Abstract
With the calculated guiding center radius $R_{guiding}$ and birth radius $R_{birth}$, we investigate the role of radial migration on the description of lithium evolution in the Galactic disk based on the upper envelope of the A(Li) vs. [Fe/H] diagram. Using migration distances, we find that stars in the solar neighborhood are born at different locations in the galactic disk, and cannot all be explained by models of chemical evolution in the solar neighborhood. It is found that the upper envelope of the A(Li) vs. [Fe/H] diagram varies significantly with $R_{birth}$, which explains the decrease of Li for super-metal-rich (SMR) stars because they are non-young stars born in the inner disk. The upper envelope of Li-$R_{birth}$ plane fits very well with chemical evolution models by Grisoni et al. for $R_{birth} = 7 - 12$ kpc. For stars born in the solar neighborhood, the young open clusters and the upper envelope of field stars with age < 3 Gyr fit well with theoretical prediction. We find that calculations using stars with ages less than 3 Gyr are necessary to obtain an undepleted Li upper envelope, and that stars with solar age (around 4.5 Gyr) have depleted around 0.3 dex from the original value.
Introduction: The Lithium Mystery
Lithium is a fickle element. While most metals build up in the Galaxy over time, lithium is easily destroyed inside stars through "burning" at relatively low temperatures. Astronomers use the "upper envelope" of lithium abundance—the maximum amount of lithium seen at a given metallicity ([Fe/H])—to trace how the Galaxy’s gas has been enriched over billions of years.
However, recent large-scale surveys revealed a puzzling trend: as stars become "super-metal-rich" (SMR), their maximum lithium levels actually start to drop. This contradicts standard chemical evolution models, which predict lithium should continue to rise alongside iron. The debate has been split: is our understanding of lithium production wrong, or are we simply looking at the wrong stars?
Methodology: Tracing Stars to Their Birthplaces
The researchers investigated whether radial migration—the process where stars drift away from their original birth orbits—is responsible for this discrepancy.
- Orbits and Birthplaces: Using kinematic data, they calculated the "guiding center radius" ($R_{guiding}$) for thousands of stars. More importantly, they estimated the "birth radius" ($R_{birth}$) by comparing a star's age and metallicity to known models of the Interstellar Medium (ISM) enrichment history.
- Upper Envelope Analysis: Instead of just looking at stars currently near the Sun, they binned stars by their calculated $R_{birth}$.
- Model Comparison: They compared these birth-radius-corrected observations against Galactic Chemical Evolution (GCE) models (specifically those by Grisoni et al.), testing both "fiducial" and "alternative" models that vary in how they account for lithium sources like novae.
The study primarily utilizes the Romano et al. (2021) catalog, based on the Gaia-ESO Spectroscopic Survey (GES) iDR6, including 26 open clusters and 2,184 filtered field dwarf stars.
Results: Migration as a Mask
Stars in the solar neighborhood are a "melting pot." Many super-metal-rich stars weren't born here; they migrated from the inner Galaxy. Because these migrants are generally older, they have had billions of years to deplete their surface lithium, creating the illusion of a "dip" in the local population.
When stars are grouped by where they were born rather than where they are, the lithium abundance increases monotonically with metallicity, matching theoretical predictions. For instance, stars with [Fe/H] > 0.1 dex in the sample were found to have an average $R_{birth}$ of 5.2 kpc and an average age of 4.7 Gyr. Their outward migration explains why they appear in our neighborhood with depleted lithium.
The 3-Gyr Threshold and Solar Depletion
The authors found that to see the "true" initial lithium abundance of the Galaxy, one must look at stars younger than 3 billion years. Beyond this age, internal stellar processes have likely already begun to drain the lithium "tank." By comparing field stars to models, they estimated that stars the age of our Sun (~4.5 Gyr) have already depleted about 0.3 dex (roughly half) of their original lithium.
Conclusion
This study demonstrates that the apparent "lithium dip" in super-metal-rich stars is an artifact of radial migration. By accounting for the birthplaces of stars, the observed lithium evolution aligns with chemical evolution models. This highlights the importance of considering Galactic dynamics when interpreting chemical abundances. Future work with more complete alpha-element data and younger stellar samples will further refine our understanding of the Milky Way's chemical history.
Summary updated