Abstract
To date there exists no reliable method to non-invasively upregulate or downregulate the state of the resting motor system over a large dynamic range. Here we show that an operant conditioning paradigm which provides neurofeedback of the size of motor evoked potentials (MEPs) in response to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), enables participants to self-modulate their own brain state. Following training, participants were able to robustly increase (by 83.8%) and decrease (by 30.6%) their MEP amplitudes. This volitional up-versus down-regulation of corticomotor excitability caused an increase of late-cortical disinhibition (LCD), a TMS derived read-out of presynaptic GABA B disinhibition, which was accompanied by an increase of gamma and a decrease of alpha oscillations in the trained hemisphere. This approach paves the way for future investigations into how altered brain state influences motor neurophysiology and recovery of function in a neurorehabilitation context.
Introduction
Our brain states are constantly fluctuating. Sometimes our motor system is "primed" and ready to move; other times, it is inhibited. Historically, these fluctuations were seen as "noise" or incidental changes. While we knew that certain mental states (like motor imagery) could influence these levels, we lacked a reliable, non-invasive way to help individuals precisely upregulate or downregulate the resting motor system over a large dynamic range.
This isn't just a curiosity for neuroscientists—it has massive implications for neurorehabilitation. For instance, after a stroke, a patient might be unable to move a limb, making traditional physical therapy impossible. If they could learn to endogenously "prime" the relevant brain circuits, it could provide the necessary neural activity to promote re-wiring and functional recovery.
Methods
The researchers developed a Brain-Computer Interface (BCI) that uses Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) and Electromyography (EMG) to create a closed-loop neurofeedback system.
- The Loop: A TMS pulse is delivered to the participant's motor cortex, evoking a small twitch in the hand called a Motor Evoked Potential (MEP).
- Neurofeedback: The size of this MEP is measured in real-time and displayed to the participant as a bar graph.
- Operant Conditioning: Participants were rewarded (visually and financially) for making the MEPs larger (UP training) or smaller (DOWN training) using mental strategies like motor imagery.
- Validation: To ensure the effect was real, they used a control group receiving "sham" feedback (not tied to their actual brain activity).
- Mechanistic Probing: The team used simultaneous EEG to look at brain rhythms and paired-pulse TMS to investigate specific inhibitory neurochemical circuits (GABAergic pathways).
The study involved 15 healthy volunteers in the experimental group and 13 in the control group. 11 participants from the experimental group were re-tested 6 months later to assess long-term retention.
Results
Participants demonstrated a remarkable ability to modulate their corticomotor excitability. Following training, they increased MEP amplitudes by an average of 83.8% during UP sessions and decreased them by 30.6% during DOWN sessions.
Key findings include:
- Machine Learning Classification: Using only EEG power values from the 1.5 seconds before the TMS pulse, a Support Vector Machine (SVM) could classify whether the brain was in an "UP" or "DOWN" state with 81.5% accuracy.
- Specificity: While the effects were strongest in the targeted hemisphere, a weaker but similar pattern was observed in the opposite hemisphere, suggesting a degree of transcallosal "spillover."
- Control Group: The control group showed no systematic changes, proving that the feedback—not just the mental imagery—was the driver of the learning.
Discussion
This study demonstrates that the brain can be treated like a "volume knob," with participants learning to modulate excitability across a massive range. Perhaps the most surprising finding was the skill retention; participants retained the ability to modulate these states 6 months later, even without a "top-up" session.
Mechanistically, the "UP" state (high excitability) was characterized by a decrease in Alpha oscillations (8-13Hz) and an increase in Gamma oscillations (31-80Hz). This supports the "pulsed inhibition" theory, where alpha acts as a gatekeeper that must be lowered to allow high-frequency gamma processing. Furthermore, by using paired-pulse TMS, the authors found that the "UP" state is specifically linked to Late Cortical Disinhibition (LCD). This suggests that the mechanism for self-modulation is the release of presynaptic $GABA_B$ inhibition, rather than a change in postsynaptic $GABA_A$ pathways.
Limitations and Future Work
While robust, the study's sample size is relatively small (n=15). The next critical step is clinical translation: determining if stroke patients can achieve similar levels of volitional control despite damaged neural architecture. Additionally, Late Cortical Disinhibition (LCD) was only detectable during the active "UP" state and not at rest, suggesting that the parameters for measuring this specific inhibitory circuit might need further optimization to be used as a general biomarker. Finally, while participants were given suggested imagery, the specific "internal" feel of the UP vs. DOWN states remains subjective and likely varies between individuals.
Summary updated