Non-orthogonal realizations of Coxeter groups

Xiang Fu

Abstract

We define in an axiomatic fashion a Coxeter datum for an arbitrary Coxeter group $W$. This Coxeter datum specifies a pair of reflection representations of $W$ in two vector spaces linked only by a bilinear pairing without any integrality and non-degeneracy requirements. These representations are not required to be embeddings of $W$ in the orthogonal group of any vector space, and they give rise to a pair of inter-related root systems generalizing the classical root systems of Coxeter groups. We obtain comparison results between these non-orthogonal root systems and the classical root systems. Further, we study the equivalent of the Tits cone in these non-orthogonal representations, and we show that strong results on the geometry in the equivalent of the Tits cone can be obtained.

Introduction

In the classical theory of Coxeter groups, as established by Bourbaki and Humphreys, the geometric realization of a group $W$ relies on a specific set of constraints. Traditionally, simple roots are required to be linearly independent, and the group is embedded as an isometry group within a vector space equipped with a symmetric bilinear form. While this "standard" realization is powerful, it is inherently restrictive.

In the paper "Non-orthogonal realizations of Coxeter groups," Xiang Fu develops a significant generalization of these geometric structures. By relaxing the requirements for linear independence and orthogonality, Fu introduces a flexible framework—the "Coxeter datum"—that unifies the study of reflection subgroups and Kac-Moody-like structures. This approach allows for a deeper understanding of how Coxeter groups behave when the classical geometric assumptions are stripped away.

The Problem: Beyond Classical Constraints

The motivation for this work stems from two primary limitations in the classical setup:

  1. Reflection Subgroups: While any subgroup of a Coxeter group generated by reflections is itself a Coxeter group, its "simple roots" may not be linearly independent in the original ambient space. Furthermore, the bilinear form values for these subgroups often fail to meet classical requirements, such as when dealing with infinite-order products.
  2. Kac-Moody Algebras: The Weyl groups associated with Kac-Moody algebras naturally suggest a "non-orthogonal" approach using dual vector spaces. However, existing theories often imposed strict integrality or non-degeneracy conditions that limited their universality.

Fu’s research bridges these gaps by providing a theory that does not require roots to form a basis or the pairing to be non-degenerate, creating a universal language for diverse realizations of Coxeter systems.

The Coxeter Datum Framework

The core of Fu's methodology is the definition of a Coxeter datum $\mathcal{C} = (S, V_1, V_2, \Pi_1, \Pi_2, \langle \cdot, \cdot \rangle)$. This consists of a set $S$, two vector spaces ($V_1$ and $V_2$), two sets of simple roots ($\Pi_1$ and $\Pi_2$), and a bilinear pairing between the two spaces.

To ensure these components behave as a coherent Coxeter system, Fu establishes five axioms (C1–C5). These axioms govern the interaction between the pairing and the reflections, ensuring that the resulting group action remains consistent with the abstract group structure. A key innovation here is the use of "canonical coefficients." Because roots in this setting are not necessarily linearly independent, Fu introduces a "free" Coxeter datum (where independence is guaranteed) and utilizes a $W$-equivariant bijection to map properties back to the general case.

Key Theoretical Insights

Faithfulness of Representations

One of the most significant results of the paper is Theorem 2.10, which proves that these constructed reflection representations are faithful for any abstract Coxeter group. This demonstrates that linear independence is not a prerequisite for a geometrically meaningful and algebraically accurate representation of $W$.

Root System Dynamics

In this non-orthogonal framework, the relationship between reflections and roots becomes more complex. Unlike classical systems where a reflection corresponds to exactly one positive root (and its negative), these systems can have infinitely many distinct positive roots corresponding to the same reflection. Fu manages this complexity through Proposition 3.18, establishing a unique $W$-equivariant bijection between the root systems in $V_1$ and $V_2$, allowing for a consistent dual perspective.

Geometric Comparison and the Tits Cone

Fu provides a bridge to classical theory through Proposition 4.11, proving that the product of the coefficients of a non-orthogonal root and its dual counterpart is always $\geq 1$. This inequality allows for direct comparison with standard orthogonal systems.

Furthermore, the paper extends the concept of the Tits cone—a fundamental object for understanding the action of infinite Coxeter groups—to this broader setting. Fu proves a major geometric result in Theorem 5.8, showing that for any $v_1$ in the dual Tits cone of $V_1$ and $v_2$ in the dual Tits cone of $V_2$, the pairing $\langle v_1, v_2 \rangle \leq 0$. This generalizes a well-known result by G.A. Maxwell and confirms that the geometry of the Tits cone remains robust even in non-orthogonal realizations.

Conclusion and Future Directions

Xiang Fu’s work provides a rigorous axiomatic foundation for non-orthogonal realizations of Coxeter groups. By proving that faithfulness and geometric structure (like the Tits cone) persist without classical constraints, the paper opens new avenues for studying reflection groups in broader algebraic contexts.

While the foundational geometry is now well-established, several areas remain for future exploration. These include the algorithmic complexity of word problems within these systems, the classification of "pathological" realizations with infinite roots per reflection, and determining the exact boundary where integrality becomes necessary for deeper structural results in Lie theory.

Summary updated

Abstract

We define in an axiomatic fashion a \emph{Coxeter datum} for an arbitrary Coxeter group $W$. This Coxeter datum will specify a pair of reflection representations of $W$ in two vector spaces linked only by a bilinear paring without any integrality and non-degeneracy requirements. These representations are not required to be embeddings of $W$ in the orthogonal group of any vector space, and they give rise to a pair of inter-related root systems generalizing the classical root systems of Coxeter groups. We obtain comparison results between these non-orthogonal root systems and the classical root systems. Further, we study the equivalent of the Tits cone in these non-orthogonal representations, and we show that strong results on the geometry in the equivalent of the Tits cone can be obtained.
BibTeX
@misc{fu2011non,
  author = {Xiang Fu},
  title = {{Non-orthogonal realizations of Coxeter groups}},
  year = {2011},
  eprint = {1112.3429},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/1112.3429},
}

Loading related content...

Figure