Neural activity related to volitional regulation of cortical excitability

Kathy Ruddy, Joshua H. Balsters, Dante Mantini, Quanying Liu, Pegah Kassraian, Nadja Enz, Ernest Mihelj, Bankim Subhash Chander, Surjo R. Soekadar, Nicole Wenderoth

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel neurofeedback system using Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) that allows individuals to voluntarily control their brain's motor cortex excitability, both increasing and decreasing it significantly. This self-regulation is linked to specific changes in brain oscillations and inhibitory circuits, opening doors for new rehabilitation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Currently, there's no reliable, non-invasive way to precisely upregulate or downregulate the excitability of the human motor system over a broad range. This is a significant challenge, especially in neurorehabilitation, where precise control over brain states could be crucial for promoting neural plasticity and recovery after conditions like stroke. While brain-computer interfaces (BCIs) have shown promise in volitionally controlling neural activity, achieving large, bidirectional changes in motor cortex excitability with direct neurofeedback has remained elusive.

Methods

The core of this study is a novel BCI-neurofeedback paradigm that combines TMS with real-time feedback of motor evoked potentials (MEPs). Here's how it works:

  • TMS-Evoked MEPs: Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation (TMS) pulses are delivered to the motor cortex, eliciting MEPs in hand muscles. The amplitude of these MEPs serves as a direct measure of corticospinal excitability.
  • Operant Conditioning with Neurofeedback: Participants are trained to either increase (UP condition) or decrease (DOWN condition) their MEP amplitudes. They receive visual feedback on a screen showing their MEP size relative to a baseline. Successful modulation (larger MEPs in UP, smaller in DOWN) is rewarded with positive auditory cues and a financial incentive.
  • Multimodal Assessment: After training, participants undergo further testing using:
  • EEG: To record brain oscillations (alpha, gamma, theta, etc.) simultaneously with TMS.
  • Paired-Pulse TMS: To probe specific inhibitory and disinhibitory circuits within the motor cortex (SICI, LICI, and LCD).
  • Control Group: A control group received the same visual feedback but it was not contingent on their MEP amplitudes, helping to isolate the effect of veridical neurofeedback.
  • Retention and Aftereffects: Follow-up tests were conducted months later to assess long-term learning and any lingering effects.

Datasets

The study utilized data collected from human participants. No specific pre-existing datasets were used for training or evaluation. The data generated by this experiment, including processed EEG, EMG, and MEPs, are made openly available on the ETH Library Research Collection.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Volitional Control Achieved: The most striking finding is that participants can indeed learn to volitionally upregulate and downregulate their motor cortex excitability over a substantial dynamic range, far beyond what's observed at rest.
  • Neurofeedback is Crucial: The control group, which received non-contingent feedback, showed no significant changes, highlighting the necessity of direct, real-time MEP feedback for learning this control.
  • Long-Term Learning: The learned ability to control MEPs is retained for at least six months, demonstrating true, lasting neuroplastic changes.
  • Mechanisms Uncovered: The study links this volitional control to specific neurophysiological changes:
  • Increased Late Cortical Disinhibition (LCD): This is a key finding, suggesting altered presynaptic GABAB inhibition is involved, particularly during the UP state.
  • Gamma Power Increase & Alpha/Theta Decrease: The UP state is associated with heightened gamma oscillations and reduced alpha and theta power in the trained hemisphere. This suggests a shift towards a more active, processing-ready state.
  • Hemispheric Specificity (and Spillover): While the primary effects are in the trained hemisphere, there's evidence of some cross-hemispheric influence, particularly in theta oscillations, reflecting the interconnectedness of motor networks.

Key Results

  • Significant MEP Modulation: Participants could robustly increase MEP amplitudes by 83.8% (UP condition) and decrease them by 30.6% (DOWN condition) compared to baseline.
  • Retention: The ability to modulate MEPs was retained for at least 6 months.
  • Feedback-Free Performance: Participants could still upregulate and downregulate MEPs even when the real-time feedback was removed, indicating optimized mental strategies.
  • Neurophysiological Signatures:
    • LCD: Significantly increased in the UP condition compared to baseline and the DOWN condition.
  • Oscillations: Significant differences in relative power were observed between UP and DOWN states for delta, theta, low alpha, high alpha, low gamma, and high gamma bands.
  • EEG Classification: A linear support vector machine could classify UP vs. DOWN brain states with an average accuracy of 81.5% based on EEG data. High Gamma and High Alpha were identified as key features.

Limitations and Future Work

  • LCD Measurement Nuances: The authors acknowledge that LCD measurement can be sensitive to parameters and may not be observed in all individuals or under all conditions, suggesting further research with optimized parameters is needed.
  • Beta Band Absence: The lack of significant modulation in the beta band, a prominent sensorimotor rhythm, is noted. This might be due to the specific mental strategies used or the lack of temporal structure in the analysis.
  • Future Directions: The paper strongly advocates for the use of this TMS-neurofeedback approach in neurorehabilitation, particularly for stroke patients. The ability to individually tailor up- or down-regulation for specific hemispheres could be a powerful tool for promoting recovery. Further research is also suggested to explore the role of I-wave mechanisms and to refine the understanding of how these altered brain states influence motor performance and recovery.

Summary updated

Abstract

To date there exists no reliable method to non-invasively upregulate or downregulate the state of the resting human motor system over a large dynamic range. Here we show that an operant conditioning paradigm which provides neurofeedback of the size of motor evoked potentials (MEPs) in response to transcranial magnetic stimulation (TMS), enables participants to self-modulate their own brain state. Following training, participants were able to robustly increase (by 83.8%) and decrease (by 30.6%) their MEP amplitudes. This volitional up-versus down-regulation of corticomotor excitability caused an increase of late-cortical disinhibition (LCD), a TMS derived read-out of presynaptic GABA<sub>B</sub> disinhibition, which was accompanied by an increase of gamma and a decrease of alpha oscillations in the trained hemisphere. This approach paves the way for future investigations into how altered brain state influences motor neurophysiology and recovery of function in a neurorehabilitation context.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ruddy2018neural,
  author = {Kathy Ruddy and Joshua H. Balsters and Dante Mantini and Quanying Liu and Pegah Kassraian and Nadja Enz and Ernest Mihelj and Bankim Subhash Chander and Surjo R. Soekadar and Nicole Wenderoth},
  title = {{Neural activity related to volitional regulation of cortical excitability}},
  booktitle = {eLife},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.7554/elife.40843},
}
Figure