The Intrinsic Flattening of Galaxy Disks

Jeremy Favaro, Stéphane Courteau, S. Comerón, Connor Stone

Abstract: Highly inclined (edge-on) disk galaxies offer the unique perspective to constrain their intrinsic flattening, $c/a$, where $c$ and $a$ are respectively the vertical and long radial axes of the disk measured at suitable stellar densities. The ratio $c/a$ is a necessary quantity in the assessment of galaxy inclinations, three-dimensional structural reconstructions, total masses, as well as a constraint to galaxy formation models. 3.6 micron maps of 133 edge-on spiral galaxies from the Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies (S4G) and its early-type galaxy extension are used to revisit the assessment of $c/a$ free from dust extinction and away from the influence of a stellar bulge. We present a simple definition of $c/a$ and explore trends with other galactic physical parameters: total stellar mass, concentration index, total HI mass, mass of the central mass concentration, circular velocity, model-dependent scales, as well as Hubble type. Other than a dependence on early/late Hubble types, and a related trend with light concentration, no other parameters were found to correlate with the intrinsic flattening of spiral galaxies. The latter is mostly constant with $\langle c/a \rangle$ = 0.124 $\pm$ 0.001 (stat) $\pm$ 0.033 (intrinsic/systematic) and greater for earlier types.

Introduction

Determining the three-dimensional structure of galaxies is a fundamental challenge in extragalactic astronomy. A key parameter is the inclination—the angle at which we observe a galaxy. However, calculating inclination requires an accurate estimate of a galaxy's "intrinsic flattening" ($c/a$), the ratio of its vertical thickness to its radial extent. Historically, these measurements have been hindered by interstellar dust, which obscures the midplane in visible light, and a heavy reliance on model-dependent light profile fitting.

Data and Methodology

This study utilizes near-infrared (3.6 µm) data from the Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies ($S^4G$). At this wavelength, dust extinction is minimal, allowing for a clearer view of the underlying stellar distribution. The sample consists of 133 edge-on galaxies, spanning both spiral and lenticular (S0) types.

To avoid the biases of traditional global model fitting, the authors developed the Method of Characteristic Cuts. Using isophotal mapping, they measured the $c/a$ ratio at specific radial intervals:

  • Inner Cut: 20% to 50% of the galaxy's radius ($r_{25}$).
  • Outer Cut: 50% to 80% of the galaxy's radius.

This approach isolates the disk from the central bulge and the potential "flaring" at the disk's outer edges, providing a more robust measure of the true disk thickness.

The intrinsic flattening (c/a) as a function of normalized radius (a/r25). The shaded regions represent the 'inner' (cyan) and 'outer' (red) cuts used to define the characteristic disk thickness.

Results and Physical Correlations

The analysis reveals a remarkably consistent flattening for spiral galaxies. The mean intrinsic flattening was determined to be $0.124 \pm 0.001$ (stat) $\pm$ 0.033 (sys).

A significant finding is the lack of correlation between disk thickness and most other physical properties. The authors tested for dependencies on total stellar mass, HI gas mass, and circular velocity ($V_{rot}$). As shown in the sample distributions below, while these parameters vary widely across the survey, they do not significantly influence the intrinsic flattening of spiral disks.

Distribution of physical parameters for the study sample compared to the parent S4G survey, illustrating the diversity of galaxies tested for correlations with intrinsic flattening.

However, morphology does play a role. Lenticular galaxies (S0s) were found to be significantly thicker on average ($\langle c/a \rangle \approx 0.20$) and exhibited greater variation than spirals. This suggests that the evolutionary processes forming S0 galaxies—such as mergers or tidal interactions—likely "puff up" their stellar disks compared to the more quiescently evolving spirals.

Conclusion

By moving to a non-parametric, infrared-based measurement, this work establishes a new benchmark for galaxy disk thickness. The "universal" flatness of spiral galaxies ($c/a \approx 0.124$) provides a simplified yet more accurate tool for calculating galaxy inclinations and serves as a critical constraint for future numerical simulations of galaxy formation. Future work will aim to expand the sample size, particularly for early-type galaxies, to further refine these morphological trends.

Summary updated

Abstract

Highly inclined (edge-on) disk galaxies offer the unique perspective to constrain their intrinsic flattening, $c/a$, where $c$ and $a$ are respectively the vertical and long radial axes of the disk measured at suitable stellar densities. The ratio $c/a$ is a necessary quantity in the assessment of galaxy inclinations, three-dimensional structural reconstructions, total masses, as well as a constraint to galaxy formation models. 3.6 micron maps of 133 edge-on spiral galaxies from the Spitzer Survey of Stellar Structure in Galaxies (S4G) and its early-type galaxy extension are used to revisit the assessment of $c/a$ free from dust extinction and away from the influence of a stellar bulge. We present a simple definition of $c/a$ and explore trends with other galactic physical parameters: total stellar mass, concentration index, total HI mass, mass of the central mass concentration, circular velocity, model-dependent scales, as well as Hubble type. Other than a dependence on early/late Hubble types, and a related trend with light concentration, no other parameters were found to correlate with the intrinsic flattening of spiral galaxies. The latter is mostly constant with $\langle c/a \rangle$ = 0.124 $\pm$ 0.001 (stat) $\pm$ 0.033 (intrinsic/systematic) and greater for earlier types.
BibTeX
@article{favaro2024intrinsic,
  author = {Jeremy Favaro and Stéphane Courteau and S. Comerón and Connor Stone},
  title = {{The Intrinsic Flattening of Galaxy Disks}},
  journal = {The Astrophysical Journal},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3847/1538-4357/ad932e},
}
Figure