Abstract
Little empirical research has been conducted to demonstrate the role of electronic word-of-mouth (eWOM) in brand value co-creation or brand trust change. Furthermore, whether this brand value co-creation and brand trust change resulting from social networking site (SNS)-based brand eWOM actually lead to consumers’ purchase decision-making is largely unknown. This study addresses these literature gaps through empirical research based on See-To and Ho’s (2014) model, which theorizes the inter-relationship between value co-creation, brand trust, and eWOM.
Introduction
In the era of social networking sites (SNSs), consumers have evolved from passive recipients of marketing messages into active participants who "co-create" value. Through electronic word-of-mouth (eWOM), users share personal stories, provide feedback, and assist others, forming a dynamic brand narrative. While marketers recognize the importance of eWOM, the specific mechanisms by which these digital narratives trigger value co-creation and shifts in brand trust—and whether these changes ultimately drive sales—remain under-explored. This study investigates how the valence of brand stories shared on social media influences a consumer's willingness to engage in value co-creation and how these interactions impact brand trust and purchase intentions.
Methodology
The researchers conducted an online survey with 237 undergraduate students at a university in the Southeastern U.S. The study employed a multi-step analytical approach:
- Recall and Content Analysis: Participants recalled a brand story they encountered on social media. These stories were qualitatively coded as either positive (n=95) or negative (n=142).
- Psychometric Scaling: Participants completed 5-point Likert and semantic differential scales measuring brand trust change, purchase intention, and engagement in value co-creation.
- Factor Analysis: Confirmatory Factor Analysis (CFA) was used to identify four distinct dimensions of value co-creation: information sharing and feedback, advocacy, helping, and personal interaction.
- Structural Equation Modeling (SEM): The authors used SEM to test the causal paths between eWOM valence, the four co-creation factors, trust change, and purchase intention.
Results and Discussion
The analysis revealed that eWOM is a powerful narrative tool capable of shifting brand trust and driving engagement. Key findings include:
- The Impact of eWOM Valence: Positive eWOM had significant positive effects on all four co-creation factors (personal interaction $\beta=.26$; info sharing $\beta=.21$; advocacy $\beta=.31$; helping $\beta=.20$) and brand trust change ($\beta=.58, p < .001$).
- The Power of Advocacy: Not all engagement is equal. While positive eWOM encourages various forms of interaction, only advocacy (recommending or defending the brand) significantly and positively influenced purchase intention ($\beta=.31, p < .001$). This suggests that taking the social risk of recommending a brand reinforces a consumer's internal commitment.
- Trust as a Gatekeeper: Brand trust change was a strong predictor of purchase intention ($\beta=.29, p < .001$). A single story on a social feed can significantly alter a consumer's baseline trust, which serves as a primary driver for purchase decisions.
- The "Helping" Paradox: Interestingly, the initial model showed a negative relationship between "helping" other consumers and purchase intention. This may be due to a "suppressor effect" or indicate that altruistic community behavior does not necessarily correlate with individual purchase readiness.
After refining the SEM by removing non-significant paths, the final model showed a strong fit (RMSEA = .10, TLI = .92, CFI = .94), supporting the overall theoretical framework.
Conclusion
This research highlights that while positive social media stories foster broad engagement, marketers should specifically aim to cultivate brand advocacy to drive sales. The study's findings are limited by its focus on a student demographic and reliance on self-reported recall. Future research should explore longitudinal designs to see how trust evolves over time and investigate whether these effects differ across specific platforms like Instagram, X (formerly Twitter), or TikTok.
Summary updated