Multi-robot motion planning for unit discs with revolving areas

Pankaj K. Agarwal, Tzvika Geft, Dan Halperin, Erin Taylor

TL;DR

This paper tackles the complex problem of planning collision-free paths for multiple robots (modeled as discs) in a shared environment, focusing on minimizing the total distance traveled. They introduce a novel approach that guarantees a feasible plan with a total distance within a constant factor of the optimal, even for an online setting where robot tasks arrive sequentially.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Coordinating multiple robots to move from their starting positions to their target positions without colliding is a fundamental challenge in robotics. This problem, known as Multi-Robot Motion Planning (MRMP), becomes particularly difficult when robots are indistinguishable (labeled) and must move in a continuous space, especially when aiming for optimal solutions that minimize total travel distance. Existing methods often struggle with scalability, optimality guarantees, or handling dynamic environments. This paper addresses the MRMP problem for labeled unit disc robots in a polygonal environment, with the added complexity of "revolving areas" around start and end points. These revolving areas provide some flexibility but also introduce new challenges. The core problem is to find a set of paths for all robots that are collision-free and minimize the sum of their individual path lengths.

Methods

The paper presents a three-stage algorithm for computing a feasible, weakly-monotone motion plan.

  1. Initial Path Computation: The algorithm first computes individual shortest paths for each robot, ignoring potential collisions with other robots. This is done using standard algorithms for shortest paths among curved obstacles.
  2. Path Modification (Avoiding Cores): Each robot's path is then modified to ensure it doesn't enter the "core" of any revolving area occupied by another robot. This involves replacing segments of the path that intersect a core with arcs along the core's boundary.
  3. Retraction and Collision Avoidance: This is the most novel stage. When a robot is "active" (moving from its start to its target), other non-active robots are "retracted" within their revolving areas to avoid collisions. The paper introduces a sophisticated retraction mechanism that ensures robots stay within their designated areas while allowing the active robot to move. This retraction is carefully designed to minimize the added path length for the non-active robots.

The algorithm also addresses the problem of finding an optimal ordering of robot movements to minimize the cost incurred by the retraction process, reducing it to a weighted feedback arc set problem.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and algorithmic development for a general polygonal environment.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Weakly-Monotone Motion Plans: The concept of "weakly-monotone" motion plans is crucial. It allows robots to move fully from start to end during their turn, while others remain in their revolving areas. This simplifies analysis and enables constant-factor approximations.
  • Revolving Areas as a Trade-off: While revolving areas offer flexibility for robots to maneuver and avoid collisions, they also introduce complexity in ensuring paths remain feasible and optimal. The paper shows that even with these areas, the problem remains challenging.
  • APX-Hardness for Optimal MRMP: A significant theoretical result is proving that finding an optimal weakly-monotone motion plan is APX-hard. This implies that no polynomial-time algorithm can guarantee a solution within a (1+ε) factor of the optimum for any ε > 0.
  • Constant-Factor Approximation for Feasible Plans: Despite the hardness of optimality, the paper achieves a breakthrough by providing the first constant-factor approximation algorithm for computing a feasible weakly-monotone motion plan. This means the total distance traveled is guaranteed to be within a small constant multiple of the optimal solution.
  • Online Adaptability: The algorithm's design, particularly its reliance on robot ordering and retraction, allows it to be adapted for online settings where robot tasks arrive sequentially, offering a constant competitive ratio.
  • Decomposition of Marginal Cost: The paper demonstrates that the additional cost incurred by editing paths to avoid collisions can be decomposed based on pairwise robot interactions, which is key to finding a good ordering.

Key Results

  • NP-Hardness of Optimal MRMP-RA: The problem of finding an optimal weakly-monotone motion plan for robots with revolving areas is NP-hard.
  • APX-Hardness of Optimal MRMP-RA: The problem is even APX-hard, ruling out efficient (1+ε)-approximation algorithms for optimality.
  • O(1)-Approximation Algorithm: The paper presents the first constant-factor approximation algorithm for computing a feasible weakly-monotone motion plan. The total distance traveled by the robots is guaranteed to be within a constant factor of the optimal solution, even if the optimal solution is not weakly-monotone.
  • O(log n log log n)-Approximation for Ordering: An algorithm is provided to find a good ordering of robot movements that minimizes the overhead cost due to path editing, achieving an O(log n log log n) approximation ratio.
  • Polynomial Time Complexity: The main approximation algorithm runs in O(n(m+n) logm) time, where n is the number of robots and m is the complexity of the environment.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Optimality vs. Feasibility: While the paper provides a constant-factor approximation for feasible weakly-monotone plans, achieving true optimality (minimizing total distance) remains APX-hard.
  • Revolving Area Size: The paper assumes a fixed radius of 2 for revolving areas. It would be interesting to explore how the problem changes with different or variable revolving area sizes, or if these bounds can be tightened.
  • Other Objectives: The current work focuses on minimizing the sum of distances. Future work could explore other objectives like makespan (latest arrival time), which is known to be challenging even for simpler scenarios.
  • General Robot Shapes: The current work is for unit disc robots. Extending these results to robots with more complex shapes would be a significant advancement.
  • Dynamic Environments: While the algorithm is adaptable to online task arrival, handling truly dynamic environments with moving obstacles or unpredictable events remains an open challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

We study the problem of motion planning for a collection of $n$ labeled unit disc robots in a polygonal environment. We assume that the robots have revolving areas around their start and final positions: that each start and each final is contained in a radius $2$ disc lying in the free space, not necessarily concentric with the start or final position, which is free from other start or final positions. This assumption allows a weakly-monotone motion plan, in which robots move according to an ordering as follows: during the turn of a robot $R$ in the ordering, it moves fully from its start to final position, while other robots do not leave their revolving areas. As $R$ passes through a revolving area, a robot $R'$ that is inside this area may move within the revolving area to avoid a collision. Notwithstanding the existence of a motion plan, we show that minimizing the total traveled distance in this setting, specifically even when the motion plan is restricted to be weakly-monotone, is APX-hard, ruling out any polynomial-time $(1+ε)$-approximation algorithm. On the positive side, we present the first constant-factor approximation algorithm for computing a feasible weakly-monotone motion plan. The total distance traveled by the robots is within an $O(1)$ factor of that of the optimal motion plan, which need not be weakly monotone. Our algorithm extends to an online setting in which the polygonal environment is fixed but the initial and final positions of robots are specified in an online manner. Finally, we observe that the overhead in the overall cost that we add while editing the paths to avoid robot-robot collision can vary significantly depending on the ordering we chose. Finding the best ordering in this respect is known to be NP-hard, and we provide a polynomial time $O(\log n \log \log n)$-approximation algorithm for this problem.
BibTeX
@article{agarwal2023multi,
  author = {Pankaj K. Agarwal and Tzvika Geft and Dan Halperin and Erin Taylor},
  title = {{Multi-robot motion planning for unit discs with revolving areas}},
  journal = {Comput. Geom},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.1016/j.comgeo.2023.102019},
}

Loading related content...

Figure