Nuclear and trace ideals in tensored ∗-categories

Samson Abramsky, Richard Blute, Prakash Panangaden

TL;DR

This paper introduces "nuclear ideals" as a way to generalize the concept of "nuclear maps" from functional analysis to the abstract setting of tensored *-categories. This new framework allows for a more nuanced understanding of structures that resemble categories of relations but lack a full compact closed structure, with applications in areas like probability and quantum field theory.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The authors aim to generalize the notion of binary relations, which are fundamental in mathematics and computer science. While the category of relations (Rel) has a rich structure (specifically, it's a compact closed category), many interesting generalizations, like probabilistic relations or certain structures arising from Hilbert spaces, lack this full structure. Specifically, they can't directly "transfer variables" between the input and output of a relation. This loss of structure means that standard categorical tools for relations don't directly apply. The paper seeks to develop a new categorical framework that captures the essence of these "generalized relations" even when the compact closed property is absent, by focusing on a specific class of "nuclear" morphisms.

Methods

The core contribution is the introduction of the concept of a nuclear ideal within the framework of tensored *-categories. A tensored -category is a category with a tensor product, an involution (like conjugation), and certain compatibility conditions. The authors define a nuclear ideal as a special class of morphisms within such a category that behaves like a compact closed category on its own. This involves defining "nuclear maps" and a corresponding "transpose" operation. They then extend this by defining trace ideals, which are analogous to trace class operators in functional analysis and are closely related to nuclear ideals. The paper also introduces new examples of tensored -categories, such as those based on distributions and probabilistic relations, and shows how these concepts apply.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Nuclear Ideals as a Bridge: Nuclear ideals provide a way to recover some of the structure of compact closed categories in settings where the full structure is absent. They act as a "well-behaved" sub-structure.
  • Hilbert Spaces and Nuclearity: The paper draws a strong analogy between the category of Hilbert spaces and bounded linear maps (Hilb) and the category of relations (Rel). In Hilb, Hilbert-Schmidt maps play a role analogous to nuclear maps, and this connection motivates the abstract definition.
  • Distributions and Probabilistic Relations: The authors construct novel tensored *-categories using distributions and probabilistic relations, demonstrating the broad applicability of their framework. These categories are not compact closed, but they do possess nuclear ideals.
  • Trace Ideals as a Generalization: Trace ideals are introduced as a generalization of the trace operation, closely linked to nuclear ideals. This connection mirrors the relationship between Hilbert-Schmidt operators and trace class operators in functional analysis.

Key Results

  • The paper formally defines "nuclear ideals" and "trace ideals" for tensored *-categories.
  • It establishes that the category of Hilbert spaces with Hilbert-Schmidt maps forms a nuclear ideal.
  • New examples of tensored *-categories are constructed using distributions (DRel) and probabilistic relations (PRel), and their nuclear ideals are characterized.
  • A close correspondence is established between nuclear ideals and trace ideals, generalizing known results from functional analysis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uniqueness of Transposition: The authors note that the "transposition map" used in defining nuclear ideals might not be unique, and they are still investigating this question.
  • Computational Significance of Trace Ideals: The computational significance of trace ideals remains an open question.
  • Higher-Dimensional Categories: Extending the theory to higher-dimensional categories is suggested as a future direction.
  • Conformal Field Theory: The authors suspect that nuclear ideals might be relevant to understanding structures in conformal field theory, particularly those that lack identity morphisms.
  • Noncommutative Distributions: The theory of DRel could be extended to noncommutative distributions.

Summary updated

Abstract

We generalize the notion of nuclear maps from functional analysis by defining nuclear ideals in tensored *-categories. The motivation for this study came from attempts to generalize the structure of the category of relations to handle what might be called ``probabilistic relations''. The compact closed structure associated with the category of relations does not generalize directly, instead one obtains nuclear ideals. We introduce the notion of nuclear ideal to analyze these classes of morphisms. In compact closed categories, we see that all morphisms are nuclear, and in the category of Hilbert spaces, the nuclear morphisms are the Hilbert-Schmidt maps. We also introduce two new examples of tensored *-categories, in which integration plays the role of composition. In the first, morphisms are a special class of distributions, which we call tame distributions. We also introduce a category of probabilistic relations which was the original motivating example. Finally, we extend the recent work of Joyal, Street and Verity on traced monoidal categories to this setting by introducing the notion of a trace ideal. For a given symmetric monoidal category, it is not generally the case that arbitrary endomorphisms can be assigned a trace. However, we can find ideals in the category on which a trace can be defined satisfying equations analogous to those of Joyal, Street and Verity. We establish a close correspondence between nuclear ideals and trace ideals in a tensored *-category, suggested by the correspondence between Hilbert-Schmidt operators and trace operators on a Hilbert space.
BibTeX
@article{abramsky1999nuclear,
  author = {Samson Abramsky and Richard Blute and Prakash Panangaden},
  title = {{Nuclear and trace ideals in tensored ∗-categories}},
  journal = {Journal of Pure and Applied Algebra},
  year = {1999},
  doi = {10.1016/s0022-4049(98)00106-6},
}

Loading related content...

Figure