Near-Optimal Multi-Robot Motion Planning with Finite Sampling

Dror Dayan, Kiril Solovey, Marco Pavone, Dan Halperin

TL;DR

This paper introduces the first finite-sample analysis for near-optimal multi-robot motion planning (MRMP). By developing a novel deterministic sampling scheme called the staggered grid, the authors provide a concrete "recipe"—specifying the exact number of samples and connection radii needed—to guarantee that a roadmap will contain a solution within a factor of $(1+\epsilon)$ of the optimal path, significantly outperforming previous theoretical bounds.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

In robotics, motion planning involves finding a collision-free path from a start to a goal. For multiple robots, this becomes exponentially harder as they must avoid not only static obstacles but also each other.

Most modern planners use "sampling-based" methods (like PRM or RRT), which are popular because they are asymptotically optimal: if you let them run forever with infinite samples, they will eventually find the best possible path. However, engineers working in the real world can't wait forever. They need to know: How many samples do I need right now to guarantee a high-quality path?

Previous research into "finite-sample" guarantees was either limited to single robots or produced extremely conservative bounds that required an impractical number of samples. This paper bridges the gap between theoretical "infinite-time" guarantees and practical "finite-time" implementation for multi-robot systems.

Methods

The authors focus on the Tensor Roadmap (TR), a structure created by taking the mathematical "tensor product" of individual robot roadmaps. Their approach involves three key components:

  1. Staggered Grid Sampling: A new deterministic sampling method. Instead of a standard square grid, it uses two interleaved grids. This provides better "coverage" of the space with fewer points. The staggered grid uses two interleaved layers to cover the configuration space more efficiently than a standard grid.

  2. Finite-Sample Analysis: The authors derive new mathematical proofs to determine the relationship between the desired path quality (stretch factor $\epsilon$), the safety margin (clearance $\delta$), the number of samples, and the connection radius.

  3. Extension to Multi-Robot Systems: They extend the single-robot analysis to the multi-robot case, accounting for the complex interactions that occur when multiple robots move simultaneously through a shared space.
The staggered grid uses two interleaved layers to cover the configuration space more efficiently than a standard grid.

Datasets (Test Scenarios)

The authors evaluated their theory using four synthetic benchmark scenarios for disc-shaped robots in a 2D plane:

  • 2-Robot Obstacle-Free: A baseline to compare against known optimal coordinated trajectories.
  • 2-Robot Spiral: A complex workspace requiring tight coordination to navigate a spiral obstacle.
  • 4-Robot Circle: Robots tightly packed inside a circular barrier, testing coordination in confined spaces.
  • 7-Robot Coordination: A larger-scale test using the MC-CBS (Multi-Constraint Conflict-Based Search) algorithm to explore the tensor roadmap.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Efficiency of Staggered Grids: The staggered grid is an "aha" moment in spatial coverage. By simply offsetting two grids, the authors achieved an exponential improvement ($1.3687^d$, where $d$ is the dimension) in the number of samples required compared to previous finite-sample methods.
  • Deterministic vs. Random: While random sampling is the industry standard, this paper shows that deterministic staggered grids provide a 100% success rate in finding a solution (if one exists with sufficient clearance), whereas random sampling can fail frequently at low sample counts.
  • Conservative Theory vs. Practical Reality: A major insight is that while the theoretical bounds are much tighter than before, they are still conservative. In practice, the algorithms achieved near-optimal results with far fewer samples than the theory strictly required.

Key Results

  • Sample Complexity Reduction: The new bounds consistently require at least one order of magnitude fewer samples than previous finite-sample theories (see Table I). Comparison of sample sizes: |Xcurr| (this work) is consistently smaller than |Xprev| (previous work).

  • High Path Quality: In experiments, the actual approximation factor was significantly lower than the theoretical $1+\epsilon$ limit. For example, setting $\epsilon=50$ (a very loose theoretical bound) still resulted in paths within 7.5% of the optimal length.

  • Reliability: The staggered grid outperformed random sampling in both success rate and path cost for small sample sets, making it a robust choice for time-constrained applications.
Comparison of sample sizes: |Xcurr| (this work) is consistently smaller than |Xprev| (previous work).

Limitations and Future Work

  • The Curse of Dimensionality: Even with the exponential improvement, the number of samples required still grows exponentially with the number of robots and their degrees of freedom. Planning for dozens of complex robots remains a massive computational challenge.
  • Search Scalability: While the roadmap can be constructed, searching through the resulting massive multi-robot graph (the Tensor Roadmap) is computationally expensive. The authors suggest that more effective search methods or learning-based sampling distributions could be a promising next step.
  • Time-Based Metrics: The current work focuses on path length. Future research could extend this to minimize total travel time or account for robot dynamics.

Summary updated

Abstract

An underlying structure in several sampling-based methods for continuous multi-robot motion planning (MRMP) is the tensor roadmap (TR), which emerges from combining multiple PRM graphs constructed for the individual robots via a tensor product. We study the conditions under which the TR encodes a near-optimal solution for MRMP -- satisfying these conditions implies near optimality for a variety of popular planners, including dRRT*, and the discrete methods M* and CBS when applied to the continuous domain. We develop the first finite-sample analysis of this kind, which specifies the number of samples, their deterministic distribution, and magnitude of the connection radii that should be used by each individual PRM graph, to guarantee near-optimality using the TR. This significantly improves upon a previous asymptotic analysis, wherein the number of samples tends to infinity. Our new finite sample-size analysis supports guaranteed high-quality solutions in practice within finite time. To achieve our new result, we first develop a sampling scheme, which we call the staggered grid, for finite-sample motion planning for individual robots, which requires significantly fewer samples than previous work. We then extend it to the much more involved MRMP setting which requires to account for interactions among multiple robots. Finally, we report on a few experiments that serve as a verification of our theoretical findings and raise interesting questions for further investigation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dayan2021near,
  author = {Dror Dayan and Kiril Solovey and Marco Pavone and Dan Halperin},
  title = {{Near-Optimal Multi-Robot Motion Planning with Finite Sampling}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=5uPk1BiHMEL},
}
Figure