Neuroplastic alterations in common synaptic inputs and synergistic motor unit clusters controlling the vastii muscles of individuals with ACL reconstruction

Stefano Nuccio, Carina Marconi Germer, Francesco Casolo, Riccardo Borzuola, Luciana Labanca, Jacopo Emanuele Rocchi, Pier Paolo Mariani, Francesco Felici, Dario Farina, Deborah Falla, Andrea Macaluso, Paola Sbriccoli, Alessandro Del VecchioJournal of Applied Physiology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

Chronic quadriceps dysfunction is a frequent complication following anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). This study investigates the neural mechanisms underlying knee extension force control in ACLR patients. By analyzing high-density surface electromyography (HDEMG) and motor unit firing patterns, researchers identified significant neuroplastic changes: reduced common synaptic input to the vastus lateralis and a reorganization of synergistic motor unit clusters. These findings suggest that the central nervous system employs compensatory neural strategies to maintain force steadiness despite overall muscle weakness.

Introduction

Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries often lead to long-term quadriceps dysfunction, even after successful surgical reconstruction and rehabilitation. A primary driver of this dysfunction is arthrogenic muscle inhibition (AMI), a neurological condition where the central nervous system (CNS) involuntarily inhibits neural drive to the quadriceps. While the reduction in maximal voluntary force (MVF) is well-documented, the impact of ACLR on submaximal force control—essential for daily activities and athletic performance—remains less understood. This study aims to elucidate how the CNS alters common synaptic inputs (CSI) and synergistic motor unit (MU) clusters to maintain force steadiness in the vastus lateralis (VL) and vastus medialis (VM) muscles following ACLR.

Methods

The study involved 11 male soccer players with unilateral ACLR and 9 healthy matched controls. Participants performed isometric knee extensions at 10% and 30% of their MVF. Neural activity was captured using High-Density Surface Electromyography (HDEMG) with 64-electrode grids placed over the VL and VM.

The HDEMG signals were decomposed into individual motor unit spike trains using blind source separation. The researchers then applied two primary analytical techniques:

  1. Intramuscular Coherence Analysis: This estimated the CSI by analyzing the frequency of MU firing patterns, specifically focusing on the $\delta$ band (<5 Hz), which reflects the effective neural drive for volitional force control.
  2. Factor Analysis: This identified "motor unit modes"—functional clusters of motor neurons that fire together. This approach allowed the researchers to determine if motor units from different muscles were being controlled as a single functional unit.

Results

Force Steadiness and Maximal Strength

As expected, the ACLR group showed significantly lower MVF in the reconstructed limb compared to the contralateral limb and healthy controls. However, force steadiness (measured by the coefficient of variation of force) remained similar across all groups and limbs. This indicates that the CNS successfully compensates for neural deficits to maintain precise force control during submaximal tasks.

Attenuated Neural Drive to the Vastus Lateralis

The study found a marked reduction in the neural drive to the VL on the reconstructed side. Specifically, the coherence in the $\delta$ band for the VL was significantly lower (0.08 at 10% MVF) compared to the contralateral side (0.22) and healthy controls (~0.18-0.24). Furthermore, the Proportion of Common Input (PCI) to the VL was significantly diminished in the reconstructed limb (0.269 vs. 0.672 in controls).

Neuroplastic Reorganization of Motor Unit Clusters

Factor analysis revealed that the CNS reorganizes how it controls motor units across the quadriceps after ACLR. In healthy limbs, motor units typically cluster according to their anatomical muscle. However, in reconstructed limbs, a significantly higher percentage of motor units (19.2%) physically located in the VL were found to synchronize their firing with the neural drive primarily associated with the VM. This suggests a plastic rearrangement where the VM's neural drive becomes more dominant in controlling the overall synergistic output of the vastii muscles.

Discussion

These findings provide evidence of significant neuroplasticity following ACLR. The reduction in common synaptic input to the VL suggests that this muscle's role in fine force modulation is marginalized. To compensate and maintain force steadiness, the CNS appears to "rewire" its control strategy, recruiting motor units from the VL into the functional clusters typically driven by the VM's neural input.

While these compensatory mechanisms allow for steady force production, they may contribute to the persistent biomechanical alterations and increased reinjury risk seen in ACLR patients. Future research should explore whether these neural adaptations persist during high-force or dynamic tasks and investigate how rehabilitation protocols might be optimized to restore more physiological neural control strategies.

Conclusion

Chronic quadriceps weakness after ACLR is not merely a matter of muscle atrophy but involves a fundamental reorganization of the neural drive. By identifying these specific alterations in common synaptic input and motor unit synergies, this study opens new avenues for targeted neuro-rehabilitation strategies aimed at restoring optimal quadriceps function.

Summary updated

Abstract

This cross-sectional study aims to elucidate the neural mechanisms underlying the control of knee extension forces in individuals with anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). Eleven soccer players with ACLR and nine control players performed unilateral isometric knee extensions at 10% and 30% of their maximum voluntary force (MVF). Simultaneous recordings of high-density surface electromyography (HDEMG) and force output were conducted for each lower limb, and HDEMG data from the vastus lateralis (VL) and vastus medialis (VM) muscles were decomposed into individual motor unit spike trains. Force steadiness was estimated using the coefficient of variation of force. An intramuscular coherence analysis was adopted to estimate the common synaptic input (CSI) converging to each muscle. A factor analysis was applied to investigate the neural strategies underlying the control of synergistic motor neuron clusters, referred to as motor unit modes. Force steadiness was similar between lower limbs. However, motor neurons innervating the VL on the reconstructed side received a lower proportion of CSI at low-frequency bandwidths (<5 Hz) compared with the unaffected lower limbs (<i>P</i> < 0.01). Furthermore, the reconstructed side demonstrated a higher proportion of motor units associated with the neural input common to the synergistic muscle, as compared with the unaffected lower limbs (<i>P</i> < 0.01). These findings indicate that the VL muscle of reconstructed lower limbs contribute marginally to force steadiness and that a plastic rearrangement in synergistic clusters of motor units involved in the control of knee extension forces is evident following ACLR.<b>NEW & NOTEWORTHY</b> Chronic quadriceps dysfunction is common after anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction (ACLR). We investigated voluntary force control strategies by estimating common inputs to motor neurons innervating the vastii muscles. Our results showed attenuated common inputs to the vastus lateralis and plastic rearrangements in functional clusters of motor neurons modulating knee extension forces in the reconstructed limb. These findings suggest neuroplastic adjustments following ACLR that may occur to fine-tune the control of quadriceps forces.
BibTeX
@article{nuccio2024neuroplastic,
  author = {Stefano Nuccio and Carina Marconi Germer and Francesco Casolo and Riccardo Borzuola and Luciana Labanca and Jacopo Emanuele Rocchi and Pier Paolo Mariani and Francesco Felici and Dario Farina and Deborah Falla and Andrea Macaluso and Paola Sbriccoli and Alessandro Del Vecchio},
  title = {{Neuroplastic alterations in common synaptic inputs and synergistic motor unit clusters controlling the vastii muscles of individuals with ACL reconstruction}},
  journal = {Journal of Applied Physiology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1152/japplphysiol.00056.2024},
}
Figure