Numerical simulation of landscape ecological river flow structure based on vegetation patch distribution and fragmentation

Jingzhou Zhang, Shengtang Zhang, Shufang Li, Zicheng Yu, Wenjun Wang, Wenhao Zhao, Guohao Li, Zheng ZhouFrontiers in Plant Science 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The self-organizing biological characteristics of vegetation and human activities lead to the disruption of the continuous spatial attributes of natural watersheds, which are significant factors affecting river wetland ecosystems. To clarify the landscape ecological flow characteristics of vegetation patch distribution and fragmentation, this study used the three-dimensional Reynolds stress turbulence model in ANSYS Fluent software. The model considered three vegetation patch coverages under two different submersion states and four fragmentation types of vegetation patches under the same coverage conditions within specific vegetation areas. The flow characteristics of longitudinally discontinuous rigid vegetation patches, occupying half of the width of the river channel, were numerically simulated. The model's applicability was verified by indoor open-channel flume experiments. The results indicated that streamwise velocity in vegetated areas is significantly lower than in non-vegetated areas, and the difference in flow capacity increases with patch coverage and fragmentation degree. Furthermore, the vertical distribution of Reynolds stress and turbulent kinetic energy (TKE) shifts significantly based on the submersion state of the canopy.

Introduction

In natural and managed river systems, vegetation rarely grows in a continuous, uniform carpet. Instead, due to both biological self-organization and human intervention, plants often form discrete patches. This "fragmentation" breaks up the spatial continuity of the watershed, creating complex flow patterns that standard, simplified models often fail to capture.

Understanding these patterns is a critical balancing act for river management: vegetation is essential for ecological health, providing habitat and water purification, yet it also affects "flow capacity"—the river's ability to move water without causing unexpected flooding or erosion. This study quantifies how the density (coverage) and the spatial arrangement (fragmentation) of these patches influence streamwise velocity, Reynolds stress, and turbulent kinetic energy (TKE).

Methodology

The researchers employed a three-dimensional Reynolds stress turbulence model (RSM) within ANSYS Fluent. Unlike simpler models that assume isotropic turbulence, the RSM is better equipped to handle the complex, swirling flows found around rigid obstacles like plant stems.

Schematic diagram of river vegetation distribution showing variations in patch coverage and fragmentation.

Key aspects of the experimental setup included:

  • Vegetation Simulation: Rigid cylinders (0.08m high, 0.01m diameter) represented plants.
  • Scenarios: Three coverage levels (2.09% to 8.37%) and two submersion states (non-submerged at 0.05m depth and submerged at 0.09m depth) were tested.
  • Fragmentation Analysis: The same volume of vegetation was divided into four different patch arrangements to isolate the effect of "spreading out" the plants.
  • Validation: To ensure numerical accuracy, physical experiments were conducted in a 5-meter-long indoor open-channel flume, with velocities measured using a 3D Acoustic Doppler Velocimeter (ADV). The numerical simulation showed an average error of only 8.09% compared to experimental data.

Results and Discussion

Fragmentation and Flow Capacity

A primary finding of the study is that fragmentation acts as a force multiplier for hydraulic resistance. As vegetation becomes more fragmented (broken into smaller, more frequent patches), the difference in flow capacity between vegetated and non-vegetated areas increases. Spreading plants out creates more interfaces where fast and slow water meet, thereby increasing overall resistance.

The Submersion Shift

The vertical structure of the flow changes fundamentally depending on whether the plants are underwater:

  • Non-submerged state: The highest turbulence and Reynolds stress occur at the riverbed (the bottom of the plants). In this state, TKE is negatively correlated with patch coverage but positively correlated with fragmentation.
  • Submerged state: The primary hydraulic activity moves to the top of the canopy. A "free layer" of water slides over the plants, creating a high-energy mixing zone. Here, Reynolds stress is positively correlated with both coverage and fragmentation.

Turbulent Kinetic Energy (TKE) Patterns

Inside a vegetation patch, TKE follows a high-low alternating pattern, creating a "zigzag" distribution along the river's length. This is significantly more intense than the smooth flow found in clear water. In submerged states, higher coverage increases TKE in the free layer above the plants, which has significant implications for how nutrients and pollutants are mixed within the river column.

Conclusion and Future Work

This research provides a roadmap for engineers to better predict how ecological restoration projects will impact river hydraulics. By understanding that fragmentation helps "fine-tune" the balance between sediment deposition (good for habitat) and channel clearing, managers can design more effective interventions.

However, limitations remain. This study utilized rigid cylinders; real aquatic plants are flexible and sway, creating even more complex turbulence. Future research should incorporate flexible vegetation models and explore a wider range of thresholds where patch coverage shifts from a minor influence to a dominant driver of river hydraulics.

Summary updated

Abstract

The self-organizing biological characteristics of vegetation and human activities lead to the disruption of the continuous spatial attributes of natural watersheds, which are significant factors affecting river wetland ecosystems. To clarify the landscape ecological flow characteristics of vegetation patch distribution and fragmentation, this study used the three-dimensional Reynolds stress turbulence model in ANSYS Fluent software. The model considered three vegetation patch coverages under two different submersion states and four fragmentation types of vegetation patches under the same coverage conditions within specific vegetation areas. The flow characteristics of longitudinally discontinuous rigid vegetation patches, occupying half of the width of the river channel, were numerically simulated. The model's applicability was verified by indoor open-channel flume experiments. The results indicated that: (1) The streamwise velocity in vegetated areas is significantly lower than in non-vegetated areas, and the difference in flow capacity between vegetated and non-vegetated areas increases with patch coverage and fragmentation degree. (2) In the non-submerged state, the maximum Reynolds stress in the vegetated area is located at the bottom of the vegetation and is negatively correlated with patch coverage but positively correlated with fragmentation degree. In the submerged state, the maximum Reynolds stress is located near the top of the canopy and is positively correlated with both patch coverage and fragmentation degree. (3) The longitudinal turbulent kinetic energy in the vegetated area is significantly higher than in the non-vegetated area. In the non-submerged state, the turbulent kinetic energy in the vegetated area is negatively correlated with patch coverage but positively correlated with fragmentation degree. In the submerged state, the turbulent kinetic energy of the longitudinal distribution in the free layer of the vegetated area is positively correlated with patch coverage, negatively correlated with fragmentation degree, and is only reflected in the upstream vegetation area.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2024numerical,
  author = {Jingzhou Zhang and Shengtang Zhang and Shufang Li and Zicheng Yu and Wenjun Wang and Wenhao Zhao and Guohao Li and Zheng Zhou},
  title = {{Numerical simulation of landscape ecological river flow structure based on vegetation patch distribution and fragmentation}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Plant Science},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3389/fpls.2024.1424566},
}
Figure