Neural determinants of the increase in muscle strength and force steadiness of the untrained limb following a 4-week unilateral training

Edoardo Lecce, Paolo Amoruso, Alessandro Del Vecchio, Francesco Casolo, Francesco Felici, Dario Farina, Ilenia Bazzucchi

Abstract

Unilateral resistance training, or "cross-education," is known to enhance strength and force steadiness in the contralateral untrained limb. While these adaptations are attributed to neural changes, the specific motoneuron-level mechanisms have remained largely unexplored. This study utilized high-density surface electromyography (HDsEMG) to track individual motor units in 10 participants over a 4-week unilateral training intervention. We found that maximal voluntary force (MVF) increased in both the trained (+14%) and untrained (+6%) limbs, while force variability (CovF) decreased in both. These improvements were mediated by a higher proportion of shared synaptic input (CSI) and lower motor unit recruitment thresholds (RT). Crucially, persistent inward currents (PICs) increased only in the trained limb, indicating that while some neural "software updates" are shared across the spinal cord, others require direct mechanical overloading.

Introduction: The Mystery of Cross-Education

It is a well-documented phenomenon in human physiology that training one limb leads to strength gains in the opposite, untrained limb. Since the untrained muscle experiences no mechanical overload, these gains must be neural in origin—a "software update" rather than a "hardware upgrade." However, identifying the exact changes within the nervous system has been challenging. This study focuses on the motoneuron, the final common pathway for movement, to determine how the nervous system optimizes muscle performance without direct exercise.

Methods and Datasets

The researchers studied 19 recreationally active individuals, with 10 performing four weeks of unilateral eccentric biceps training and 9 serving as controls. Using High-Density Surface Electromyography (HDsEMG) with a 64-electrode grid, the team "decomposed" electrical signals into the firing patterns of individual motor units.

A key strength of this study was the use of longitudinal tracking, which allowed researchers to monitor the exact same 375 motor units (from an initial pool of 1,266) before and after the intervention. They specifically analyzed:

  • Common Synaptic Input (CSI): The shared "command" signal across the motor unit pool.
  • Persistent Inward Currents (PICs): Internal spinal amplifiers that sustain motoneuron firing.
  • Recruitment Thresholds (RT): The force level required to activate a motor unit.

Results: Force Steadiness

Both the trained and untrained limbs showed significant improvements in force steadiness. This was strongly correlated ($R^2 > 0.70$) with a reduction in the variability of common synaptic input (CSI-V). Essentially, the nervous system became more consistent in its shared commands to the muscle, reducing the "noise" that causes force fluctuations.

Adaptations in force steadiness for both trained and untrained limbs, showing reduced variance in common synaptic input (CSI-V) and force variability (CovF).

Results: Strength and Neural Drive

Maximal voluntary force (MVF) increased by 14% in the trained limb and 6% in the untrained limb. While both sides benefited from increased CSI and lower recruitment thresholds, a key divergence emerged: Persistent Inward Currents (PICs) and overall neural drive increased only in the trained limb. This suggests that while the "shared command" (CSI) can be learned and applied to both sides, the "internal amplifiers" (PICs) within the spinal cord require local activation or mechanical load to adapt.

Comparison of neural adaptations and strength gains between the trained (blue) and untrained (red) limbs.

Discussion: Neural Determinants of Gain

The findings suggest that cross-education is a "leakage" of neural skill. The nervous system learns to send a clearer, more synchronized signal (increased CSI) and lowers the barrier to entry for muscle activation (lower RT) for both limbs. However, the trained limb receives an additional boost from enhanced PICs, explaining its superior strength gains. This distinction highlights that while the brain and spinal cord can distribute some efficiency gains bilaterally, certain physiological "amplifiers" remain localized to the exercised muscle.

Limitations and Future Work

  1. Signal Origin: HDsEMG identifies that shared input increased but cannot pinpoint if the source is the motor cortex or spinal circuitry.
  2. Sample Size: With 19 participants, larger cohorts are needed to confirm these findings across broader populations.
  3. Clinical Potential: The most promising application is in rehabilitation, where cross-education could help maintain function in immobilized limbs (e.g., after injury or stroke). Future research should focus on these clinical populations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Enhanced untrained muscle strength and force steadiness following unilateral resistance training (i.e., cross-education ) is typically attributed to neural responses. However, the mechanisms of these adaptations for spinal motoneurons remain unexplored. Therefore, we examined maximal-voluntary-force (MVF), steady-force variability (CovF), and longitudinally tracked motor unit adaptations in 10 individuals completing a 4-week unilateral strength intervention compared to 9 controls. High-density surface electromyography was recorded from the biceps brachii during steady (10%MVF) and trapezoidal (35%MVF) contractions. The relative proportion of common synaptic input (CSI) to motoneurons and its variability (CSI-V) were estimated using coherence and spectral analysis. Indirect estimates of persistent inward currents using firing rate hysteresis (ΔF) and motor unit recruitment thresholds (MURT) were assessed during the ramp forces (35%MVF). MVF increased in both the trained (+14%, p <0.001) and untrained limbs (+6%, p =0.004), and CovF decreased in both limbs ( p <0.001). Greater CSI was observed on both sides (p<0.01), concomitant with reduced CSI-V (p<0.01). ΔF increased exclusively in the trained limbs (+1.61±0.71 pps; p <0.001), and both sides exhibited lower MURT (p<0.001). In trained limbs, MVF gains were strongly associated with changes in CSI, MURT, and ΔF (R²>0.70, p <0.01), while the contralateral muscle MVF increase was associated exclusively with CSI and MURT (R²>0.65, p <0.01). In both limbs, lower CovF was strongly associated with reduced CSI-V (R²>0.70, p <0.01). Our findings suggest that enhanced untrained muscle force and steadiness are mediated by increased relative strength of shared synaptic input with respect to independent noise and decreased variability of this shared input, with gains in trained muscle MVF being associated with ΔF. Key points Unilateral resistance training improves strength and force steadiness in the contralateral untrained limb, suggesting neural adaptations without directly overloading the muscle. Despite established force-related modifications, the specific neural mechanisms mediating these functional responses remain largely unknown. 4-week unilateral training intervention enhanced muscle strength and force steadiness in the untrained limbs of 10 individuals, alongside a greater proportion of shared synaptic input, reduced variance in common input, and lower motor unit recruitment thresholds. We demonstrate that the neural mechanisms underlying improved strength and force control in muscles without mechanical overloading are associated with a higher relative shared input among motoneurons and reduced variance in these common input components. Graphical abstract legend unilateral training intervention reduced the variance in common synaptic input (CSI-V), which was associated with decreased variability in force steadiness (CovF) in both the trained and contralateral untrained limbs. On the exercised side, the increase in maximal voluntary force (MVF) was accompanied by a higher proportion of common synaptic input (CSI), a lower motor unit recruitment threshold (RT), enhanced persistent inward current (PIC) amplitude, and increased neural drive. In contrast, the contralateral untrained limb exhibited higher shared synaptic input and a lower RT but with unaltered PIC amplitude and neural drive (⇋). Overall, these adaptations resulted in a 14% increase in MVF in the exercised limb and a 6% increase in the untrained limb.
BibTeX
@article{lecce2025neural,
  author = {Edoardo Lecce and Paolo Amoruso and Alessandro Del Vecchio and Francesco Casolo and Francesco Felici and Dario Farina and Ilenia Bazzucchi},
  title = {{Neural determinants of the increase in muscle strength and force steadiness of the untrained limb following a 4-week unilateral training}},
  journal = {The Journal of Physiology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1113/jp288954},
}
Figure