Near-Optimal Multi-Robot Motion Planning with Finite Sampling

Dror Dayan, Kiril Solovey, Marco Pavone, Dan Halperin

Introduction

Multi-robot motion planning (MRMP) involves navigating multiple agents through a shared environment without collisions. Traditional sampling-based planners, such as PRM or RRT, typically guarantee asymptotic optimality, meaning they find the shortest path only as the number of samples approaches infinity. However, practical applications require performance guarantees within a finite timeframe. This research introduces a deterministic "recipe" for MRMP that ensures near-optimal solutions using a finite number of samples.

The Staggered Grid Sampling Scheme

A core contribution of this work is the "staggered grid" sampling method. Unlike random sampling or standard uniform grids, the staggered grid consists of two interleaved square grids. This geometric arrangement provides a more efficient "covering" of the configuration space, requiring fewer points to ensure that any point in the space is within a specific distance of a sample.

The staggered grid sampling scheme consists of two interleaved square grids to optimize space coverage.

By utilizing this deterministic approach, the authors achieve an exponential improvement in sample efficiency—specifically a factor of $1.3687^d$ (where $d$ is the dimension) over previous finite-sample methods. This efficiency is critical in high-dimensional multi-robot state spaces.

Tensor Roadmap (TR) Analysis

The authors extend single-robot finite-sample analysis to the multi-robot domain through Tensor Roadmaps (TR). By constructing individual roadmaps for each robot using the staggered grid and specific connection radii, the resulting tensor product of these graphs is guaranteed to contain a path that is at most $(1+\epsilon)$ times longer than the optimal path. This provides a theoretical bridge allowing discrete search algorithms, like Conflict-Based Search (CBS), to be applied to continuous spaces with rigorous optimality guarantees.

Results and Performance

The proposed method was validated through various simulation scenarios, ranging from simple 2-robot benchmarks to complex 7-robot coordination tasks. Key findings include:

  1. Sample Efficiency: The staggered grid significantly reduces the number of samples required compared to previous deterministic methods.
  2. Success Rate: The method maintained a 100% success rate in finding valid paths, outperforming random sampling in constrained environments.
  3. Path Quality: While theoretical bounds might be conservative, empirical results showed that found paths were often within 1-5% of the optimal, even when the theoretical guarantee was much looser.
Sample counts for different dimensions (d), clearance (delta), and optimality factors (epsilon) comparing the current method to previous approaches.

As shown in the table above, the number of samples ($|X_{curr}|$) required by the new scheme is consistently lower than previous methods ($|X_{prev}|$) across various dimensions and optimality requirements.

Limitations and Future Directions

Despite its efficiency, the method still faces the "curse of dimensionality," as sample requirements grow exponentially with the number of robots. Current multi-robot search algorithms also struggle with the large roadmaps generated by strict theoretical bounds. Future work aims to incorporate learning-based sampling to focus points in critical areas and extend the theory to non-holonomic systems, such as wheeled vehicles with turning constraints.

Summary updated

Abstract

An underlying structure in several sampling-based methods for continuous multirobot motion planning (MRMP) is the <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">tensor roadmap</i> , which emerges from combining multiple probabilistic roadmap (PRM) graphs constructed for the individual robots via a tensor product. We study the conditions under which the tensor roadmap encodes a near-optimal solution for MRMP—satisfying these conditions implies near optimality for a variety of popular planners, including dRRT*, and the discrete methods M* and conflict-based search, when applied to the continuous domain. We develop the first finite-sample analysis of this kind, which specifies the number of samples, their deterministic distribution, and magnitude of the connection radii that should be used by each individual PRM graph, to guarantee near-optimality using the tensor roadmap. This significantly improves upon a previous asymptotic analysis, wherein the number of samples tends to infinity. Our new finite sample-size analysis supports guaranteed high-quality solutions in practice within finite time. To achieve our new result, we first develop a sampling scheme, which we call the <italic xmlns:mml="http://www.w3.org/1998/Math/MathML" xmlns:xlink="http://www.w3.org/1999/xlink">staggered grid</i> , for finite-sample motion planning for individual robots, which requires significantly fewer samples than previous work. We then extend it to the much more involved MRMP setting, which requires to account for interactions among multiple robots. Finally, we report on a few experiments that serve as a verification of our theoretical findings and raise interesting questions for further investigation.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{dayan2021near,
  author = {Dror Dayan and Kiril Solovey and Marco Pavone and Dan Halperin},
  title = {{Near-Optimal Multi-Robot Motion Planning with Finite Sampling}},
  booktitle = {IEEE International Conference on Robotics and Automation},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=5uPk1BiHMEL},
}
Figure