“Net” value co-creation: The effect of interactions on consumer citizenship behavior in online travel communities

Biyu Guan, Haiquan Chen, Yunhao Liu, Rui Liu, Ailing WuFrontiers in Psychology 2022 · DOI

Abstract

Online travel communities are vital for tourism companies, but their long-term viability depends on voluntary consumer citizenship behavior (CCB), such as helping others and providing feedback. This study investigates how consumer interactions influence these behaviors through psychological mechanisms. By analyzing 593 users, the research finds that interaction strengthens self-identity and perceived social support, which in turn enhances community identification and citizenship actions. Additionally, the study highlights how symbolic and utilitarian motivations moderate these relationships, providing strategic insights for community management and value co-creation.

Introduction: The Value of Citizenship

While many online travel platforms are launched to drive direct sales, their survival is inextricably linked to "extra-role" behaviors known as Consumer Citizenship Behavior (CCB). Unlike "intra-role" behaviors like making a purchase, CCB involves voluntary actions: recommending the community to others, assisting fellow travelers with advice, and providing constructive feedback to the platform.

Most research has focused on transactional metrics like brand loyalty or purchase intention. However, true value co-creation in a community stems from these voluntary contributions. This paper explores the psychological pathways—specifically self-identity, social support, and community identification—that transform a passive user into an active, helpful "citizen."

Conceptual Framework

The researchers proposed a model where consumer interaction drives CCB through two primary psychological engines: self-identity and perceived social support. These factors lead to community identification, which acts as the final bridge to citizenship behavior.

Figure 1: The conceptual model illustrating the hypothesized relationships between interaction, psychological states, and citizenship behavior.

The model also accounts for user motivation. Symbolic motivation (seeking status) and utilitarian motivation (seeking functional information) act as filters that change how interactions are processed by the user.

Methodology and Data

The study employed Structural Equation Modeling (SEM) to test 11 hypotheses. Data was collected via a four-part questionnaire from 593 active users of major Chinese travel communities like Tripadvisor, Qyer.com, and Mafengwo.com.

Table 1: Demographic characteristics of the study participants.

As shown in the demographic breakdown, the sample was relatively balanced by gender and skewed toward highly educated young professionals (aged 26–35), reflecting the core user base of these digital platforms.

Key Findings

The analysis confirmed all 11 hypotheses, revealing several critical insights:

  • The Dual Pathway: Interaction significantly boosts both Self-Identity (β = 0.580) and Perceived Social Support (β = 0.459). When users interact, they affirm their identity as travel enthusiasts and feel cared for by the group.
  • The Power of Identification: Community identification—the feeling of belonging—is the strongest direct predictor of voluntary citizenship behavior (β = 0.408).
  • Motivation as a Filter: For those with symbolic motivation, interactions have a stronger impact on self-identity. For those with utilitarian motivation, interactions more effectively build a sense of social support.
  • Reciprocity: Drawing on Social Exchange Theory, the findings suggest that when users receive subjective support (like respect) during interactions, they feel a psychological urge to "pay it back" through citizenship.

Discussion and Limitations

These findings suggest that community managers should move beyond just encouraging participation and focus on fostering high-quality interactions that build identity and support.

However, the study has limitations. The results are specific to the experiential travel industry and may not apply to purely functional product communities. Additionally, the cross-sectional nature of the survey makes it difficult to definitively prove that interaction causes citizenship, as "good citizens" might naturally interact more. Future research should consider individual personality traits and the impact of multi-sensory community design on user engagement.

Summary updated

Abstract

Online traveling community is initiated by companies, but its survival is inextricably linked to consumer citizenship behavior (e.g., out-group recommendation, in-group helping, and inward response). The majority of researches have investigated consumer behavior of brand community such as consumer satisfaction, brand loyalty, and purchase intention. A few scholars try to explore consumer behaviors beyond the purchase, like participation, which was concerned as the value co-creation. However, the value co-creation of the community should depend on consumers' citizenship behaviors instead of their pure participation. Therefore, this study empirically examines the effect of consumer interaction on consumer psychology and citizenship behaviors of the online travel community. The findings demonstrated that consumer interaction facilitated participants' self-identity and their perceived social support, which enhanced their community identification and thus their citizenship behaviors. Furthermore, the motivation of participation plays a moderator in this process. Specifically, symbolic motivation moderates the relationship between consumer interaction and their self-identity, while utilitarian motivation moderates the effect of consumer interaction on their perceived social support. These findings contributed to the intervention of consumer citizenship behavior in online traveling community and provide insights into the management of the online travel community from the perspective of the value co-creation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{guan2022net,
  author = {Biyu Guan and Haiquan Chen and Yunhao Liu and Rui Liu and Ailing Wu},
  title = {{“Net” value co-creation: The effect of interactions on consumer citizenship behavior in online travel communities}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Psychology},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpsyg.2022.991009},
}
Figure