Nuclear and Trace Ideals in Tensored *-Categories

Samson Abramsky, Richard Blute, Prakash Panangaden

Abstract

We generalize the notion of nuclear maps from functional analysis by defining nuclear ideals in tensored -categories. The motivation for this study came from attempts to generalize the structure of the category of relations to handle what might be called "probabilistic relations". The compact closed structure associated with the category of relations does not generalize directly, instead one obtains nuclear ideals. We introduce the notion of nuclear ideal to analyze these classes of morphisms. In compact closed categories, we see that all morphisms are nuclear, and in the category of Hilbert spaces, the nuclear morphisms are the Hilbert-Schmidt maps. We also introduce two new examples of tensored -categories, in which integration plays the role of composition. In the first, morphisms are a special class of distributions, which we call tame distributions. We also introduce a category of probabilistic relations which was the original motivating example. Finally, we extend the recent work of Joyal, Street and Verity on traced monoidal categories to this setting by introducing the notion of a trace ideal. For a given symmetric monoidal category, it is not generally the case that arbitrary endomorphisms can be assigned a trace. However, we can find ideals in the category on which a trace can be defined satisfying equations analogous to those of Joyal, Street and Verity. We establish a close correspondence between nuclear ideals and trace ideals in a tensored *-category, suggested by the correspondence between Hilbert-Schmidt operators and trace operators on a Hilbert space.

Introduction

The concept of nuclear maps is a cornerstone of functional analysis, particularly in the study of Hilbert spaces. This paper generalizes this notion by introducing nuclear ideals within the broader framework of tensored -categories. The primary motivation stems from the need to handle "probabilistic relations," where the standard compact closed structure of the category of relations (Rel*) fails to generalize directly. By identifying specific ideals of morphisms that behave like those in compact closed categories, the authors provide a rigorous way to define traces and transposes in settings where they are not globally available.

Theoretical Framework

The authors define a tensored *-category as a symmetric monoidal category equipped with a covariant involution (adjoint). In this setting, they axiomatize nuclear ideals. A morphism $f: A \to B$ is considered nuclear if it can be uniquely associated with a "pseudoname" in a tensor product space, effectively allowing it to be treated as a matrix-like object.

Commutative diagram illustrating the categorical structure underlying nuclear morphisms, involving tensor products and dual objects.

The definition of a nuclear ideal allows for the recovery of useful features like traces even when the identity map itself may not be traceable. This is particularly relevant in infinite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, where the identity is not a Hilbert-Schmidt operator.

Key Insights and Examples

The paper bridges the gap between abstract category theory and concrete functional analysis through several key examples:

  • Hilbert Spaces: In the category Hilb, the nuclear ideal corresponds exactly to the class of Hilbert-Schmidt maps.
  • Distributions (DRel): The authors construct a category where morphisms are "tame distributions" and composition is defined via integration (convolution).
  • Probabilistic Relations (PRel): Objects are probability spaces and morphisms are measures. The nuclear ideal here consists of measures with functional kernels.

A central insight is that integration is composition. In probabilistic and distributional settings, integration plays the role that existential quantification plays in relational composition. Furthermore, the authors establish a correspondence between nuclear ideals and trace ideals, extending the work of Joyal, Street, and Verity.

Naturality diagram for the unit object I and its dual, showing the consistency of the trace operation on the unit.

Conclusion and Future Directions

The introduction of nuclear and trace ideals provides a powerful tool for analyzing categories that lack global compact closure. While the transposition map used to define these ideals is canonical in the studied examples, its general uniqueness remains a point for further investigation. Future work may explore the computational semantics of these ideals in programming language theory and their extension to higher-dimensional structures like 2-Hilbert spaces in Topological Quantum Field Theory (TQFT).

Summary updated

Abstract

We generalize the notion of nuclear maps from functional analysis by defining nuclear ideals in tensored *-categories. The motivation for this study came from attempts to generalize the structure of the category of relations to handle what might be called ``probabilistic relations''. The compact closed structure associated with the category of relations does not generalize directly, instead one obtains nuclear ideals. We introduce the notion of nuclear ideal to analyze these classes of morphisms. In compact closed categories, we see that all morphisms are nuclear, and in the category of Hilbert spaces, the nuclear morphisms are the Hilbert-Schmidt maps. We also introduce two new examples of tensored *-categories, in which integration plays the role of composition. In the first, morphisms are a special class of distributions, which we call tame distributions. We also introduce a category of probabilistic relations which was the original motivating example. Finally, we extend the recent work of Joyal, Street and Verity on traced monoidal categories to this setting by introducing the notion of a trace ideal. For a given symmetric monoidal category, it is not generally the case that arbitrary endomorphisms can be assigned a trace. However, we can find ideals in the category on which a trace can be defined satisfying equations analogous to those of Joyal, Street and Verity. We establish a close correspondence between nuclear ideals and trace ideals in a tensored *-category, suggested by the correspondence between Hilbert-Schmidt operators and trace operators on a Hilbert space.
BibTeX
@article{abramsky1999nuclear,
  author = {Samson Abramsky and Richard Blute and Prakash Panangaden},
  title = {{Nuclear and Trace Ideals in Tensored *-Categories}},
  journal = {Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1016/s0022-4049(98)00106-6},
}

Loading related content...

Figure