EVALUATION OF EXERTING FORCE AS DESIGNING DRY-LAID MASONRY TYPE OF REVETMENTS IN RIVER BENDS

Hideki Otsuki, Kazuo Ashida, Bingyi Liu, Yuji Ohmoto, Akira FujitaPROCEEDINGS 1998 · DOI

Abstract

In order to prepare the guide for designing rich-in-nature type of revetments, we are making some researches into hydraulic characteristics and bank erosion in river bends. In this paper, first, we examine the distribution of flow velocity and the stability of dry-laid masonry type of revetments in river bends by experiments. Then, 2D numerical simulations are carried out to investigate the velocity characteristics under several kinds of conditions. It is shown that the index $v_{toe}/v_{avg}$ ($v_{toe}$: the maximum depth-averaged velocity over the toe of the outer bank, $v_{avg}$: the average velocity in the approach channel) is useful for evaluation of exerting force on revetments, and that some kinds of parameters such as $r/B$ (radius of curvature to width ratio), dimensionless shear stress $\tau_{*0}$, and Froude number $Fr$ influence this index.

Introduction

In "nature-rich" river engineering (多自然型川づくり), engineers prefer using natural materials like dry-laid masonry—stones fitted together without mortar—because they are porous and flexible. However, these structures are more vulnerable to hydraulic forces than rigid concrete, especially in river bends where centrifugal forces create complex secondary currents and significant bed scouring. Until this study, there was a lack of quantitative design guidelines to determine exactly how much force these traditional masonry structures could withstand in a bend. This research aims to provide the "missing link" between river hydraulics and structural stability for eco-friendly bank protection.

Methodology

The researchers employed a dual-track approach combining physical flume experiments and 2D numerical simulations.

  1. Hydraulic Model Experiments: A 1/50 scale model of a 90-degree curved channel with a movable sand bed was constructed. The team tested different masonry configurations, varying stone size, slope gradient, and the presence of "foot protection" (root-solidifying work at the base of the slope).
  2. 2D Numerical Simulations: To generalize the experimental findings, a 2D shallow-water flow model was used, accounting for secondary currents and bed deformation. A parametric study across 24 cases varied the radius of curvature ($r/B$), depth-to-width ratios ($h/B$), and Froude numbers ($Fr$).
Experimental setup (Fig-1), cross-sectional design (Fig-2), and observed velocity distributions (Fig-3).

Key Insights and Results

The study identifies the ratio $v_{toe}/v_{avg}$—the maximum depth-averaged velocity at the outer bank toe relative to the average approach velocity—as the most effective metric for characterizing the hydraulic force acting on a revetment.

A major finding is that bed scouring is a primary driver of bank stress. As the riverbed scours at the outer bend, flow concentrates there, significantly increasing $v_{toe}$. Simulations on a flat bed consistently underestimated this force compared to an equilibrium (scoured) bed. The two most influential factors on this velocity ratio are the radius of curvature ratio ($r/B$) and the dimensionless shear stress ($\tau_{*0}$).

Relationship between the velocity ratio $v_{toe}/v_{avg}$ and curvature $r/B$, highlighting stability limits for curved and straight sections.

In equilibrium bends, $v_{toe}/v_{avg}$ typically ranges between 1.1 and 1.3. For dry-laid masonry without foot protection, the safety threshold appears when the velocity ratio exceeds approximately 1.1. Experiments confirmed that "foot protection" (placing larger stones at the base) is essential; it prevents slope sliding due to scour and creates local hydraulic roughness that reduces the velocity acting directly on the masonry face.

Conclusion

This paper establishes a framework for evaluating the hydraulic forces acting on "nature-rich" dry-laid masonry revetments. By identifying the $v_{toe}/v_{avg}$ metric and its dependence on river geometry and sediment transport, the authors provide a quantitative basis for eco-friendly design. Future work will expand these findings to more complex meandering planforms and validate scale effects for larger river systems.

Summary updated

Abstract

In order to prepare the guide for designing rich-in-nature type of revetments, we are making some researches into hydraulic characteristics and bank erosion in river bends. In this paper, first, we examine the distribution of flow velocity and the stability of dry-laid masonry type of revetments in river bends by experiments. Then, 2D numerical simulations are carried out to investigate the velocity characteristics under several kinds of conditions. It is shown that the index νtoe/νavg (νtoe: the maximum depth-averaged velocity over the toe of the outer bank, νavg: the average velocity in the approach channel) is useful for evaluation of exerting force on revetments, and that some kinds of parameters such as r (the radius of curvature)/B (the width of river), dimensionless shear stress in the approach channel τ·0, Froude number Fr, etc. have an influence on the value of index νtoe/νavg.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{otsuki1998evaluation,
  author = {Hideki Otsuki and Kazuo ASHIDA and Bingyi Liu and Yuji OHMOTO and Akira Fujita},
  title = {{EVALUATION OF EXERTING FORCE AS DESIGNING DRY-LAID MASONRY TYPE OF REVETMENTS IN RIVER BENDS}},
  booktitle = {PROCEEDINGS},
  year = {1998},
  doi = {10.2208/prohe.42.469},
}
Figure