Abstract
Previous studies on review information evaluation focus on the important roles of two key factors namely argument strength and source credibility but pay less attention to how social influence and social relationship exert impact on this information evaluation behavior. To fill this research gap, based on the similarity – attraction theory and social capital theory, we articulate how source credibility is determined by two social relationship factors: tie strength and perceived similarity. Further, drawing upon the social influence model, we propose that the susceptibility to normative influence intensifies the impact exerted on source credibility by tie strength and perceived similarity. Also, relationships between argument strength and review helpfulness and between source credibility and review helpfulness are both moderated by normative susceptibility. A survey is conducted to test the proposed research model and the results suggest that hypotheses are supported. The results offer important and interesting insights to information systems research and practice.
Introduction
In the landscape of Electronic Word-of-Mouth (eWOM), consumers are frequently overwhelmed by a deluge of reviews. Understanding why certain reviews are perceived as "helpful" while others are ignored is a critical challenge for both researchers and platform designers. Traditional frameworks, such as the Heuristic-Systematic Model (HSM), posit that information is evaluated through two primary channels: systematic processing (the logical strength of the argument) and heuristic processing (mental shortcuts like the reviewer’s reputation).
However, as platforms like Yelp or Dianping integrate social networking features, reviewers are no longer anonymous entities. This research addresses a significant gap in the literature: how social relationships—specifically tie strength and perceived similarity—and an individual’s "normative susceptibility" (the desire to conform to social expectations) influence the processing of online reviews.
Theoretical Framework and Methodology
The researchers developed an extended model rooted in Social Capital Theory and Similarity-Attraction Theory. They introduced three primary social variables into the standard HSM framework to better capture the nuances of modern eWOM:
- Tie Strength (TS): The closeness and frequency of interaction between the reviewer and the reader.
- Perceived Similarity (PS): The degree to which a reader feels they share tastes, values, or backgrounds with the reviewer.
- Normative Susceptibility (RN): A personality trait measuring how much an individual is influenced by social norms and the expectations of others.
To test this model, the authors conducted a survey-based study using Partial Least Squares (PLS) path modeling. This approach allowed them to analyze the complex relationships between these variables and their ultimate impact on perceived "Review Helpfulness."
Study Design and Data
The study focused on Dianping.com, a leading Chinese online review platform. Data was collected from a pool of 1,000 invited participants, resulting in 230 usable responses. The sample was 61.3% female with an average age of 22, and the majority (71.7%) were experienced internet users with over six years of online activity. All constructs were measured using five-point Likert scales adapted from validated prior research to ensure reliability and validity.
Key Insights and Results
The study confirmed that credibility is not merely a product of expertise; it is deeply social. Both tie strength and perceived similarity were found to be strong antecedents of source credibility. Essentially, if a reader feels a reviewer is "like them," they are statistically more likely to trust the source before even engaging with the content of the review.
The Role of Normative Susceptibility
The most significant finding involves the role of Normative Susceptibility (RN), which acts as a "master switch" for information processing:
- High Susceptibility Group: These individuals rely heavily on heuristic cues. For this group, Source Credibility was a major driver of helpfulness ($\beta = 0.305$), while the actual Argument Strength was statistically insignificant ($\beta = 0.137$).
- Low Susceptibility Group: These individuals are more independent thinkers who prioritize systematic processing. For them, Argument Strength was the primary driver of helpfulness ($\beta = 0.269$), while Source Credibility became insignificant ($\beta = 0.134$).
Furthermore, the results suggest a "bias effect" where heuristic cues can color systematic processing. A highly credible source can make a mediocre argument appear stronger than it is, particularly for those prone to social conformity.
Conclusion and Limitations
This research demonstrates that social relationships and personality traits significantly bias our perception of information. While the study provides a robust framework, the authors note several limitations. The findings are based on a single platform (Dianping.com) in a specific cultural context, which may limit generalizability to Western platforms like Amazon. Additionally, while normative susceptibility was a powerful moderator, other traits like the "need for cognition" remain unexplored. Future research should investigate how these social factors interact across different product categories, such as luxury goods versus daily necessities.
Summary updated