between the masses.
  2. Viscous Force ($F_v$): A drag force proportional to velocity, representing the interactions and "friction" within the galactic medium.
  3. Coriolis Force ($F_c$): The "hidden" force that appears because the entire background environment is rotating.

By numerically solving the dynamical equations for this system, they simulated particle trajectories in both 2D and 3D to see if they could replicate observed galactic shapes.

Key Insights

  • The Trajectory is the Spiral: In traditional theory, individual stars move in ellipses. In this model, the actual path of a single particle is a spiral. This explains why even "flocculent" galaxies without clear density waves still look like spirals.
  • The "Turning-Back" Mechanism: The relationship between a particle's velocity and its radius shows "turning-back" points. At these points, particles aggregate, naturally creating the high-density regions we recognize as spiral arms.
  • Origin of the Thin Disc: The authors show that particles lose energy faster in the direction parallel to the background rotation axis. This causes them to accumulate into a thin plane relatively quickly.
  • Warps as Coriolis Effects: If the background rotation isn't perfectly aligned with the galaxy's disc, a "leaving-plane" component of the Coriolis force is generated. This naturally creates the warped, S-shaped structure seen in many galaxies (like the Milky Way) without needing to invoke dark matter halos.

Key Results

The simulations produced striking visual matches to real astronomical and meteorological phenomena. When viscosity is set to zero, the particles follow a petal-like path. However, with a small amount of viscosity ($\eta = 0.06$), the trajectory settles into a stable spiral that fits a logarithmic function ($r = 2.015e^{0.531\theta}$), which is the mathematical hallmark of spiral galaxies.

Numerical simulations showing the transition from petal-like trajectories (top) to stable spiral structures (bottom) as viscosity is introduced.

Crucially, the model suggests that the high tangential velocities observed in galaxies—usually attributed to dark matter—could instead be a result of the Coriolis force from the rotating cosmic background.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the extreme simplicity of the model. A two-particle system is a far cry from a galaxy containing billions of stars and vast clouds of gas. The authors acknowledge that their findings need to be verified through more complex N-body or hydrodynamic simulations.

Additionally, the "cosmic background rotation" is a bold cosmological assumption that requires more direct observational evidence to be widely accepted. The viscosity coefficient ($\eta$) is also treated as a free parameter; future work would need to derive this from the physical properties of the interstellar medium.

Summary updated

Abstract

It is discussed that the formation of the spiral galaxies is driven by the cosmic background rotation, not a result of an isolated evolution proposed by the density wave theory. To analyze the motions of the galaxies, a simple double particle galaxy model is considered and the Coriolis force formed by the rotational background is introduced. The numerical analysis shows that not only the trajectory of the particle is the spiral shape, but also the relationship between the velocity and the radius reveals both the existence of spiral arm and the change of the arm number. In addition, the results of the three-dimensional simulation also give the warped structure of the spiral galaxies, and shows that the disc surface of the warped galaxy, like a spinning coins on the table, exists a whole overturning movement. Through the analysis, it can be concluded that the background environment of the spiral galaxies have a large-scale rotation, and both the formation and evolution of hurricane-like spiral galaxies are driven by this background rotation.
BibTeX
@misc{cao2018is,
  author = {Zexin Cao and Ling Liu and Tingting Zheng},
  title = {{Is the Spiral Galaxy a Cosmic Hurricane?}},
  year = {2018},
  eprint = {1802.02734},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1802.02734},
}
Figure